AI summary by TwinMind

The History of Superconductors (Before LK-99)

Asianometry

25m 2s

LK99 Discovery and Current Status

  • July 22, 2023: Paper posted claiming room temperature ambient pressure superconductor LK99
  • Global replication attempts underway
  • Wikipedia page tracking running tally of results
  • Quest for room temperature superconductor spans over 100 years

Discovery of Superconductivity (1911)

  • Dutch physicist Heike Kamerlingh Onnes and students experimented with liquid helium at super low temperatures
  • Competing theories: Sir James Dewar predicted resistance approaching zero, Lord Kelvin predicted minimum then rise to infinity
  • Mercury experiment showed resistance falling to zero at 4.2 Kelvin
  • Onnes named phenomenon "superconductivity"
  • Transition temperature: temperature where material achieves superconducting state

Early Disappointments and Critical Parameters

  • 1913: Onnes traveled to Chicago, spoke of helium cooling plant for efficient motors/generators
  • Lead transition temperature: 7.2 Kelvin (higher than mercury)
  • 1914: Lead coil lost superconducting powers when magnetic field reached horseshoe magnet strength
  • Three critical parameters discovered: low temperature, low magnetic field, low current density
  • Pure metal/simple alloy superconductors (Type 1) unsuitable for practical industrial use
  • Onnes became first victim of "Sirens of superconductivity"

Research Slowdown and New Discoveries (1920s-1930s)

  • Liquid helium cooling created formidable financial barrier
  • No big market need pushing commercialization
  • 1930s discoveries: Tantalum (4.4K), Thorium (1.4K), Niobium (9.2K - highest transition temperature)
  • 1933: Meissner effect discovered - superconductor expels magnetic fields, explains floating on magnets
  • Late 1920s: Soviet Ukrainian scientist Lev Shubnikov discovered Type 2 superconductors
    • Different from Type 1 pure metals
    • Can display mix of ordinary and superconducting properties at certain magnetic limits
    • More tolerant of higher magnetic fields
    • Almost always complicated alloys or compounds
  • 1937: Shubnikov arrested, accused of espionage, executed during Great Purge

Post-WWII Developments

  • MIT Professor Samuel Collins invented Collins helium liquefier system
  • Made liquid helium more available for research
  • Search for higher temperature superconductors remained difficult without good theory
  • Most researchers started with metals having low resistivity (copper, gold, silver)

Systematic Search and A3B Discovery (1950s)

  • Early 1950s: BT Matthias and John Hulm took systematic experimental approach
  • Pioneered method using Meissner effect to find superconductors
  • Applied external magnetic field to samples while cooling, measured field expulsion
  • Tested over 5,000 compounds systematically through periodic table
  • Discovered A3B superconductors: three niobium atoms + one silicon/tin/aluminum atom
  • Held record for highest transition temperature: 23K for 28 years
  • Matthias formulated "Matthias Rules" for finding superconductors
    • Rule #6: "Stay away from theorists"
  • Matthias looked down on superconducting theory, calling them "just descriptions"

BCS Theory (1957)

  • Three scientists proposed foundational theory: John Robert Schrieffer, Leon Cooper, John Bardeen
  • Bardeen won first Nobel Prize as transistor inventor, second for BCS Theory
  • BCS Theory suggests electrons pair up in superconducting state despite normal repulsion
  • New force called phonons (energized vibrations in crystal lattice) creates attractive forces
  • Electron pairs form "Cooper pairs" - exempt from Pauli Exclusion Principle
  • Cooper pairs travel through crystal lattice without resistance
  • Energy bond holding Cooper pairs is weak, easily broken by thermal energy
  • Explains superconductivity at low temperatures
  • Materials explainable by BCS called "conventional superconductors"

High Field Superconductors (1960s-1970s)

  • 1960: 35 elements and 1,000 alloys showed superconductivity
  • 1961: Niobium-based alloys retained superconductivity in stronger magnetic fields
  • Called "high field superconductors"
  • Enabled large superconducting wires performing better than copper
  • Produced powerful magnetic fields using little power
  • Achieved Kamerlingh Onnes' original dream
  • Early 1970s: Industry achieved reliable, viable superconducting wire production
  • MRIs with superconducting wire became single biggest commercial use for superconductors

High Temperature Superconductors Discovery (1986)

