AI summary by TwinMind
The Great War of the Worlds Panic Myth | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
45m 59s
H.G. Wells Original Novel (1898)
- First alien invasion story ever published
- Originally serialized in Pearson's (UK) and Cosmopolitan (US) magazines
- Never been out of print since first edition 1898
- Explored themes of:
- Breakdown of rigid Victorian society
- Human dominion over animals (humans as domesticated animals to aliens)
- Pre-Animal Farm social commentary on treatment of animals
Orson Welles' Radio Adaptation Context (1938)
- Great Depression era, headed toward war, uneasy feeling in US
- Radio still new cutting-edge technology, not fully defined medium
- Welles already famous as voice of "The Shadow"
- Mercury Theater on CBS doing hour-long classic novel adaptations
- Previous shows: Treasure Island, Around the World in 80 Days
- Chose War of the Worlds for Halloween spookiness
Production Development
- Initial script considered terrible by cast/crew
- Production team told radio critic it would be "real stinker" that "will put everyone to sleep"
- Key collaborators: John Houseman (partner), Howard Koch (writer)
- Major changes made to improve quality:
- Eliminated time passage from novel - made everything happen "right now"
- Added documentary/news bulletin style (faux-verite)
- Last-minute changes by Welles to shake up actors, get raw performances
Broadcast Details - October 30, 1938, 8 PM
- Properly introduced as Mercury Theater radio play
- Opened with musical program from "Meridian room, hotel Park Plaza"
- Lulled listeners into thinking it was regular music broadcast
- Late tuners missed introduction, thought listening to hotel music
- First news bulletin at 17.5 minute mark
- No sponsors = no commercial breaks
- Stretched first half to 40 minutes (past normal 30-minute station break)
- Featured realistic details:
- Reporter asking witness to speak louder into microphone
- Government official sounding like FDR (Secretary of Interior)
- Grover's Mill, New Jersey as invasion site (real town)
Competing Programming
- Chase & Sanborn Hour with Edgar Bergen/Charlie McCarthy (most popular show)
- Channel surfing during commercial breaks led people to War of the Worlds
- Some markets (Boston) preempted broadcast for local programming
Initial Newspaper Reports (Next Day)
- Headlines: "Fake Radio War Stirs Terror Through U.S." (NY Daily News)
- Stories of shock, hysteria, suicide attempts, heart attack deaths
- AP reported Pittsburgh man found wife with poison saying "I'd rather die this way than like that"
- NY Times: 20+ people in NY treated for shock and hysteria
- Welles publicly apologized, claimed didn't intend panic
Hadley Cantrell's Study (Princeton, 1940)
- Social psychologist released book on broadcast effects
- Claimed 6 million listeners, 1/6 frightened or disturbed
- Methodology problems:
- Interviewed only 135 people, almost all in New Jersey
- Selected 100 who were scared, excluded 35 who weren't
- Extrapolated New Jersey findings to entire country
- Study became basis for mass media/communications coursework for decades
- Created cautionary tale narrative about media responsibility
Revisionist Period (2010s)
- Myth debunked that America "lost its mind"
- Real ratings showed only 2% of respondents listening during broadcast
- New narrative: newspapers conspired against radio as competing medium
- Claimed panic was entirely fabricated
Brad Schwartz's Research (Current Understanding)
- Leading War of the Worlds scholar
- Analyzed actual letters/cables sent to Welles and Mercury Theater (University of Michigan archives)
- Found truth between extremes:
- Some people did panic (especially in New Jersey)
- Not widespread national hysteria
- Less than 1/4 of letters described panic
- Most panicked letter writers weren't angry when writing
- Described as "first viral phenomenon in media"
Estelle Pulse Story
- Manhattan couple spent last $6 to flee NYC by train
- Got off in Connecticut, warned other passengers
- Fellow passenger showed them newspaper TV listings proving it was radio play
- Other passengers gave them money to return to NYC
- Estelle wrote 15-page admiring letter to Welles next day
Newspaper Reaction Explanation
- Newsrooms received 150% more calls that night
- All calls asking about Martian invasion
- Police also called newsrooms for information
- Created impression of widespread panic to phone operators
- Combined with unverified wire service reports
- Led to lazy reporting without follow-up verification
Ecuador Incident (1948)
- Broadcasters recreated Welles' play in Quito
- Got other radio stations to participate
- Real public panic occurred
- Crowd discovered it was fiction, became angry mob
- Burned down newspaper building with radio station
- 6 people killed, 15 injured
- Two broadcasters indicted for their role
Listener Mail
- Tom from Stoke-on-Trent, UK engineer
- Been binging show for 2 years
- Recommends Polish mayonnaise over Japanese mayonnaise
- Emails various people about random topics
