AI summary by TwinMind
The lie that invented racism | John Biewen
TED
18m 22s
Personal Background and Early Racial Awareness
- Speaker raised in 1960s-70s by progressive parents who supported MLK (only 20% of white Americans supported MLK while alive)
- Family watched Sidney Poitier movies, Roots; clear message: "racism is wrong, racists are bad people"
- Lived in very white Minnesota community
- Allowed belief that white racists on TV were "from some other place" - didn't feel implicated
- Became journalist caring about equality/justice but puzzled why racism persisted despite being "clearly wrong"
Traditional Media Approach to Race
- Mostly white media typically reports "racial issues" by pointing cameras at people of color
- Standard questions: how are Black, Native American, Latino, Asian Americans doing in community/economy/education
- Speaker admits doing "share of that kind of journalism over many years"
Catalyzing Events Leading to Perspective Shift
- George Zimmerman killing Trayvon Martin
- Unending string of high-profile police shootings of unarmed Black people
- Rise of Black Lives Matter movement
- Dylann Roof and Charleston massacre
- Oscars So White controversy
- Daily racist incidents captured on smartphones/internet
- Stubborn data showing systemic racism in every institution:
- Housing segregation
- Job discrimination
- Racialized inequities in schools and criminal justice
- Rise of Donald Trump and discovery that solid majority of white Americans would embrace/accept "raw bitter kind of white identity politics"
Journalistic Pivot to Examining Whiteness
- Realized "white folks are the story, whiteness is a story"
- Questioned: "what would a podcast series about whiteness sound like?"
- Acknowledged this approach "could get uncomfortable"
- Found almost no journalism examining whiteness deeply
- Noted Black intellectuals had critiqued white supremacist culture for centuries
- Recent 2-3 decades: scholars examined race through whiteness frame
Scientific Reality of Race
- Science clear: one human race, all related, descended from common ancestor in Africa
- Some walked to colder/darker places, lost melanin
- Genetically all 99.9% the same
- More genetic diversity within racial groups than between them
- No gene for whiteness, blackness, or Asian-ness
Origins of Racial Concept
- Race is recent invention - just few hundred years old
- Before: people divided by religion, tribal group, language
- Ancient Greeks thought they were superior but not due to innate superiority - believed they'd developed most advanced culture
- Called Ethiopians, Persians, Celts "barbaric" culturally, not racially
- Ancient slavery: people enslaved those who looked like them and those who didn't
- English word "slave" derived from "Slav" - Slavic people enslaved by Western Europeans for centuries
First Articulation of Racist Ideas
- Historian Ibrahim Kendi identified: Gomes de Zurara, Portuguese man, 1450s
- First to lump together all people of Africa (vast diverse continent)
- Described them as distinct group: "inferior and beastly"
- Ignored sophisticated African cultures of pre-colonial time
- Zurara hired by Portuguese king
- Few years before: slave traders tied to Portuguese crown pioneered Atlantic slave trade
- First Europeans to sail directly to sub-Saharan Africa to kidnap/enslave Africans
- Story about African inferiority justified new trade to others/church
- "With stroke of pen Zurara invented both blackness and whiteness"
- Blackness has no meaning without whiteness
- Other European countries followed Portuguese lead
Development in Colonial America
- People calling themselves white took racist ideas, turned into law
- Laws stripped all human rights from people called Black
- Locked into "particularly vicious brand of chattel slavery"
- Laws gave even poorest white people benefits:
- Right to not be enslaved for life
- Right to not have loved ones torn away and sold
- Sometimes real benefits: free land handouts to white people only in places like Virginia
- Started long before American Revolution, continued long after
Key Takeaways from Historical Understanding
- Race not biological thing - story some people decided to tell
- People told story to justify brutal exploitation of other humans for profit
- Most didn't learn these facts in school
- Once understood: racism not mainly problem of individual bigotry attitudes
- Racism is tool to divide and prop up economic/political/social systems advantaging some, disadvantaging others
- Tool to convince white folks who may not get great deal from stratified society to support status quo ("could be worse, at least I'm white")
Current Implications
- Tool of whiteness still doing job it was invented to do
- Powerful people leverage/reinforce this weapon in halls of power, broadcast studios
- Not about whether they believe what they're saying or are "really racist"
- About pocketbooks and power
- No longer mystified that racism persists - it's not like flat earth theory that would naturally fade
Call to Action for White People
- People who look like us invented notion of race to advantage themselves and us
- "It's our problem to solve - it's a white people problem"
- Speaker embarrassed previously thought of racism as mainly struggle for people of color
- Previously felt like sidelines observer at sports contest
- Now: "no sidelines, we're all in it, we are implicated"
- If not joining struggle to dismantle advantaging system, then supporting it
Beyond Guilt to Responsibility
- Not about shame or white guilt - "white guilt doesn't get anything done"
- History isn't our fault, but feel stronger sense of responsibility to do something
- Altered approach to work as documentary storyteller and teacher
Practical Applications
- Support leaders pushing conversation about reparations
- Find/support people working to transform unjust institutions in communities
- At work: not grudgingly attend diversity/equity meetings but figure out how to be "real accomplice to colleagues of color"
- Show up with humility, vulnerability, willingness to put down unearned power
- Believe we'd benefit from society not built on exploitation/oppression of anyone
- Ultimate motivation: "because it's right"