  • IBM lab Zurich: Alex Müller (senior research fellow) and Georg Bednorz
  • Müller interested after observing IBM's $300 million failed Josephson computer project
  • 1983: Recruited Bednorz to look for superconductors in oxides
  • Found French article describing metallic electrical conductivity at 900°C in ceramics
  • Produced ceramic compound: barium, lanthanum, copper, oxygen achieving superconductivity at 35 Kelvin
  • Major breakthrough - ceramics traditionally electrical insulators
  • Kept results secret initially, published in small German physics journal April 1986
  • Paper title: "Possible High Tc Superconductivity in the Ba-La-Cu-O System"
  • Published September 1986, rumors circulated since July

Scientific Community Response and Replication

  • Discovery shook scientific community like earthquake
  • Violated established Matthias Rules
  • Highlighted hole in BCS Theory
  • November 1986: Shoji Tanaka (University of Tokyo) confirmed results
  • Paul Chu (University of Houston) replicated results, made headlines
  • Race emerged with 77 Kelvin (liquid nitrogen temperature) as target
  • January 1987: Chu discovered superconductor above 90 Kelvin, breaking "liquid nitrogen barrier"
  • February 1987: Chu announced breakthrough after patent attempt

YBCO Superconductors and Naming

  • Called "1-2-3 superconductors": 1 yttrium, 2 barium, 3 copper atoms
  • Also called YBCO superconductors, cuprate superconductors, rare earth cuprate superconductors
  • Big layered compounds structure like cakes
  • Copper-oxygen layers separated by insulating oxide layers
  • Superconductivity happens within thin copper-oxygen layers
  • Cooper pairs probably involved but differently from BCS Theory
  • Called "unconventional superconductors"

Economic Impact of Liquid Nitrogen Barrier

  • Liquid nitrogen: $0.50/gallon vs liquid helium: $24/gallon
  • Significant cost benefits for cooling systems

Woodstock of Physics (March 1987)

  • March 15: American Physical Society special symposium on high temperature superconductors
  • Several thousand physicists at Hilton hotel
  • Evening session: 7 PM to 3 AM (8 hours)
  • Called "Woodstock of Physics"

Global Investment Rush (1987-1988)

  • Media headlines: New York Times, Business Week ("more important than light bulb and transistor")
  • Japan: Multiple ministries directed R&D spending
  • 1988: MITI's single biggest R&D expenditure on high temperature superconductors
  • US: Presidential conference on superconductivity July 1987
  • Reagan proposed 11-point plan for new industries
  • Tens of millions federal R&D dollars
  • Corporate players: IBM, Bell Labs
  • New startups: American Superconductor Corporation, Conductus, Illinois Superconductor Inc., Superconducting Technologies Inc.

Engineering Challenges and Reality Check

  • Transition temperature only one factor for commercial viability
  • Superconducting wires need high current densities and high magnetic field tolerance
  • Cuprate superconductors had higher transition temperatures but other critical parameters not dramatically higher
  • Materials engineering problems: ceramics very brittle, difficult to work with
  • Layered structure required specific alignment over hundreds of meters for wire production
  • Took substantial time to engineer wire using high temperature superconductors
  • Some applications still use niobium-titanium (established 1970) due to superior mechanical properties
  • 80-90% of MRI machines still use niobium-titanium 30 years later

Continued Research and Later Discoveries

  • 16 months after discovery: Bednorz and Müller won Nobel Prize (record for fastest recognition)
  • 2001: Japanese team discovered magnesium diboride (39 Kelvin transition temperature)
    • Below cuprates but higher than traditional low temperature superconductors
    • Conventional BCS behavior - dead end
  • February 2008: Dr. Hideo Hosono reported fluorine-doped iron-based superconductor (26 Kelvin)
    • Opened new branch separate from cuprates
    • Few months later: iron superconductor found with 56 Kelvin transition temperature
    • Progress since stalled
  • 2015: German team claimed superconductivity in sulfur hydrides over 200 Kelvin at high pressure
    • Questions about validity
    • Recent controversial room temperature claim retracted by Nature magazine

Current Reality and Future Outlook

  • Many applications already technically possible with existing low temperature superconductors
  • Economic barriers remain primary obstacle
  • Maglev trains: magnets not significant portion of financial cost (land, labor, planning, construction dominate)
  • Room temperature superconductor might not compete with existing economic solutions
  • Wire production from layered materials could take years
  • Real world applications might be years and millions of dollars away
  • LK99 outcome uncertain but excitement around superconductivity continues

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome