AI summary by TwinMind
The History of Superconductors (Before LK-99)
Asianometry
25m 2s
LK99 Discovery and Current Status
- July 22, 2023: Paper posted claiming room temperature ambient pressure superconductor LK99
- Global replication attempts underway
- Wikipedia page tracking running tally of results
- Quest for room temperature superconductor spans over 100 years
Discovery of Superconductivity (1911)
- Dutch physicist Heike Kamerlingh Onnes and students experimented with liquid helium at super low temperatures
- Competing theories: Sir James Dewar predicted resistance approaching zero, Lord Kelvin predicted minimum then rise to infinity
- Mercury experiment showed resistance falling to zero at 4.2 Kelvin
- Onnes named phenomenon "superconductivity"
- Transition temperature: temperature where material achieves superconducting state
Early Disappointments and Critical Parameters
- 1913: Onnes traveled to Chicago, spoke of helium cooling plant for efficient motors/generators
- Lead transition temperature: 7.2 Kelvin (higher than mercury)
- 1914: Lead coil lost superconducting powers when magnetic field reached horseshoe magnet strength
- Three critical parameters discovered: low temperature, low magnetic field, low current density
- Pure metal/simple alloy superconductors (Type 1) unsuitable for practical industrial use
- Onnes became first victim of "Sirens of superconductivity"
Research Slowdown and New Discoveries (1920s-1930s)
- Liquid helium cooling created formidable financial barrier
- No big market need pushing commercialization
- 1930s discoveries: Tantalum (4.4K), Thorium (1.4K), Niobium (9.2K - highest transition temperature)
- 1933: Meissner effect discovered - superconductor expels magnetic fields, explains floating on magnets
- Late 1920s: Soviet Ukrainian scientist Lev Shubnikov discovered Type 2 superconductors
- Different from Type 1 pure metals
- Can display mix of ordinary and superconducting properties at certain magnetic limits
- More tolerant of higher magnetic fields
- Almost always complicated alloys or compounds
- 1937: Shubnikov arrested, accused of espionage, executed during Great Purge
Post-WWII Developments
- MIT Professor Samuel Collins invented Collins helium liquefier system
- Made liquid helium more available for research
- Search for higher temperature superconductors remained difficult without good theory
- Most researchers started with metals having low resistivity (copper, gold, silver)
Systematic Search and A3B Discovery (1950s)
- Early 1950s: BT Matthias and John Hulm took systematic experimental approach
- Pioneered method using Meissner effect to find superconductors
- Applied external magnetic field to samples while cooling, measured field expulsion
- Tested over 5,000 compounds systematically through periodic table
- Discovered A3B superconductors: three niobium atoms + one silicon/tin/aluminum atom
- Held record for highest transition temperature: 23K for 28 years
- Matthias formulated "Matthias Rules" for finding superconductors
- Rule #6: "Stay away from theorists"
- Matthias looked down on superconducting theory, calling them "just descriptions"
BCS Theory (1957)
- Three scientists proposed foundational theory: John Robert Schrieffer, Leon Cooper, John Bardeen
- Bardeen won first Nobel Prize as transistor inventor, second for BCS Theory
- BCS Theory suggests electrons pair up in superconducting state despite normal repulsion
- New force called phonons (energized vibrations in crystal lattice) creates attractive forces
- Electron pairs form "Cooper pairs" - exempt from Pauli Exclusion Principle
- Cooper pairs travel through crystal lattice without resistance
- Energy bond holding Cooper pairs is weak, easily broken by thermal energy
- Explains superconductivity at low temperatures
- Materials explainable by BCS called "conventional superconductors"
High Field Superconductors (1960s-1970s)
- 1960: 35 elements and 1,000 alloys showed superconductivity
- 1961: Niobium-based alloys retained superconductivity in stronger magnetic fields
- Called "high field superconductors"
- Enabled large superconducting wires performing better than copper
- Produced powerful magnetic fields using little power
- Achieved Kamerlingh Onnes' original dream
- Early 1970s: Industry achieved reliable, viable superconducting wire production
- MRIs with superconducting wire became single biggest commercial use for superconductors
High Temperature Superconductors Discovery (1986)
- IBM lab Zurich: Alex Müller (senior research fellow) and Georg Bednorz
- Müller interested after observing IBM's $300 million failed Josephson computer project
