AI summary by TwinMind

The Fencing Of The Commons | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

43m 3s

Introduction and Medieval Commons System

  • Podcast hosts Josh and Chuck discuss fencing the commons, related to tragedy of the commons episode
  • Process of separating/extracting land from commoners who formerly used it
  • Some historians argue this created wealth inequality, wage labor, and problematic features of modern world
  • Self-interested powerful group pulled off massive land grab in England

Norman Conquest and Manor System (1066)

  • William the Conqueror established feudal system after conquering England
  • Wealthy nobles received all land divided into manors
  • Manor lords had allegiance to king, owned:
    • Manor house
    • Peasant village
    • Great farmland worked by peasants
    • Commons shared by commoners
  • Commoners had usufructory rights - legal right to use/work land and take products for sustenance
  • System worked well for several centuries

Medieval Farming System

  • Land divided into strips within fields
  • One field: meadow for sheep/cattle grazing
  • Other fields: crop land in long thin strips
  • Each strip belonged to different person
  • Strips distributed across fields to ensure fair soil quality
  • Crop rotation system every few years
  • Meadow field fertilized by animal waste, became crop land next rotation
  • Straight strips due to difficult-to-turn plows
  • Shared oxen for plowing
  • Collective farming decisions - all had to farm simultaneously
  • Democratic local council elected annually to allocate strips and set fees
  • Income cap system - wealthy commoners had to leave
  • Some landless people worked as hired farm hands but had access to waste resources

The Waste and Early Legal Changes

  • "Waste" = forest areas for hunting, fishing, gathering peat and wood
  • Valuable resource despite name
  • 1235: Statute of Merton allowed manor lords to enclose land legally
  • Required leaving plenty of common land for peasants
  • Little attention paid for ~100 years

Black Death Impact (Mid-14th Century)

  • Up to half of England's population died from plague
  • Created labor shortage, gave peasants bargaining power
  • Reduced food needs due to population decline
  • Shift toward sheep grazing for wool trade - more profitable than farming
  • Sheep required less labor but more land
  • Wealthy landowners increasingly pursued enclosure following Statute of Merton
  • Armed displacement of villages for sheep grazing
  • First wave of enclosure (14th-15th centuries) driven by expensive wool prices

Physical Enclosure Methods

  • Literal fencing to contain sheep
  • Hedges grown thick with vines and brambles
  • Hedges became part of British culture, now protected landmarks

Legal Requirements vs. Reality

  • Officially required unanimous consent of all stakeholders
  • In practice:
    • Sometimes just taken by force
    • Sometimes forced relocation to less fertile land
    • Sometimes completely illegal seizure
  • Enclosure proponents often in Parliament or friends with MPs
  • Supermajority approval came from same social class

Opposition and Criticism

  • Thomas More's "Utopia" (1516) called sheep "great devourers" of communities
  • Henry VIII initially slowed enclosures to preserve peasantry
  • Massive waves of violence throughout centuries
  • 1381 peasants' revolt partially about enclosure
  • English Civil War: Diggers (radical faction of Levelers) opposed enclosure
  • Diggers believed British birth = birthright to British soil
  • "The Blacks" - commoners who poached deer and destroyed trees
  • Black Act imposed death penalty for poaching - hundreds hanged

Fens Battle

  • Fens = vast marshy areas of England
  • Wealthy wanted to drain for crop land
  • Peasants argued they used the land productively
  • Wealthy portrayed as "waste land" and peasants as "lazy"
  • Peasants claimed higher income from fens than city work
  • Peasants successfully defended fens through most of 1700s but ultimately lost

Parliamentary Enclosure Era (1750-1860)

  • Government officially endorsed enclosure through Parliament
  • ~4,000 parliamentary acts passed between 1750-1860
  • ~11,000 square miles enclosed (1/5 of England)
  • Required petition to Parliament and local supermajority approval
  • Same people seeking enclosure were in Parliament or connected to MPs

Agricultural Revolution Innovations

  • Norfolk four-course system (Lord Townshend "Turnip"):
    • Wheat, turnips, barley, clover rotation
    • Clover good for grazing, bees, soil
    • Turnips fed livestock
    • No need for fallow fields
  • Jethro Tull's seed drill enabled long straight row planting
  • Coincided with Industrial Revolution
  • Created efficient agricultural system to feed growing urban workforce

Forced Urbanization

  • Displaced peasants legally considered "vagrants" (criminal status)
  • Forced to move to cities and work in factories
  • Had to buy food from land they were forced off
  • Wages rose but work was dangerous and intense
  • Possible increased malnutrition based on height/weight data
  • Population doubled 1750-1850

Critics and Resistance

  • Arthur Young (Secretary of Board of Agriculture) initially pro-enclosure
  • 1801 report warned of drying villages and impoverished commoners
  • Board rejected report
  • ~350 English villages vanished during parliamentary enclosure period
  • Chartists bought enclosed lands to return to crop production
  • 70,000 members but went bankrupt - couldn't acquire land fast enough

Global Impact and Expansion

  • British Empire exported enclosure to colonies
  • Scotland: Highland Clearances displaced thousands
  • Russia 1861: Alexander II ended serfdom, implemented similar system
  • Contributed to Russian Revolution
  • Colonial expansion for raw materials to feed industrial machine

End of Enclosure (1860s-1876)

  • Wealthy urban middle class wanted parkland for recreation
  • Commons Preservation Society gained Parliamentary influence
  • 1876 Commons Act required public benefit for enclosure
  • Commons Preservation Society became National Trust
  • Irony: Now protects hedges that originally created enclosure

Modern Remnants

  • Few commons still exist:
    • Laxton, North Nottinghamshire: open field system with strips
    • Oxford Freeman guild owns town meadow for grazing and fishing
  • National Trust protects historical enclosure hedges from removal

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome