AI summary by TwinMind
The murderous medieval king who inspired "Macbeth" - Benjamin Hudson
TED-Ed
6m 9s
Shakespeare's Macbeth Plot Overview
- Opens with Scottish generals Macbeth and Banquo encountering trio of witches
- Witches predict Macbeth will become Scotland's king, Banquo's descendants will take throne
- Macbeth kills King Duncan and Banquo in murderous frenzy
- Paranoid Macbeth summons witches again for aid
- They predict safety until faraway forest lays siege upon his castle
- Play ends with army disguised as trees sacking his keep
- Duncan's son Malcolm reclaims throne
Historical Basis in 11th Century
- 1040: Scottish general Macbethad killed predecessor Duncan to become king of Scotland
- 1057: Duncan's son Malcolm Canmore led successful raid against usurper
- Six 11th century texts record these events
- Subsequent historians mention witches, prophecies, arboreal armies
Medieval Historical Writing Practices
- Various clerics, chroniclers, poets wrote about medieval Scottish king
- Writers operated as storytellers rather than objective historians
- Standard practice: pull details from various historical accounts to craft new histories
- Reflected current cultural norms
- Argued moral positions
- Commented on royal politics
John of Fordun's Account (1380)
- Scottish cleric penned history of Scotland incorporating Macbethad's rule
- Written during war with England, after great plague
- Goal: instill Scottish pride in devout, educated readers
- Glorified Canmore dynasty, denounced Macbethad as villain interrupting their rule
Andrew of Wyntoun's Demonization
- Cleric further demonized Macbeth decades after Fordun
- Writing for audiences enthralled by occult
- Portrayed murderous usurper as devil's spawn
- Added hallucinations of ghostly greyhounds
- Introduced witches inspired by Norse mythology Fates
- Added rebels using branches to camouflage attack
Hector Boece's Renaissance Perspective
- Renaissance scholar had more sympathy for Macbeth
- Portrayed as just ruler who descended into ruthless paranoia
- Cautionary tale possibly criticizing tyrannical contemporary kings
- Henry VIII
- Francis I
- Altered version likely inspired Shakespeare
Shakespeare's Political Motivations
- England ruled by King James I when writing "Macbeth"
- James descended from Stuarts, Scottish royal dynasty including fictional Banquo
- Possible flattery of King James:
- Gave Banquo bigger role
- Introduced prophecy about descendants taking throne
- Witches inclusion potentially motivated by James's hatred of witchcraft
- Playing to throne by exaggerating sinister supernatural elements
- Alternative: rebelling against king's censorship of other witchy plays
Shakespeare's Unique Contributions
- More tormented and confused protagonist than previous tellings
- Central questions posed:
- Is he devil or saint?
- Are witches real or illusion?
- Is he in charge of destiny or determined by external forces?
- Shakespeare's Macbeth may be truest version
- Not due to historical similarities
- Because character tries to determine role in ever-changing currents of history
