AI summary by TwinMind
The Hidden Cost of the Green Transition’s Mineral Rush | Galina Angarova | TED
TED
13m 55s
Indigenous Wisdom and Core Values
- Trusted elder's teaching: "Pay attention to your intention or other people's intentions"
- Shiny packages often contain same centuries-old paradigm of take and extract
- Key questions: Is it to take or give? Extract or regenerate?
- Speaker from Abzai clan of Herit nation of Buryat peoples (Siberian indigenous)
- Located on both sides of Lake Baikal (largest freshwater lake in world)
- Traditional teachings from grandmother:
- Take only what you need
- Leave something behind for regeneration
- Think seven generations ahead
- Currently leading global coalition for indigenous rights in green economy
Norilsk Nickel Disaster and Tesla Campaign
- May 2020: Tyr Peninsula, Russian Arctic
- Norilsk subsidiary fuel tank ruptured
- 21,000 tons of diesel spilled into local waterways
- Worst environmental disaster in Arctic history
- Decimated fishing/hunting grounds of indigenous communities
- Tesla nickel supply chain campaign:
- Elon Musk/Tesla seeking new nickel suppliers
- Global campaign urged Tesla not to purchase from Norilsk
- Established direct dialogue with Tesla
- Tesla confirmed no involvement/plans with Norilsk supply chain
- Result: Tesla adopted indigenous people's policy requiring suppliers to respect indigenous rights
- Continuing work to ensure policy implementation throughout supply chains
- Key lesson: End-user companies more susceptible to indigenous rights reputational risk
- Can manifest in substantial financial losses
Global Transition Minerals Crisis
- Transition minerals in increasing demand: nickel, copper, cobalt, lithium
- Used in electric vehicles, batteries
- Touted as climate change solution
- Huge part of green energy transition
- University of Queensland study: 54% of transition minerals located on/near indigenous lands
- Existential threat to 467 million indigenous peoples
- Best stewards of ecosystems/environments
- Lives/livelihoods completely dependent on territories/lands
- Since May 2020: Multiple impacted communities across:
- Russia, US, Argentina, Bolivia, Chile, Indonesia, Democratic Republic of Congo
Specific Global Examples
- January 2023: Largest rare earth deposit found in Kiruna village, Sami territories, Sweden
- Sami communities already impacted by existing iron ore mine on reindeer herding grounds
- New mines for green technologies would completely wipe them out
- Lithium Triangle (Argentina, Bolivia, Chile):
- Atacama Desert - driest place on Earth
- Koa indigenous communities competing with lithium mining for clean drinking water
- Mining industry extremely water intensive
Free, Prior and Informed Consent (FPIC)
- Fundamental right to self-determination expressed through FPIC
- Four principles bringing right to life:
- Free: without coercion/manipulation
- Prior: before any decision about development on indigenous lands/territories
- Informed: full disclosure, investor reports, briefings, environmental/social/cultural impact assessments
- Consent: right to say yes/no/maybe/yes with conditions
- Not just legal requirement - meaningful engagement for all stakeholders
- Policy makers, corporations, civil society, indigenous peoples
- Not anti-development - process as important as end result
- About treating people as equals, approaching traditional governance systems on equal footing
Corporate Engagement Strategy
- Worked with Tesla and Ford to establish indigenous people's policies
- Practical implementation example (Ford):
- Battery supplier must buy cobalt from mining company
- Mining company must document compliance with standards
- Must meaningfully engage with community from whose lands cobalt comes
- Goal: Work with every automaker worldwide
- Ultimate goal: Fundamentally change how governments/corporations engage with indigenous peoples
Holistic Solutions Approach
- Electric vehicles not silver bullet - no silver bullet solutions exist
- Could be part of solution but not THE solution
- Question whether extraction even needed - reuse/recycling could play powerful role
- Need stack of many solutions
- Indigenous peoples don't offer every solution but center justice, equity, rights, well-being
- Most important solutions come from communities living on land they know best
- Equipped with millennia-old traditional knowledge inherited from ancestors
Community-Led Climate Solutions
- Examples of indigenous-led initiatives:
- Nigeria, Colombia, Mexico: planting/restoring mangrove forests
- Ecuador: managing agroecological farms
- Alaska: experimenting with kelp production
- All support indigenous livelihoods while massively absorbing CO2
- Cumulative impact of all solutions will determine future of species/climate
- Must avoid one-sided approaches (carbon tunnel approach focusing solely on CO2 emissions)
- Look at solutions holistically without sacrificing indigenous peoples
Final Reflection on Intention
- Question: What is the intention?
- Are we creating new things to give, share, love, serve others?
- Or creating them to take, extract, serve ourselves?
- With right intention rooted in reciprocity and care - chance for success
- Mindset will determine survival vs. extinction
- Alternative to extractive mindset: be part of ecosystem, good neighbor, good relative to each other and other-than-human
