AI summary by TwinMind
The Little Plane War
Wendover Productions
9m 34s
Commercial Aviation Industry Structure
- Classic duopoly: Boeing (US) and Airbus (Europe)
- Two-thirds of all commercial aircraft made by these two manufacturers
- Boeing known for iconic 747
- Airbus formed from consortium of European manufacturers
Small Aircraft Market Gap
- Boeing and Airbus don't successfully make small planes despite attempts
- Airbus A318 (A320 variant): only 80 sold
- Boeing 707: commercial failure with 156 sales
- Significant untapped market exists for small aircraft
Regional Aircraft Manufacturers
- Embraer (Brazilian): E-jet family launched 15+ years ago, nearly 1,500 sold
- Bombardier (Canadian): makes 6% of world's commercial planes, successful CRJ regional jets
- London City Airport: 70% of 100+ daily flights use Embraer E-jets due to noise restrictions, steep approach angle, short runway
- US: 400 commercial airports, hundreds served by non-Boeing/Airbus jets due to government subsidies
Bombardier CSeries Development
- Launched 10 years ago to fill gap between small regional jets and larger Boeing/Airbus planes
- Features: composite construction, advanced aerodynamics, high bypass engines
- Development timeline: parts selected from 2007, first flight September 16th, 2013
- Originally planned commercial service 2014
Development Setbacks
- Uncontained engine failure during ground testing at Mirabelle Airport
- Prevented exhibition at Farnborough airshow (biennial, most important industry tradeshow)
- Program nearly out of money 2015
- Survived with significant financial support from Canadian and Quebec governments
CSeries Commercial Launch
- Entered service June 15, 2016 with Swiss Airlines (Zurich to Paris)
- Aircraft specifications: 3,800-mile range, transatlantic capability to small airports
- Current operations (October 2017): 14 planes flying (9 Swiss Airlines, 5 Air Baltic)
- Orders: nearly 350 planes (enough for profitability)
US Market Challenge
- American market crucial for program success due to tendency to use smaller planes
- Bombardier desperate for major US airline order
- Delta deal: 75 planes sold for $20 million each (quarter of $80 million list price)
- Manufacturing cost: ~$30 million per plane (selling at loss)
Boeing Trade Complaint
- Boeing filed dumping petition with US Department of Commerce
- Problem: Boeing doesn't make equivalent aircraft to CSeries
- Boeing claims CSeries hurts 737-700 sales
- Delta's position: didn't want 737s, Boeing couldn't deliver before 2020
- CSeries advantages: better range, shorter runway capability, more efficient, smaller size
Subsidy Arguments
- Boeing claims Bombardier received unfair subsidies
- Bombardier subsidies: ownership exchange or interest-free loans to be repaid
- Boeing subsidies: $14 billion over 20 years through tax breaks
- Boeing requested 80% tariff
- US Department of Commerce imposed 300% tariff
Airbus Partnership Solution
- October 16, 2017: Airbus acquired 50.01% stake in CSeries program for free
- Airbus benefits: marketing/sales powerhouse, resources exceed Bombardier's, no size overlap with existing planes
- Bombardier benefits: access to Airbus's superior sales capabilities
- Key advantage: Airbus final assembly line in Mobile, Alabama makes planes "American" (potentially avoiding tariffs)
Market Impact and Projections
- 20-year demand forecast: 5,500 aircraft in CSeries size category
- Pre-Airbus: Bombardier expected 40% market share (2,000+ planes)
- Post-Airbus: Expected 60% market share (3,000+ planes)
- Revenue impact: tens of billions in additional revenue
- Boeing impact: every sale is money lost to Boeing, now with legal American-made plane
