AI summary by TwinMind
The five most promising ways to quantize gravity
Sabine Hossenfelder
7m 19s
Introduction and Problem Statement
- Quantum gravity currently one of biggest unsolved problems in foundations of physics
- Many colleagues think quantum gravity will remain academic curiosity without practical relevance
- Speaker disagrees - whatever solves this will reveal something about quantum theory
- Quantum theory underlies all modern electronic devices
- May take 100-1000 years for practical applications, but understanding nature better won't remain academic speculation
- Clarification: quantizing gravity itself not the problem
- Can quantize gravity same way as other interactions
- Problem: resulting theory breaks down at high energies, cannot be fundamental
- Naive quantization called "perturbatively quantized gravity"
- Worked out in 1960s by Feynman, DeWitt, and others
- Widely believed to be approximation to correct theory
- Real problem: quantize gravity AND get theory that doesn't break down at high energies
- High energies proportional to frequencies
- High energies called "ultraviolet" or "UV"
- Sought theory must be "UV complete"
Five Popular Approaches to Quantum Gravity
1. String Theory
- Most widely known and still most popular attempt for UV complete quantum gravity theory
- Core idea: instead of quantizing particles, quantize strings
- Amazing consequence: strings automatically exchange force with same properties as gravitational force
- Discovered in 1970s, got physicists very excited
- Problems in past decades:
- Several problems occurred that were "fixed"
- Made theory increasingly contrived
- Never been proved that string theory is indeed UV complete
2. Loop Quantum Gravity
- Often named as biggest competitor to string theory
- Comparison somewhat misleading:
- String theory supposed to unify all interactions
- Loop quantum gravity only about quantizing gravity
- Method: discretizes space in terms of network
- Uses integrals around small loops to describe space (hence name)
- Nodes represent volumes
- Links between nodes represent areas of surfaces where volumes meet
- About as old as string theory
- Solves problem of combining general relativity and quantum mechanics into consistent theory
- Major issue: remains unclear exactly how one recovers general relativity in this approach
3. Asymptotically Safe Gravity
- Asymptotic safety idea goes back to 1976 paper by Steven Weinberg
- Core concept: theory seeming to have problems at high energies when quantized naively may not have problem after all
- Just more complicated to find out what happens at high energies
- Asymptotically safe gravity applies this idea to gravity
- Also solves problem of quantum gravity
- Major shortcoming: not been proven that theory obtained this way at high energies still makes sense as quantum theory
4. Causal Dynamical Triangulation
- Problem with quantizing gravity comes from infinities appearing when particles interact at very short distances
- Most approaches rely on removing short distances using objects of finite extensions
- Loop quantum gravity works this way
- String theory works this way
- Causal dynamical triangulation also removes short distances
- Method: approximates curved space with triangles or higher dimensional counterparts
- Key difference from other approaches:
- Other approaches: finite extension is postulated new property of underlying true nature of space
- CDT: finite size of triangles is mathematical aid, eventually takes limit where size goes to zero
- Major reason many remain unconvinced: treats space and time differently (Einstein taught us not to do this)
5. Emergent Gravity
- Not one specific theory but class of approaches
- Common feature: gravity derives from collective behavior of large number of constituents
- Much like laws of thermodynamics
- Like thermodynamics: don't need to know exact properties of constituents to get dynamical law
- If gravity is emergent, quantizing gravity doesn't make sense
- Analogy: don't get theory for structure of atoms by quantizing equations for gases
- Instead of quantizing gravity: removes inconsistency between gravity and quantum mechanics by saying quantizing gravity is wrong thing to do
Conclusion
- Which theory is right: no one knows
- Problem: really hard to find experimental evidence for quantum gravity
- Hard doesn't mean impossible
- Future discussion planned on how to experimentally test quantum gravity
