AI summary by TwinMind
The Most Valuable Airspace in the World
Wendover Productions
10m 47s
Geographic and Economic Context
- East Asia (China, Japan, Korea, Taiwan) and Europe: 2.4 billion people each
- Combined regions: 1/3 world population, ~$20 trillion GDP each
- Together account for half of world's economic activity
- Russia strategically positioned between these economic powerhouses
Cold War Flight Restrictions
- Soviet Union prohibited non-Soviet airlines from overflying territory
- 1950s BOAC London-Tokyo route: 36 hours, 10,000 miles
- Stops: Rome, Beirut, Bahrain, Karachi, Calcutta, Yangon, Bangkok, Manila
- Distance between cities actually 6,000 miles
- Slower propeller service: 88 hours (Sunday departure, Thursday arrival)
Arctic Route Development
- SAS pioneered polar routes as alternative to Soviet airspace
- Initial use: faster routes to American west coast
- Required new navigation systems (magnetic compasses ineffective in high north)
- 1950s SAS polar route: Copenhagen-Kangaroo Suart Greenland-Winnipeg-Los Angeles
- Reduced 36-hour trip to 22 hours
Anchorage as Global Hub
- 1960s: Only 40,000 people in Anchorage, Alaska (new state since 1959)
- Became crucial Europe-Asia stopping point
- BOAC London-Tokyo polar route (thrice weekly):
- Departure: Heathrow 1:45 PM
- Anchorage arrival: 9.5 hours later
- 1-hour refuel stop
- Tokyo arrival: 7 additional hours
- Total: 17.5 hours (half previous time)
- 1960s-70s airlines serving Anchorage: Air France, SAS, KLM, Iberia, Lufthansa, JAL, Korean Air
- Modern terminal built 1982 to handle hundreds monthly flights
Advanced Aircraft Alternatives
- Finnair 1983: Helsinki-Tokyo non-stop via international airspace north of Russia
- Route over North Pole: 13 hours (vs today's 9-hour direct)
- Still faster than Anchorage stop
Post-Soviet Airspace Opening
- 1991 Soviet Union collapse
- Russia granted overflight rights to European/East Asian airlines
- Required modernization: Air traffic control system anglicization
- International aviation standard: English language requirement
- Airlines quickly switched to non-stop Europe-Asia flights over Siberia
- Anchorage international terminal abandoned (built for hundreds monthly flights, now sees flight every few days)
Russian Overflight Economics
- Siberian routes save airlines significant time/money
- Russia charges substantial overflight fees
- Estimated cost: Up to $100 per passenger per round-trip Europe-Asia flight
- Exact fees kept secret, vary by airline
Geopolitical Control Mechanisms
- 133 countries signed ICAO transit agreement (allows any airline overflight)
- Russia NOT signatory - can pick/choose which airlines get access
- Used as geopolitical weapon:
- 2014: Threatened EU airline closure over sanctions
- 2017: Threatened Dutch airline closure over Schiphol Airport slot reduction
- April 2018: Tacitly threatened US airline closure over Syria military action
Airline Access Restrictions
- General rule: One airline per European country for Siberian overflight
- Exceptions exist: British Airways AND Virgin Atlantic (both London-based) serve Shanghai/Hong Kong
- Country-specific monopolies:
- Air France: Only French airline with rights
- Lufthansa: Only German airline with rights
- Iberia: Only Spanish airline with rights
Budget Airline Competition Challenges
- Legacy carriers maintain quasi-monopoly on East Asian routes
- SAS: Operates from Norway, Denmark, Sweden with Siberian rights to Tokyo, Beijing, Shanghai
- Norwegian Air: Major low-cost carrier wanting eastward expansion
- Current routes: Copenhagen/Oslo/Stockholm-Bangkok, London-Singapore (southern routes avoiding Siberia)
- Repeatedly denied Siberian overflight rights
- Argues SAS doesn't operate Norway-Asia flights, so Norwegian should get Norwegian rights
- Russia denies because SAS partially registered in Norway
- Norwegian subsidiaries:
- UK subsidiary unlikely to get rights (BA/Virgin already have them)
- Ireland subsidiary potential option (no Irish airline has Siberian rights, but SAS has Irish subsidiary too)
Other Budget Airline Attempts
- Iceland airlines (WOW Air, Iceland Air) attempted negotiations
- Russia wants high fees that make low-cost operations impossible
- WOW Air planned Reykjavik-Delhi route:
- Direct routing would cross Russia
- Alternative routing adds only 45 minutes
- Flight start planned December 2018
Market Impact Assessment
- Russia uses overflight rights as negotiation tool
- Pulling rights = huge financial blow to airlines
- Granting rights = competitive advantage
- Current system stifles competition, keeps Asia flights expensive
- No budget airline granted Siberian overflight rights to date
- Shortcut availability saves millions of passengers time/money annually
