AI summary by TwinMind
The Matewan Massacre | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
55m 26s
Introduction and Topic Selection
- Hosts Josh and Chuck discuss Mexico City trip
- Episode idea originated from Will Oldham's appearance in John Sayles' Matewan film
- Topic covers Battle of Matewan as part of larger West Virginia Mine Wars
- Events took place in southern Appalachian coal country, early 20th century
Coal Industry Background in West Virginia
- West Virginia and coal historically linked since mid-19th century
- Bituminous coal industry crucial for American growth - factories, railroads, heating
- Coal provided more energy than wood, prevented deforestation around cities
- Coal companies profited heavily while miners faced brutal conditions
- Dozens of miners died annually from accidents and occupational hazards
- Coal companies controlled towns - owned houses, businesses, law enforcement
- Used "judicious mixture" of workers (European immigrants, Appalachian locals, Black Southerners) to prevent unionization
- Paid different wages for same work to create division
United Mine Workers of America (UMWA) Formation
- Founded 1890 as comprehensive union representing all miners regardless of race
- Unlike craft unions, included Black workers, Chinese immigrants
- 1897 major strike in Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, Pennsylvania resulted in 8-hour workday
- Southern West Virginia remained largest pocket of non-union miners nationally
- Early strikes were "bloody affairs" with people killed on both sides
Paint Creek and Cabin Creek Strike (1912)
- First major West Virginia Mine War confrontation
- Wildcat strike initially, then UMWA endorsed
- Baldwin Felts Detective Agency hired as private police force
- Used machine guns, shot up miners' homes with families inside
- Governor William "Tommy" Glascock declared martial law
- State militia broke strike, arrested union leaders and strikers
- Mother Jones arrested along with other organizers
- Military tribunals held, ended when WWI distracted attention
Baldwin Felts Detective Agency
- Founded 1892 by William G. Baldwin in Roanoke, Virginia
- Thomas Felts hired 1893 as co-owner
- Modeled after Pinkerton Agency for union busting
- Services included: kicking hobos off trains, supplementing local police, "eradicating black crime"
- Hired rough backgrounds, used any means necessary
- Operated with impunity due to coal company control of towns
- Prevented union organizing in West Virginia for 8-year period
- Involved in Ludlow Massacre (Colorado 1914) - 11 children killed
1920 Organizing Campaign
- UMWA launched nationwide coal strike end of 1919 - 27% raise for union workers
- West Virginia miners excluded from benefits, rallied to organize
- Campaign focused on McDowell, Logan, and Mingo Counties
- Matewan in Mingo County not company-controlled town
- Had independent businesses, legitimate local law enforcement
Key Figures in Matewan
- Police Chief "Smiling Sid" Hatfield - pro-union, descendant of Hatfield family
- Previously tried for blowing up coal tipple
- Mayor Cabell Cornelius "CC" Testerman - Hatfield's friend
- Stone Mountain Coal Company operated in area
- C.E. Lively - Baldwin Felts spy, opened restaurant to monitor union meetings
- Involved in Ludlow Massacre, befriended local leaders including Hatfield
May 19, 1920 - The Battle of Matewan
- About dozen Baldwin Felts guards came to evict miners from tent city
- Albert and Lee Felts (brothers of company co-owner) among guards
- CB Cunningham (Colorado Massacre participant) present
- Confrontation in town street between guards and Hatfield/Testerman
- Albert Felts claimed warrant for Hatfield's arrest
- Testerman declared warrant fake, said can't arrest police chief
- Armed miners gathered, someone fired first shot
- Shootout resulted in 7 detectives killed (including Albert and Lee Felts)
- Mayor Testerman killed, 2 miners died
- Some guards fled across river to Kentucky, others shot while running
- Bullet holes preserved in brick buildings with brass plugs
Aftermath and Rumors
- Trains redirected around Matewan that night
- Rumors spread that Hatfield shot Testerman over wife Jesse
- Rumor traced to Baldwin Felts detectives
- Hatfield married Jesse Testerman less than 1 month later
- Jesse was direct descendant of Randolph McCoy (Hatfield-McCoy feud)
- Hatfield and Jesse arrested for cohabitation before wedding
Trial Results - Round One
- Hatfield, Deputy Ed Chambers, and 17 miners all acquitted
- Tried in Mingo County (not coal company controlled)
- Sympathetic jury found self-defense
- Baldwin Felts and coal operators unsatisfied with results
August 1, 1921 - Assassination (Round Two)
- Hatfield and Chambers tried for coal tipple bombing in McDowell County
- Petitioned for venue change, granted pending final court appearance
- Both men gunned down in broad daylight with wives present
- C.E. Lively (the spy) among assassins
- Claimed self-defense, acquitted in coal company-friendly McDowell County
- Jesse Testerman Hatfield widowed twice, remarried state constable January 1922
March on Logan County and Battle of Blair Mountain (Round Three)
- 10,000 armed miners assembled in Marmet (8 miles south of Charleston) August 1921
- Sought to avenge Hatfield/Chambers deaths, confront Sheriff Don Chafin
- Governor Ephraim Morgan (anti-union Republican) finally intervened
- Chafin gathered deputies, anti-union civilians on Blair Mountain ridge
- Several days of warfare: gunfire, Gatling guns, machine guns, rifles
- Airplanes dropped shrapnel bombs and gas bombs
- President Warren Harding sent federal troops
- Miners surrendered only to federal forces, not coal company forces
- Considered victory - "Uncle Sam did it," not Baldwin Felts or operators
Long-term Impact and Resolution
- Post-Hatfield assassination: 90% of area miners signed with union
- Coal operators continued anti-union tactics through 1920s
- UMWA membership dropped from 500,000 (1920) to 100,000 (1929)
- Events drew national attention to labor struggles
- Contributed to FDR's New Deal policies
- UMWA voice elevated to national politics
- Labor union strengthening, better working conditions
- Benefits extended to non-union workers through competitive pressure
- UMWA formed CIO (Congress of Industrial Organizations)
- Enormous effect on future of American labor movement
Baldwin Felts Agency Decline
- Operated 15 years after Matewan, less publicly
- Baldwin and Felts both died within 1.5 years of each other (1936)
- Company folded permanently
- C.E. Lively returned to mining, became destitute by 1927
Cultural Legacy
- John Sayles' 1987 film "Matewan" - fictionalized version
- Chris Cooper starred, some real characters included
- Preserved historical sites with bullet hole markers
