AI summary by TwinMind
The Legacy & Re-Making of America's Chinatowns | Talks at Google
Talks at Google
56m 23s
Introductions and Business Backgrounds
- Wilson Tang: CEO of Namwa Tea Parlor, NYC's first dim sum restaurant (100+ years old)
- Inherited from uncle in 2010
- Expanded from 1 flagship to 4 East Coast locations + 3 in Shenzhen, China
- Offers full service, quick service, and frozen foods
- Products sold at Pearl River Mart Chelsea Market
- Joanne Huang: President of Pearl River Mart (established 1971)
- Father-in-law started as "friendship store" - subversive way to introduce Asian culture
- Joined 5 years ago when SoHo rent increased fivefold
- Built 4 stores in last 5 years: flagship Chinatown, 2 Chelsea Market locations, Museum of Chinese in America
- Each store different focus: art gallery, books/culture, food
- Paul Ang: Owner of Fong On, oldest family-run tofu shop in NYC (since 1933)
- Started by grandfather, father took over 1940s-50s
- Brothers ran until few years ago when decided to close
- Paul restarted, renovated, modernized business
- Traditional tofu blocks + silken tofu pudding with toppings
Personal Motivations for Continuing Family Businesses
- Wilson: Hospitality/restaurant always in DNA, uncles/aunts all in restaurant business
- Watched immigrant parents work low-paying jobs for family's future
- Studied finance but never enjoyed it
- Jumped at opportunity to take over restaurant
- Paul: Father told him from age 5 "you're going to do family business"
- Always said no, but ultimately returned for same reasons grandfather started
- To support family, doing what they knew best
- Missed the foods they used to make
- Joanne: Different path - didn't grow up in retail/hospitality
- NYC kid, parents working class (mom bookkeeper, dad engineer)
- Followed typical 2nd generation Asian-American path: specialized high school, lawyer
- Worked at 100+ year old institutions, appreciated institutions built on shoulders of predecessors
- Reluctant entrepreneur, risk-averse
- Couldn't bear NYC without Pearl River when about to close
Business Longevity and Expansion Strategy
- Namwa: 101 years (celebrated centennial 2020)
- Fong On: 87-88 years
- Pearl River: 50 years (supposed to celebrate during COVID)
- Wilson's expansion approach:
- Case-by-case basis, made mistakes growing too fast initially
- Very calculated now, know exact square footage requirements
- Logistics plays big part
- Taking step-by-step approach post-COVID
- Joanne's longevity secret: Respecting core essence while adapting
- Working with in-laws 6 days/week as office mate
- Balancing respect for elders' generation with representing current/future generations
- Paul: Adapting to newer markets, changing consumption patterns
- Previously didn't expand enough, now reducing footprint to concentrate on core items
- Looking to Wilson as expansion model
Chinatown Gentrification and Future Vision
- Wilson: Change inevitable, slowing it down at manageable pace
- Keeping flagship Chinatown store traditional (shumai, shrimp dumplings, classics)
- Creative innovation at smaller locations (Nolita, Lower East Side)
- Edamame dumplings, gluten-free options, duck buns, crispy tofu buns
- Marriage of old and new as expansion strategy
- Paul: Gentrification inevitable but outsiders part of keeping legacy alive
- Teaching people to eat food traditional way vs. adapting to Western tastes
- No chocolate/strawberry soy milk - keep authentic preparation
- Room for expansion with original flair vs. complete adaptation
- Joanne: Modern Chinatown pioneers came after 1965, not that long ago
- Current generation are kids of that generation
- Chinatowns often frozen in time as remembered Asia
- Hope for accepting new/modern while keeping traditions alive
- Multi-generational inputs make communities lively
- Incumbent on those who grew up in neighborhood to shape authentic change
Lunar New Year Traditions and Celebrations
- Wilson: Teaching children (Ryan 8, Lucy 7) traditions through food
- Dumplings = gold nuggets (wealth), long noodles = long life
- No traditional parade due to COVID
- Massive spring cleaning, getting rid of broken toys/junk
- Children help at restaurant weekends: putting in tickets, folding boxes
- Ryan loves restaurant work, Lucy more into arts/crafts
- Paul: Not big celebrator growing up (youngest, followed others' traditions)
- Non-Chinese wife now pushing traditions he would have let go
- First time decorating store for Chinese New Year in entire history
- Planning celebrations
- Joanne: Pearl River celebrates lunar new year 365 days/year
- Active blog/Instagram researching traditions for customers
- Many grandparents not around, adopted/half-Asian customers need information
- Consolidating tradition explanations: foods, character meanings, significance
- Too busy running business to do deep house cleaning
Anti-Asian Violence and Community Response
- Wilson: Keep talking about it, share on social media, educate children
- Can't stand it, won't brush under rug
- Asian Americans need to stand together collectively
- Joanne: Violence always existed, but now opportunity for communities of color to be allies
- Different from parents' generation approach of "just push through"
- Current generation more willing to engage in dialogue
- Uncharted waters, best approach is keep talking
- Paul: Racism worse in past, getting better daily
- More public knowledge, Asians more vocal, more representation
- Pandemic strained progress due to fear
- Need more representation, constant vocal advocacy
Business Challenges and Pricing Philosophy
- Commercial rent relief/reform needed - unsustainable for small businesses
- Cultural shift needed: Asian food should not be cheap
- Wilson: Stood firm on $5 shrimp dumplings vs. $2.25 elsewhere
- Labor expensive, rent/insurance/everything costs money
- "We don't make cheap stuff, we're up there with the best"
- Paul: Chinatown problem - don't value products/services enough
- Should charge more for modern world
- Slim margins mean any disruption kills businesses
- Joanne: Consciously trained customers that artisanal products have value
- Chinese stuff should not be cheap
- Quality and curation justify pricing
Community Support and Collaboration
- Small group of 2nd/3rd/4th generation business owners heavily tapped for community events
- Joanne built art gallery showcasing Asian American artists (takes money from business)
- Wilson published Namwa cookbook featuring other Chinatown businesses
- Support organizations: Send Chinatown Love, Welcome to Chinatown
- Individual help: graphic design, postcards, micro-investments
- Federal stimulus money needed for legislative solutions
