AI summary by TwinMind

The Legacy & Re-Making of America's Chinatowns | Talks at Google

Talks at Google

56m 23s

Introductions and Business Backgrounds

  • Wilson Tang: CEO of Namwa Tea Parlor, NYC's first dim sum restaurant (100+ years old)
    • Inherited from uncle in 2010
    • Expanded from 1 flagship to 4 East Coast locations + 3 in Shenzhen, China
    • Offers full service, quick service, and frozen foods
    • Products sold at Pearl River Mart Chelsea Market
  • Joanne Huang: President of Pearl River Mart (established 1971)
    • Father-in-law started as "friendship store" - subversive way to introduce Asian culture
    • Joined 5 years ago when SoHo rent increased fivefold
    • Built 4 stores in last 5 years: flagship Chinatown, 2 Chelsea Market locations, Museum of Chinese in America
    • Each store different focus: art gallery, books/culture, food
  • Paul Ang: Owner of Fong On, oldest family-run tofu shop in NYC (since 1933)
    • Started by grandfather, father took over 1940s-50s
    • Brothers ran until few years ago when decided to close
    • Paul restarted, renovated, modernized business
    • Traditional tofu blocks + silken tofu pudding with toppings

Personal Motivations for Continuing Family Businesses

  • Wilson: Hospitality/restaurant always in DNA, uncles/aunts all in restaurant business
    • Watched immigrant parents work low-paying jobs for family's future
    • Studied finance but never enjoyed it
    • Jumped at opportunity to take over restaurant
  • Paul: Father told him from age 5 "you're going to do family business"
    • Always said no, but ultimately returned for same reasons grandfather started
    • To support family, doing what they knew best
    • Missed the foods they used to make
  • Joanne: Different path - didn't grow up in retail/hospitality
    • NYC kid, parents working class (mom bookkeeper, dad engineer)
    • Followed typical 2nd generation Asian-American path: specialized high school, lawyer
    • Worked at 100+ year old institutions, appreciated institutions built on shoulders of predecessors
    • Reluctant entrepreneur, risk-averse
    • Couldn't bear NYC without Pearl River when about to close

Business Longevity and Expansion Strategy

  • Namwa: 101 years (celebrated centennial 2020)
  • Fong On: 87-88 years
  • Pearl River: 50 years (supposed to celebrate during COVID)
  • Wilson's expansion approach:
    • Case-by-case basis, made mistakes growing too fast initially
    • Very calculated now, know exact square footage requirements
    • Logistics plays big part
    • Taking step-by-step approach post-COVID
  • Joanne's longevity secret: Respecting core essence while adapting
    • Working with in-laws 6 days/week as office mate
    • Balancing respect for elders' generation with representing current/future generations
  • Paul: Adapting to newer markets, changing consumption patterns
    • Previously didn't expand enough, now reducing footprint to concentrate on core items
    • Looking to Wilson as expansion model

Chinatown Gentrification and Future Vision

  • Wilson: Change inevitable, slowing it down at manageable pace
    • Keeping flagship Chinatown store traditional (shumai, shrimp dumplings, classics)
    • Creative innovation at smaller locations (Nolita, Lower East Side)
    • Edamame dumplings, gluten-free options, duck buns, crispy tofu buns
    • Marriage of old and new as expansion strategy
  • Paul: Gentrification inevitable but outsiders part of keeping legacy alive
    • Teaching people to eat food traditional way vs. adapting to Western tastes
    • No chocolate/strawberry soy milk - keep authentic preparation
    • Room for expansion with original flair vs. complete adaptation
  • Joanne: Modern Chinatown pioneers came after 1965, not that long ago
    • Current generation are kids of that generation
    • Chinatowns often frozen in time as remembered Asia
    • Hope for accepting new/modern while keeping traditions alive
    • Multi-generational inputs make communities lively
    • Incumbent on those who grew up in neighborhood to shape authentic change

Lunar New Year Traditions and Celebrations

  • Wilson: Teaching children (Ryan 8, Lucy 7) traditions through food
    • Dumplings = gold nuggets (wealth), long noodles = long life
    • No traditional parade due to COVID
    • Massive spring cleaning, getting rid of broken toys/junk
    • Children help at restaurant weekends: putting in tickets, folding boxes
    • Ryan loves restaurant work, Lucy more into arts/crafts
  • Paul: Not big celebrator growing up (youngest, followed others' traditions)
    • Non-Chinese wife now pushing traditions he would have let go
    • First time decorating store for Chinese New Year in entire history
    • Planning celebrations
  • Joanne: Pearl River celebrates lunar new year 365 days/year
    • Active blog/Instagram researching traditions for customers
    • Many grandparents not around, adopted/half-Asian customers need information
    • Consolidating tradition explanations: foods, character meanings, significance
    • Too busy running business to do deep house cleaning

Anti-Asian Violence and Community Response

  • Wilson: Keep talking about it, share on social media, educate children
    • Can't stand it, won't brush under rug
    • Asian Americans need to stand together collectively
  • Joanne: Violence always existed, but now opportunity for communities of color to be allies
    • Different from parents' generation approach of "just push through"
    • Current generation more willing to engage in dialogue
    • Uncharted waters, best approach is keep talking
  • Paul: Racism worse in past, getting better daily
    • More public knowledge, Asians more vocal, more representation
    • Pandemic strained progress due to fear
    • Need more representation, constant vocal advocacy

Business Challenges and Pricing Philosophy

  • Commercial rent relief/reform needed - unsustainable for small businesses
  • Cultural shift needed: Asian food should not be cheap
  • Wilson: Stood firm on $5 shrimp dumplings vs. $2.25 elsewhere
    • Labor expensive, rent/insurance/everything costs money
    • "We don't make cheap stuff, we're up there with the best"
  • Paul: Chinatown problem - don't value products/services enough
    • Should charge more for modern world
    • Slim margins mean any disruption kills businesses
  • Joanne: Consciously trained customers that artisanal products have value
    • Chinese stuff should not be cheap
    • Quality and curation justify pricing

Community Support and Collaboration

  • Small group of 2nd/3rd/4th generation business owners heavily tapped for community events
  • Joanne built art gallery showcasing Asian American artists (takes money from business)
  • Wilson published Namwa cookbook featuring other Chinatown businesses
  • Support organizations: Send Chinatown Love, Welcome to Chinatown
  • Individual help: graphic design, postcards, micro-investments
  • Federal stimulus money needed for legislative solutions

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome