AI summary by TwinMind

The intangible effects of walls | Alexandra Auer

TED

11m 48s

Historical Context of Wall Construction

  • Humankind builds walls for shelter, protection, privacy throughout history
  • Past 70 years: barriers between countries doubled
  • Current walls exceed numbers from WWII end and Cold War
  • Growing up in Germany: Berlin Wall fall felt like introduction of barrier-free world
  • Post-9/11: extreme rise in construction
  • Since 9/11: wall construction doubled with ~30 new structures planned/built

Security vs. Feeling of Security

  • Walls/fences built with security intentions: protection from other groups, crime, illegal trades
  • Walls provide feeling of security ≠ real security
  • Structures cannot actually protect, instead they separate
  • Create "us vs them" mentality, establish enemy perception

Physical and Mental Wall Interconnection

  • Physical walls create mental walls in people's heads
  • Mental walls make people lose sight of commonalities with "other side"
  • Mental walls can grow strong enough to encourage building/strengthening physical walls
  • Constant cycle: physical walls empower mental walls, mental walls empower physical walls
  • Cycle disrupted only when one part falls away

Berlin Wall Case Study

  • During construction: hard to identify who wall faced - people identified as one
  • No "us vs them" initially, no "others" concept
  • During separation: both sides developed different identities
  • Mental wall formed: created "us vs them" division
  • 1989 wall fall: mental wall remained in people's heads
  • Eastern Germans had to be reintegrated into own country
  • Many still feel they never fully arrived despite not moving

Scientific Evidence of Mental Wall Effects

  • 2005 University of Berlin study (15 years post-reunification):
    • Germans still believe cities on former wall's other side are further away than reality
    • Link between political attitude and distance estimation
    • More against reunification = estimated cities further away
    • Mental wall keeps other side cities "far away"
    • Higher/stronger mental wall = more difficult to reach

Young Generation Study Results

  • Author repeated study with young Germans who grew up without wall
  • Results: generation generally bad at geography (east and west)
  • Improvement: never experienced physical wall, couldn't build mental wall initially
  • Potential indication of future without mental wall dividing Germany
  • Reality: one wall disappearing while billions of others constructed

Gated Communities Trend

  • Global trend: rise of gated communities
  • Same concept as countries but smaller scale
  • Neighborhoods surrounded by walls/fences protecting citizens from other citizens
  • Only difference: by choice
  • Physical and mental effects same for people inside and outside
  • Separating cities, neighborhoods, even playgrounds

Brussels School Case Study

School Setup

  • Spring of last year: design project at two elementary schools in Brussels
  • Both schools share entrance and schoolyard
  • Both teach in Dutch
  • One school: mainly Belgian children
  • Other school: immigrant children
  • Schools separated by walls and fences
  • No interaction points except fence in schoolyard

Children's Behavior and Attitudes

  • Children must stand at fence to talk to friends on other side
  • Most children never get opportunity to make friends on other side
  • School should be place for all children to come together and learn
  • More diversity = more to learn
  • School might be only time in life for establishing contact despite social differences
  • Separating children during development makes integration extremely difficult/impossible

Community Acceptance

  • Author seemed only one with problem with fence
  • Most parents, teachers, children stopped seeing/questioning structure
  • People favor the fence - "just how it is"
  • Boy said wouldn't play with other side, but would if fence wasn't there
  • Quickly added fence should stay because "other side is mean, never give back ball"
  • Children from both sides say other side is mean because never give back ball
  • Both sides dislike each other, regular arguments at fence
  • Main reason people feel need for fence: protects children from each other/toys, prevents chaos

Escalation and School Response

  • Children started crawling beneath fence to get ball back
  • Schools' reaction: installed metal plates
  • Now children climb over fence
  • Unclear what came first: mental wall that grew strong enough to build physical fence, or fence that emphasizes social differences

Intervention Project

Author's Approach

  • Goal: show both sides how much they have in common
  • For children: easier because despite language differences (Dutch vs French/Turkish/Arabic mix), all speak universal language of play
  • Desire to play stronger than supposed differences

Games Installation

  • Installed different games at fence
  • Turned fence into interface/common ground instead of barrier
  • Children began drawing together, exchanging pencils, talking on phone
  • Phones were great success - amazed they could hear other side through device

Parent Engagement Strategy

  • Parents play big role in shaping children's everyday life and environment
  • Needed to show parents commonalities with other side
  • Challenge: parents speak different languages, work different jobs, different incomes, live in different social circles, different beliefs/cultures/values
  • Author different in all these aspects too

Picture Exhibition Solution

  • Chose not to convince parents directly
  • Let children do the talking
  • Designed picture exhibition on schoolyard showing children playing together through fence
  • Asked people to write thoughts/ideas/wishes on big wooden boxes
  • Labeled boxes with "what do you think"
  • Many people wrote "yes" without specific question being asked
  • When asked what they were answering: "yes the fence should go," "yes we want to play with other side"
  • Pictures implied enough to answer unproposed question
  • People saw absurdity of situation again, felt fence unnecessary
  • No forced opinion from author

Results

  • Exhibition showed two sides their similarities
  • That day: no "us vs them," no "others"
  • Mental wall started to crumble
  • Breaking mental wall = long journey, more difficult than tearing down physical wall
  • Must challenge opinions/beliefs, maybe admit own wrongs
  • Brussels event was big step (taking generations in Germany)

Global Implications and Lessons

  • Many examples worldwide telling same story as Brussels and Germany
  • Enough examples to learn from, but still seek walls as solutions
  • Walls cannot solve problems they're meant to address
  • Walls don't fight root of problems, only reduce symptoms
  • Next time planning to build wall or support wall building: remember real impact
  • Simple structure hardly creates more security
  • Affects people living with it daily
  • People often share culture/values despite geographic borders
  • Building one wall actually creates two walls
  • Will take decades and generations to overcome

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome