AI summary by TwinMind
The Future Will Be Shaped by Optimists | Kevin Kelly | TED
TED
9m 53s
Introduction: The Case for Optimism Despite Global Challenges
- Speaker argues for optimism despite tremendous global problems
- Climate change seems almost impossible to solve
- Social inequality appears endemic and difficult to eliminate
- Scale of problems provides more reason for optimism
- Historical breakthroughs required strong sense of optimism
- Example: first airplanes
- Belief in possibility necessary for achievement
- No guarantee belief ensures success
- Without belief, nothing happens inadvertently
- Need to imagine desired world and believe we can make it happen
- History shaped by optimists; future requires optimism
Defining Pro-topia vs Utopia
- Target world is not perfect/utopia
- "Pro-topia": world where things are little bit better
- Optimism = perspective expecting slightly more good than bad
- More reasons to hope than fear
- Not sunny temperament or blindness to problems
- Not Pollyanna self-delusion
Historical Evidence for Optimism
- Optimism based on fact of historical progress
- Scientific, rational data analysis shows evidence
- Global scale improvement over last 500 years
- Incremental improvement over time on average
Three Reasons People Don't See Progress
Reason 1: Progress is About What Doesn't Happen
- Most progress involves prevented negative events
- Examples:
- Two-year-old child not dying of smallpox
- Family farmers' surplus not stolen by raiders
- These non-events don't make headlines
Reason 2: Bad Things Happen Faster Than Good Things
- Good things take time
- News cycle compressed to 5-minute intervals
- Only bad stuff changes in 5 minutes
- Good stuff takes longer
- If newspapers updated every 100 years, very different headlines
Reason 3: Small Improvements Are Invisible in the Noise
- Societies creating few percent more good than destroyed annually
- Few percent compounds over time = civilization
- 1-2% improvement invisible in 49% "crap and destruction"
- Only visible when looking back into past
- 500 years of progress unlikely to stop tomorrow
- Very probable long-term trend continues for rest of lives
First Reason for Optimism: Alignment with Historical Progress
- Optimism makes us realists
- Aligning with long history of progress
- Historical trend likely to continue
Second Reason: Civilization Requires Trust and Collaboration
- Civilization = mechanism for improvements
- Relies on optimistically trusting others
- Collaboration with 8 billion strangers enables achievements beyond individual capacity
- Trust is type of optimism
- Can trust future generations (billions yet unborn)
- Currently benefiting from previous generations' work:
- Roads, canals, skyscrapers, telephone networks
- May enjoy more benefits than past generations when they began
- Previous generations acted as good ancestors
- Sacrificed immediate yields for future generations
Being Good Ancestors
- Want to be good ancestors
- Moving benefits to future generations = act of optimism
- Requires belief in future generations' existence
- Willingness to sacrifice immediate gains for future investment
- Enables accomplishments beyond individual present capacity
- Extends capability over time
Trusting Future Capability
- Future generations have better living standards due to progress
- More capability to solve problems:
- More knowledge
- Better tools
- Can trust future generations to solve problems we cannot
- Should be optimistic because capacity to solve problems greater than thought
- Not because problems smaller than thought
Third Reason: Problems Are Disguised Opportunities
- Optimists don't shun problems
- Optimism = embracing problems
- Problems make solutions; solutions make problems
- Most current problems generated by past solutions
- Climate change example:
- Past solution: artificial power
- Now creates current problem
- Today's solutions will generate future problems
- New solutions create many more problems
Science Analogy
- Science answers generate 2-3 new questions
- Things we didn't know we didn't know
- Science expanding ignorance faster than knowledge
- Unlimited pool of questions and problems
Problems as Progress Conduits
- Problems don't impede progress
- Problems are conduit of progress
- No problems = no progress
- Reject utopia because no problems there
- Bad things are possibilities yielding new solutions and opportunities
- Problems unlimited = no limit for improvement
- Can improve in all directions
Conclusion: Choice and Moral Obligation
- Optimism is choice, not temperament
- Can choose optimism regardless of temperament
- Gigantic problems require gigantic optimism
- Moral obligation to be optimistic
- Optimism enables:
- Shaping future
- Becoming better ancestors
- Expanding reach beyond ourselves
- Creating things bigger than ourselves
- Realist alignment with long arc of history
- Embracing problems as opportunities
- Optimism as power to create desired future
