AI summary by TwinMind
The Fencing Of The Commons | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
43m 3s
Introduction and Medieval Commons System
- Podcast hosts Josh and Chuck discuss fencing the commons, related to tragedy of the commons episode
- Process of separating/extracting land from commoners who formerly used it
- Some historians argue this created wealth inequality, wage labor, and problematic features of modern world
- Self-interested powerful group pulled off massive land grab in England
Norman Conquest and Manor System (1066)
- William the Conqueror established feudal system after conquering England
- Wealthy nobles received all land divided into manors
- Manor lords had allegiance to king, owned:
- Manor house
- Peasant village
- Great farmland worked by peasants
- Commons shared by commoners
- Commoners had usufructory rights - legal right to use/work land and take products for sustenance
- System worked well for several centuries
Medieval Farming System
- Land divided into strips within fields
- One field: meadow for sheep/cattle grazing
- Other fields: crop land in long thin strips
- Each strip belonged to different person
- Strips distributed across fields to ensure fair soil quality
- Crop rotation system every few years
- Meadow field fertilized by animal waste, became crop land next rotation
- Straight strips due to difficult-to-turn plows
- Shared oxen for plowing
- Collective farming decisions - all had to farm simultaneously
- Democratic local council elected annually to allocate strips and set fees
- Income cap system - wealthy commoners had to leave
- Some landless people worked as hired farm hands but had access to waste resources
The Waste and Early Legal Changes
- "Waste" = forest areas for hunting, fishing, gathering peat and wood
- Valuable resource despite name
- 1235: Statute of Merton allowed manor lords to enclose land legally
- Required leaving plenty of common land for peasants
- Little attention paid for ~100 years
Black Death Impact (Mid-14th Century)
- Up to half of England's population died from plague
- Created labor shortage, gave peasants bargaining power
- Reduced food needs due to population decline
- Shift toward sheep grazing for wool trade - more profitable than farming
- Sheep required less labor but more land
- Wealthy landowners increasingly pursued enclosure following Statute of Merton
- Armed displacement of villages for sheep grazing
- First wave of enclosure (14th-15th centuries) driven by expensive wool prices
Physical Enclosure Methods
- Literal fencing to contain sheep
- Hedges grown thick with vines and brambles
- Hedges became part of British culture, now protected landmarks
Legal Requirements vs. Reality
- Officially required unanimous consent of all stakeholders
- In practice:
- Sometimes just taken by force
- Sometimes forced relocation to less fertile land
- Sometimes completely illegal seizure
- Enclosure proponents often in Parliament or friends with MPs
- Supermajority approval came from same social class
Opposition and Criticism
- Thomas More's "Utopia" (1516) called sheep "great devourers" of communities
- Henry VIII initially slowed enclosures to preserve peasantry
- Massive waves of violence throughout centuries
- 1381 peasants' revolt partially about enclosure
- English Civil War: Diggers (radical faction of Levelers) opposed enclosure
- Diggers believed British birth = birthright to British soil
- "The Blacks" - commoners who poached deer and destroyed trees
- Black Act imposed death penalty for poaching - hundreds hanged
Fens Battle
- Fens = vast marshy areas of England
- Wealthy wanted to drain for crop land
- Peasants argued they used the land productively
- Wealthy portrayed as "waste land" and peasants as "lazy"
- Peasants claimed higher income from fens than city work
- Peasants successfully defended fens through most of 1700s but ultimately lost
Parliamentary Enclosure Era (1750-1860)
- Government officially endorsed enclosure through Parliament
- ~4,000 parliamentary acts passed between 1750-1860
- ~11,000 square miles enclosed (1/5 of England)
- Required petition to Parliament and local supermajority approval
- Same people seeking enclosure were in Parliament or connected to MPs
Agricultural Revolution Innovations
- Norfolk four-course system (Lord Townshend "Turnip"):
- Wheat, turnips, barley, clover rotation
- Clover good for grazing, bees, soil
- Turnips fed livestock
- No need for fallow fields
- Jethro Tull's seed drill enabled long straight row planting
- Coincided with Industrial Revolution
- Created efficient agricultural system to feed growing urban workforce
Forced Urbanization
- Displaced peasants legally considered "vagrants" (criminal status)
- Forced to move to cities and work in factories
- Had to buy food from land they were forced off
- Wages rose but work was dangerous and intense
- Possible increased malnutrition based on height/weight data
- Population doubled 1750-1850
Critics and Resistance
- Arthur Young (Secretary of Board of Agriculture) initially pro-enclosure
- 1801 report warned of drying villages and impoverished commoners
- Board rejected report
- ~350 English villages vanished during parliamentary enclosure period
- Chartists bought enclosed lands to return to crop production
- 70,000 members but went bankrupt - couldn't acquire land fast enough
Global Impact and Expansion
- British Empire exported enclosure to colonies
- Scotland: Highland Clearances displaced thousands
- Russia 1861: Alexander II ended serfdom, implemented similar system
- Contributed to Russian Revolution
- Colonial expansion for raw materials to feed industrial machine
End of Enclosure (1860s-1876)
- Wealthy urban middle class wanted parkland for recreation
- Commons Preservation Society gained Parliamentary influence
- 1876 Commons Act required public benefit for enclosure
- Commons Preservation Society became National Trust
- Irony: Now protects hedges that originally created enclosure
Modern Remnants
- Few commons still exist:
- Laxton, North Nottinghamshire: open field system with strips
- Oxford Freeman guild owns town meadow for grazing and fishing
- National Trust protects historical enclosure hedges from removal