- 1983: Recruited Bednorz to look for superconductors in oxides
- Found French article describing metallic electrical conductivity at 900°C in ceramics
- Produced ceramic compound: barium, lanthanum, copper, oxygen achieving superconductivity at 35 Kelvin
- Major breakthrough - ceramics traditionally electrical insulators
- Kept results secret initially, published in small German physics journal April 1986
- Paper title: "Possible High Tc Superconductivity in the Ba-La-Cu-O System"
- Published September 1986, rumors circulated since July
Scientific Community Response and Replication
- Discovery shook scientific community like earthquake
- Violated established Matthias Rules
- Highlighted hole in BCS Theory
- November 1986: Shoji Tanaka (University of Tokyo) confirmed results
- Paul Chu (University of Houston) replicated results, made headlines
- Race emerged with 77 Kelvin (liquid nitrogen temperature) as target
- January 1987: Chu discovered superconductor above 90 Kelvin, breaking "liquid nitrogen barrier"
- February 1987: Chu announced breakthrough after patent attempt
YBCO Superconductors and Naming
- Called "1-2-3 superconductors": 1 yttrium, 2 barium, 3 copper atoms
- Also called YBCO superconductors, cuprate superconductors, rare earth cuprate superconductors
- Big layered compounds structure like cakes
- Copper-oxygen layers separated by insulating oxide layers
- Superconductivity happens within thin copper-oxygen layers
- Cooper pairs probably involved but differently from BCS Theory
- Called "unconventional superconductors"
Economic Impact of Liquid Nitrogen Barrier
- Liquid nitrogen: $0.50/gallon vs liquid helium: $24/gallon
- Significant cost benefits for cooling systems
Woodstock of Physics (March 1987)
- March 15: American Physical Society special symposium on high temperature superconductors
- Several thousand physicists at Hilton hotel
- Evening session: 7 PM to 3 AM (8 hours)
- Called "Woodstock of Physics"
Global Investment Rush (1987-1988)
- Media headlines: New York Times, Business Week ("more important than light bulb and transistor")
- Japan: Multiple ministries directed R&D spending
- 1988: MITI's single biggest R&D expenditure on high temperature superconductors
- US: Presidential conference on superconductivity July 1987
- Reagan proposed 11-point plan for new industries
- Tens of millions federal R&D dollars
- Corporate players: IBM, Bell Labs
- New startups: American Superconductor Corporation, Conductus, Illinois Superconductor Inc., Superconducting Technologies Inc.
Engineering Challenges and Reality Check
- Transition temperature only one factor for commercial viability
- Superconducting wires need high current densities and high magnetic field tolerance
- Cuprate superconductors had higher transition temperatures but other critical parameters not dramatically higher
- Materials engineering problems: ceramics very brittle, difficult to work with
- Layered structure required specific alignment over hundreds of meters for wire production
- Took substantial time to engineer wire using high temperature superconductors
- Some applications still use niobium-titanium (established 1970) due to superior mechanical properties
- 80-90% of MRI machines still use niobium-titanium 30 years later
Continued Research and Later Discoveries
- 16 months after discovery: Bednorz and Müller won Nobel Prize (record for fastest recognition)
- 2001: Japanese team discovered magnesium diboride (39 Kelvin transition temperature)
- Below cuprates but higher than traditional low temperature superconductors
- Conventional BCS behavior - dead end
- February 2008: Dr. Hideo Hosono reported fluorine-doped iron-based superconductor (26 Kelvin)
- Opened new branch separate from cuprates
- Few months later: iron superconductor found with 56 Kelvin transition temperature
- Progress since stalled
- 2015: German team claimed superconductivity in sulfur hydrides over 200 Kelvin at high pressure
- Questions about validity
- Recent controversial room temperature claim retracted by Nature magazine
Current Reality and Future Outlook
- Many applications already technically possible with existing low temperature superconductors
- Economic barriers remain primary obstacle
- Maglev trains: magnets not significant portion of financial cost (land, labor, planning, construction dominate)
- Room temperature superconductor might not compete with existing economic solutions
- Wire production from layered materials could take years
- Real world applications might be years and millions of dollars away
- LK99 outcome uncertain but excitement around superconductivity continues
