AI summary by TwinMind
The mental health benefits of storytelling for health care workers | Laurel Braitman
TED
9m 44s
Medicine and the Muse Program Background
- Laurel Braitman: writer-in-residence at Stanford Medical School for several years
- Hired by Audrey Shafer (poet/anesthesiologist) who started Medicine and the Muse Program
- Program goal: reintroduce humanities into medical education and training
- Braitman's role: teach writing, storytelling, communication skills to physicians, nurses, medical students, healthcare workers
Mental Health Crisis in Medical Education
- Initial expectation: student essays about cadaver dissection, poems about anatomy
- Reality: students writing about crushing anxiety, unbearable pressure to succeed, mental health diagnoses, suicide attempts, isolation, career doubts
- Student Uriel Sanchez quote: mentors force choice between "being a really good person or a really good doctor"
- Key statistics:
- 30% of American medical students are depressed
- 1 in 10 medical students have thought about suicide
- Practicing physicians have worse rates: widespread job dissatisfaction, high depression rates
- Doctors have one of highest suicide rates of any US profession
- Physicians' humanity/emotional well-being never made core part of training
- Real vulnerability (sharing mental health diagnoses) can be career-ending
Storytelling Workshop Program Structure
- Evening, weekend, day-long storytelling workshops at farms and locations with good food
- Invited facilitators: journalists, writers, producers, podcasters, poets
- Teaching focus: writing, communication, storytelling skills
- Participants practice vulnerability by sharing stories aloud
- Goal: reconnect with what drew them to medicine originally
- Skills for handling stressful, messy reality of medical work
- Helping realize medicine as calling
Student Success Stories
Maite Van Hentenryck
- Had leg amputated as baby
- Medical school quiz question: "first time you encountered someone with a disability"
- Realized supervisors never considered she (the doctor) was the person with disability
- Shared story with ~100 peers despite being shy
- Result: students with disabilities approached her to co-lead campus advocacy group for visibility/inclusion in medical training
Pablo Romano
- Parents immigrated from Mexico
- Father died when Pablo was 18, mother died when he was 20
- First time talking publicly about being orphan
- Co-created "Talk Rx" live storytelling series with Braitman
- Popular venue for peers to share vulnerable thoughts/feelings
- Quote: "At the end of the day, what moves people is stories"
Arifeen Rahman
- Second-year medical student
- Parents immigrated from Bangladesh to US before her birth
- Grew up in safe, stable Northern California home, Harvard graduate
- Initially felt her stories weren't worth telling
- Gave talk about being possibly only Bangladeshi American girl to win Daughters of American Revolution essay contest
- Dressed as Declaration of Independence for Halloween
- Story represents new American dream complexities
Research Results and Impact
Candice Kim Research
- MD-PhD student in medical education
- Written about #MeToo in medicine, navigating queer identity in conservative field, mother's metastatic cancer diagnosis
- Research findings on storytelling participants:
- 36-51% decrease in distress
- Results last up to one month (measurement stopped at one month)
- 100% of participants recommend opportunities to friends
- If this was mental health drug, would be "absolute blockbuster"
Program Philosophy and Outcomes
- Storytelling as vulnerability practice: like "raising flag up flagpole" - others see it, resonate if they agree
- Creativity doesn't belong to certain job categories - all professions can make meaning, find beauty, create
- Created culture of vulnerability where none existed before
- Allows doctors to envision different future for themselves and patients
- Maite's vision: doctor who remembers birthdays without charts, knows patients' favorite colors and TV shows, remembered for listening and treating whole person not just disease
Broader Healthcare System Impact
- Being human is terminal condition - all will die
- Helping healthcare professionals communicate meaningfully with each other, patients, themselves
- Won't magically fix contemporary healthcare system problems
- Won't lift immense burdens placed on physicians
- Key to ensuring healers healthy enough to heal others
- Vulnerable communication with compassion = "absolute best medicine we have"
