AI summary by TwinMind

The Great War of the Worlds Panic Myth | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

45m 59s

H.G. Wells Original Novel (1898)

  • First alien invasion story ever published
  • Originally serialized in Pearson's (UK) and Cosmopolitan (US) magazines
  • Never been out of print since first edition 1898
  • Explored themes of:
    • Breakdown of rigid Victorian society
    • Human dominion over animals (humans as domesticated animals to aliens)
    • Pre-Animal Farm social commentary on treatment of animals

Orson Welles' Radio Adaptation Context (1938)

  • Great Depression era, headed toward war, uneasy feeling in US
  • Radio still new cutting-edge technology, not fully defined medium
  • Welles already famous as voice of "The Shadow"
  • Mercury Theater on CBS doing hour-long classic novel adaptations
    • Previous shows: Treasure Island, Around the World in 80 Days
  • Chose War of the Worlds for Halloween spookiness

Production Development

  • Initial script considered terrible by cast/crew
  • Production team told radio critic it would be "real stinker" that "will put everyone to sleep"
  • Key collaborators: John Houseman (partner), Howard Koch (writer)
  • Major changes made to improve quality:
    • Eliminated time passage from novel - made everything happen "right now"
    • Added documentary/news bulletin style (faux-verite)
    • Last-minute changes by Welles to shake up actors, get raw performances

Broadcast Details - October 30, 1938, 8 PM

  • Properly introduced as Mercury Theater radio play
  • Opened with musical program from "Meridian room, hotel Park Plaza"
    • Lulled listeners into thinking it was regular music broadcast
    • Late tuners missed introduction, thought listening to hotel music
  • First news bulletin at 17.5 minute mark
  • No sponsors = no commercial breaks
  • Stretched first half to 40 minutes (past normal 30-minute station break)
  • Featured realistic details:
    • Reporter asking witness to speak louder into microphone
    • Government official sounding like FDR (Secretary of Interior)
    • Grover's Mill, New Jersey as invasion site (real town)

Competing Programming

  • Chase & Sanborn Hour with Edgar Bergen/Charlie McCarthy (most popular show)
  • Channel surfing during commercial breaks led people to War of the Worlds
  • Some markets (Boston) preempted broadcast for local programming

Initial Newspaper Reports (Next Day)

  • Headlines: "Fake Radio War Stirs Terror Through U.S." (NY Daily News)
  • Stories of shock, hysteria, suicide attempts, heart attack deaths
  • AP reported Pittsburgh man found wife with poison saying "I'd rather die this way than like that"
  • NY Times: 20+ people in NY treated for shock and hysteria
  • Welles publicly apologized, claimed didn't intend panic

Hadley Cantrell's Study (Princeton, 1940)

  • Social psychologist released book on broadcast effects
  • Claimed 6 million listeners, 1/6 frightened or disturbed
  • Methodology problems:
    • Interviewed only 135 people, almost all in New Jersey
    • Selected 100 who were scared, excluded 35 who weren't
    • Extrapolated New Jersey findings to entire country
  • Study became basis for mass media/communications coursework for decades
  • Created cautionary tale narrative about media responsibility

Revisionist Period (2010s)

  • Myth debunked that America "lost its mind"
  • Real ratings showed only 2% of respondents listening during broadcast
  • New narrative: newspapers conspired against radio as competing medium
  • Claimed panic was entirely fabricated

Brad Schwartz's Research (Current Understanding)

  • Leading War of the Worlds scholar
  • Analyzed actual letters/cables sent to Welles and Mercury Theater (University of Michigan archives)
  • Found truth between extremes:
    • Some people did panic (especially in New Jersey)
    • Not widespread national hysteria
    • Less than 1/4 of letters described panic
    • Most panicked letter writers weren't angry when writing
  • Described as "first viral phenomenon in media"

Estelle Pulse Story

  • Manhattan couple spent last $6 to flee NYC by train
  • Got off in Connecticut, warned other passengers
  • Fellow passenger showed them newspaper TV listings proving it was radio play
  • Other passengers gave them money to return to NYC
  • Estelle wrote 15-page admiring letter to Welles next day

Newspaper Reaction Explanation

  • Newsrooms received 150% more calls that night
  • All calls asking about Martian invasion
  • Police also called newsrooms for information
  • Created impression of widespread panic to phone operators
  • Combined with unverified wire service reports
  • Led to lazy reporting without follow-up verification

Ecuador Incident (1948)

  • Broadcasters recreated Welles' play in Quito
  • Got other radio stations to participate
  • Real public panic occurred
  • Crowd discovered it was fiction, became angry mob
  • Burned down newspaper building with radio station
  • 6 people killed, 15 injured
  • Two broadcasters indicted for their role

Listener Mail

  • Tom from Stoke-on-Trent, UK engineer
  • Been binging show for 2 years
  • Recommends Polish mayonnaise over Japanese mayonnaise
  • Emails various people about random topics

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome