AI summary by TwinMind
The Headache of Taking a Company Private - Hostile Takeovers to Poison Pills Explained
The Plain Bagel
13m 56s
Introduction to Going Private
- Going public = big news, big payouts for owners, investment opportunities for public
- Going private = less common, opposite process
- Elon Musk Twitter deal sparked questions about private takeover process
- Shareholders have limited control over takeover decisions
- Management can actively fight against attractive offers using defense tactics
What Taking a Company Private Means
- Small group/individual buys all publicly traded shares
- Delists from public exchanges, becomes sole owner(s)
- All shareholders forfeit stock for cash (usually at premium to market price)
- Acquirer gains sole control over profitability and assets
- Process doesn't involve individual buy orders on Robin Hood
Role of Board of Directors
- Elected body making key business decisions
- Decides management pay, dividends, acquisition offers
- Necessary for corporate control (can't have hundreds of thousands fighting for control)
- Acquirer must convince board offer is in public investors' best interest
- Board acceptance required for deal approval
Deal Approval Process
- Investors don't individually decide to sell shares
- Deals require shareholder vote for approval
- Some brokers have weird policies about forwarding voting documents
- Regulatory approval needed (antitrust, security concerns)
- Process can take months to years
- Closing date announced when approved
- Shares disappear, replaced with cash on closing date
Why Acquirers Want to Buy Public Companies
- Believe company would perform better under their control
- Current management not realizing company's potential
- Public markets undervaluing business (currently a steal)
- Company would do better without public company baggage
- Strict regulations
- Tedious reporting requirements
- Fees/expenses for keeping shareholders informed
- Distraction from longer-term objectives
- Impatient public investors demanding change on stock price fluctuations
How Private Owners Benefit
- Receive company profits as dividends (direct cash payout)
- Sell company later after improving operations
- Relist company at higher price
- Find another private investor with money
Impact on Current Investors
- Takeover offers typically come at premium to current stock prices
- Acquirer must offer better than open market alternative
- Positive for investors short-term
- Rumors alone can send stock price surging
- Deals aren't always in investor's best interest
Risks for Investors
- Takeover price may still be below what investors believe position worth
- May force loss realization when hoping to ride out downturn
- Deal may fall through, stock price falls back to pre-deal level
- Twitter example: shares fell below pre-deal announcement after Elon threatened to walk away over fake accounts
- Failed deal signals buyer found something wrong or future offers likely rejected
- Share price approaches but doesn't match offer price (discount represents deal risk)
Board Rejection Reasons
- Believe investors will see larger return keeping company public
- Deal has little chance of closing
- Selfish reasons: board/employees/managers lose jobs
- Management entrenchment to keep cushy positions
Hostile Takeover Methods
- Circumvent board, negotiate directly with shareholders
- Three primary methods to vote in new directors:
1. Open Market Operations
- Buy stock on open market (lots of Robin Hood trades)
- Takes long time for meaningful position
- Some investors won't sell
2. Tender Offer
- Announce buying shares at premium to market price
- Example: $10 stock, offer $13 to investors
- Clear incentive to sell directly
- Costs extra premium
3. Proxy Battle
- Campaign to convince investors to vote in deal-friendly directors
- Get needed directors without majority stake
- Move forward with takeover plans
Defense Tactics by Board
- Board has authority to make changes without shareholder approval
Poison Pill (Shareholder Rights Plan)
- Twitter implemented briefly against Elon Musk
- Named after spy suicide pills
- If single shareholder reaches ownership threshold, company sells extra shares to others at discount
- Dilutes acquirer's ownership percentage
- Makes majority stake much more expensive
Crown Jewel
- Plan to automatically sell key asset if acquirer gains too much control
- Discourages moving forward
Other Tactics
- Super majority rules (require more than simple majority vote)
- Golden parachute (big pay to directors if business acquired)
- White knight (sell to friendly investor before hostile acquirer)
Impact on Investor Returns
- Conflicting research on how tactics impact returns
- Some studies suggest poison pills help boards bargain for better deals
- Whether tactics are good/bad depends on case-by-case nature
- Investors can suffer throughout process
Investment Considerations
- Any company can be taken private
- Takeover announcements generally positive
- Some base entire strategy on buying potential takeover targets
- Often more headache than expected
- Stock discounts to takeover price exist for reason (Twitter example)
- Gap exists due to deal risk
- Investors must decide if added risk worth extra return
