AI summary by TwinMind
The Language Sounds That Could Exist, But Don't
Tom Scott
6m 30s
English Spelling Problems
- "ough" produces different sounds: enough, cough, plough, hiccup, although, thought, thoroughly
- Multiple historical causes for spelling inconsistency:
- Loanwords with maintained/approximated pronunciations
- Monks spelling sounds as words entered language
- French scribes from Norman invasion respelled English words to match French spelling rules
- Spelling standardized with printing press implementation (16th century)
- Occurred during early modern English period
- Happened before Great Vowel Shift when vowels shifted
- Other European languages use different letters for different sounds
Creation of International Phonetic Alphabet (IPA)
- Late 19th century: International Phonetic Association created IPA beginnings
- Century later after revisions: now used worldwide
- Users: linguists, phonologists, speech pathologists, singers, many others
- Goal: one symbol for every sound in every spoken language worldwide
IPA Design Principles
- Eurocentric roots: based on Roman alphabet with Greek letters
- Closer language to European = more transcriptions look like regular Latin text
- Designed for easy typing without custom letter plates for printing presses/typewriters
- Features: rotated letters, partial symbols
- Designers avoided many diacritics
- Principle: one symbol per sound, one sound per symbol
Sound Production Mechanics
- Process: push air from lungs → create constriction in mouth/throat
- Two key factors:
- Place of articulation: where in mouth/throat constriction occurs
- Manner of articulation: how much constriction made
- Chart organized by these two factors
- Additional charts: vowels, diacritics, extensions
- Narrow transcription possible using diacritics for dialect/language/person variations
Consonant Chart Categories
- Plosives (top row): stop airflow then release suddenly (mini explosion)
- Examples: p, t, k moving backwards in mouth
- Glottal stop: closing airflow in throat (English "uh-oh", Mountain, Hawaii, Baja)
- Nasals: sounds made through nose
- Trills: not native to most English dialects
- Taps and flaps: one-time equivalent of long trills
- Fricatives: two parts touch (tongue tip + alveolar ridge)
- Alveolar ridge: hard roof of mouth behind top teeth ("pizza ridge" - burns when biting hot pizza)
- Approximants: two parts don't quite meet
- Lateral: air goes around sides (like "l" or Welsh "ll")
Chart Symbols and Limitations
- White background spaces: possible for humans but no symbol assigned
- Linguists haven't found them used in world languages
- If discovered, International Phonetic Association adds symbol
- Last addition: 2005
- Shaded/gray areas: theorized impossible to produce
- Velar trill example: need loose tissue fold for rapid trilling, no flesh loose enough at back roof of mouth (velum)
- Glottal lateral example: can't get tongue down throat to create center blockage while air escapes around sides
- Gray boxes forbidden from human speech due to physical limitations of being human
Writing vs. Speaking Differences
- Sometimes write things we can't pronounce
- Examples: holding letter "P" too long, silent letters
- Reference: Gretchen McCulloch's book "Because Internet"
