AI summary by TwinMind
The Han Supremacist Problem
Asianometry
14m 57s
Introduction and Definition of Han Identity
- Han ethnic supremacy emerging as concern on China's internet and cultural spaces
- Han identity complex, similar to defining "whiteness" in America
- Historical fluidity (like Italian/Irish not initially considered "white")
- Constructed bundle of items: Confucian values, certain rites, cultural practices
- No single qualification determines Han status definitively
- Han supremacists view Han as single mono-race despite ethnic diversity (Hakka, Cantonese, others)
- Supremacist sites claim: "Han people are core race in China, interests of Han race one with China"
- Describe 5,000 years direct racial inheritance
- Claim Han blood "one of purest in world"
- Reality: Han genetically deeply intermixed breed, mixing for generations across China
- "Race of interbred mongrels" - more so than most global populations
Historical Context and Political Development
- Past 1,000 years: China ruled longer by foreigners than Han people
- Han nationalism helped topple Qing dynasty, establish ROC and PRC
- Centuries of Manchu rule grated against Han majority
- Chinese elites used "furry and horned men" rhetoric against minorities to unify "pure Han race"
Republic of China Era
- Sun Yat-sen realized Han supremacy would divide country
- Other WWI-era empires (Russia, Austria-Hungary) splitting due to minority issues
- Sun wanted to avoid same fate for China
- Guomindang promoted racial harmony as core tenet
- Five-colored flag of ROC
- Principle of five races under one union
- Sometimes advocated single unified Chinese race
- Han ethnocentrism remained lingering governance issue
Communist Party Approach
- CCP drew disproportionate support from ethnic minorities disillusioned with ROC
- Mao Zedong held strong views on ethnic minority value
- April 1956 Mao speech: "Reactionary rulers chiefly from Han nationality sowed estrangement among nationalities, bullied minority peoples"
- Called for extensive sustained efforts to educate cadres/masses
- Emphasized reviewing Han-minority relationships, dealing with abnormalities "in earnest"
CCP Ethnic Minority Policies
- PRC pays significant attention to ethnic minority/racial harmony issues
- Ideological and practical reasons for focus
- Despite male-dominated leadership, CCP promoted high-performing ethnic minority cadres
Creation and Classification System
- 1950s: Teams sent to locate, classify, protect non-Han ethnic cultures
- Created 56 separate nationalities
- People's Congress crafted affirmative action policies, preferential treatment
Specific Benefits for Minorities
- Regional ethnic autonomous states within China
- Dedicated museums, parks, schools, events, authorities
- Preferential treatment in national testing exam (Gaokao)
- Western China minorities: 200 points required
- Han people: 500 points required
- Exception to one-child policy
- Similar policies exist in Taiwan for recognized aboriginal tribes
Policy Outcomes and Han Resentment
- Policies introduced due to significant gaps between ethnic minorities and Han
- Similar to white-black gaps in America (income, wealth, employment)
- Policies appear unsuccessful in closing generational gaps
- Instead cultivated resentment from Han majority
- Han perspective: "High majority crucial driver of Chinese nation/history but treated worse than minorities, seen as part of problem"
Online Han Supremacist Movement
- Strong adherence in dark corners of Chinese internet
- Dozens of Han culture forums/websites emerged in China, Taiwan, overseas diaspora
- Famous site: "Han Wang" (now closed)
Cultural Revival Aspects
- Advocate revitalization of certain Han cultural aspects
- Reject others for non-Han origins
- Clothing focus: Cringe at Qing-era clothing (Manchu qipao, magua horse jacket)
- Promoted Hanfu clothing from pre-Manchu conquest Ming dynasty
- Hanfu movement went mainstream as "cute cosplay" for cultural connection
- Served as gateway drug to harder Han supremacism
Anti-Manchu Sentiment
- Special dislike for Manchu people
- Vigorously fought to revise Qing/Yuan dynasty views
- Paint Qing dynasty/Manchu leaders as bloodthirsty
- Claims: Manchu rolled back Ming progressive advancements, stole Han wealth, butchered Han, made China backwards
- Allowed West to advance and invade - "colonists same as British in India"
- Point to historical records of deaths from Qing conquest of Ming
- Reality: Qing conquest was long, complicated series of wars with Han fighting Han
- Boiling down to "bad Manchu victimizing innocent Han" hijacks history
- Goal: Reject celebration of 300 years China's history, pin decline on foreign face, absolve Han blame
Contemporary Policy Criticisms
- CCP affirmative action policies receive legitimate online criticism
- Perception: Government made deal with ethnic minorities - "no independence attempts = special privileges"
- Two most criticized policies:
- National examination advantages
- One-child policy exemption
- One-child exemption moved ethnic minority proportion from 3% (1949) to 8% (today)
- Still 1.2 billion Han Chinese total
- Han supremacist view: "Han people only country conducting own self-destruction"
- Perception: More ethnic minorities "running around and they are dumber"
Ethnic Violence and Reactions
- Incidents bring out worst of Han supremacists
- Late 2000s Urumqi riots triggered massive anti-minority sentiment
- Complaint: Ethnic minorities can attack Han people/rob at marketplaces, authorities allow it "in name of national unity"
Comparative Analysis with United States
- Parallels between China and US racial issues
- US founding fathers bound different races/creeds under freedom/happiness concept
- Reality didn't live up to values then or now
- Americans tried fixing through inclusiveness, expanding definition of "American"
- Darker US schools of thought:
- America built on Christianity/exclusively Christian values
- American white ethnocentrism
Chinese Parallel Schools of Thought
- Inclusive school: Can be accepted into Chinese society/Han race through Confucian values/rites
- "China nation of many races, all in this together"
- Darker school: Inherent gap between Han people and "barbarians"
- Other races "born barbarians, blood is barbarian"
- Assimilation attempts would be "fool's errand"
Geographic Distribution and Government Response
- Problem exists globally: America, Hong Kong, China, Taiwan, anywhere Chinese live
- Most troubling in areas with significant Han majorities
- China and Singapore only Han-majority countries with substantial minority populations
- Chinese government attempts to dodge concerns by:
- Creating "us (China) vs them (West)" feeling
- Making all Westerners foreigners
- Encouraging acceptable level of anti-foreign sentiment
- Helps suppress Han supremacism feelings
- Tactic may work but questionable long-term health
Conclusion and Assessment
- Tendency to dismiss as "niche group" or "keyboard warriors"
- Author considers serious problem due to widespreadness
- Government focus on other issues, many officials themselves Han
- Easy seduction by "supreme race" ideology
- Calls for serious attention to growing movement
