AI summary by TwinMind

The Mysterious Disappearance of the Franklin Expedition | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

50m 27s

Introduction and Northwest Passage Context

  • Franklin Expedition: famous Arctic expedition from mid-19th century
  • All 129 crew members died - extremely rare even for Arctic exploration
  • Last seen by whaling ships at voyage beginning, then vanished
  • Mystery endured for over century with scant evidence
  • Northwest Passage: route from Atlantic to Pacific through Arctic
  • Difficult navigation due to 30,000 islands, moving ice, unpredictable conditions
  • British Royal Navy wanted to chart remaining 300 miles of unknown Arctic territory
  • Mid-19th century: everything else globally charted except Arctic question mark

John Franklin Background

  • Born 1786, not wealthy but extensive naval combat experience
  • 1819: transitioned from military to Arctic exploration career path
  • Previous expeditions: mixed results, failures but gained notoriety
  • First expedition: half crew died, Franklin ate leather boots to survive, wrote bestselling book, knighted despite failure
  • Second expedition: also problematic, bailed out by Inuit both times
  • 1837: appointed lieutenant governor Van Diemen's land (Tasmania)
  • Wife Lady Jane Franklin pushed for final Arctic expedition to restore family name

Ships and Preparations

  • Two ships: HMS Erebus and HMS Terror
  • Originally warships (mortar vessels), retrofitted for Arctic
  • Iron plates on front for ice breaking
  • Steam engines added to sailing vessels for emergency power
  • Steam system provided central heating and water distillation
  • Retractable propellers for shallow/icy water
  • Supplies: 32,000 lbs beef, 33,000 lbs tinned meat, fresh vegetables, livestock
  • Pets: monkey (gift from Lady Jane), dog named Neptune, unnamed cat
  • 7,000+ lbs tobacco, 4,000 gallons rum/wine, 3,000 lbs candles
  • 930 gallons lemon juice (1 oz daily per crew member for scurvy prevention)
  • 8,000 tins from contractor Stephen Goldner (rushed timeline)

The Voyage Begins

  • Departed May 1845, left Disco Bay Greenland July 1845
  • 134 crew originally, 5 left behind in Greenland for swearing/drunkenness
  • Final crew: 129 men
  • Last sighting: whaling ships Enterprise and Prince of Wales at Lancaster Sound
  • Forced south immediately due to ice conditions

First Winter and Early Progress

  • Wintered at Beachy Island (first winter 1845-46)
  • Three deaths during first winter (considered poor record)
  • Successfully navigated through first summer
  • Made progress charting and exploring
  • Reached northwest corner King William Island by second winter

The Disaster Unfolds

  • September 1846: iced in for second winter off King William Island
  • Expected 3-year supply duration, initially not worried
  • Summer 1847: ice didn't melt - unprecedented situation
  • May 1847: team left message in Royal Navy form under cairn
  • June 11, 1847: Franklin died while team was away
  • Francis Crozier took command, James Fitz James third in command
  • Remained iced in from September 1846 through 1848 and beyond
  • Ships never moved within ice pack

Abandonment and Death March

  • Crozier's decision: wait for ice to melt vs. walk to safety
  • Chose to abandon ships and walk toward mainland Canada
  • Dragged heavy sleds loaded with supplies across ice
  • Few dozen made it to mainland Canada but still in extreme danger
  • Inuit location name: "Tuk-tu-nu-nee" (back of beyond)
  • Ice core samples later showed two worst winters in 700 years

Search Period (1847-1859)

  • Over 30 search expeditions launched
  • Royal Navy offered £20,000 reward (£2.2M today, $2.8M USD)
  • Lady Jane Franklin led public campaign
  • Search expeditions contributed more Arctic charting than original expedition
  • John Rae: key searcher who listened to Inuit testimony
  • Rae reported cannibalism based on Inuit accounts
  • Lady Jane Franklin and Charles Dickens publicly attacked Rae
  • Dickens wrote racist diatribe dismissing Inuit testimony

Inuit Knowledge and Testimony

  • Inuit had detailed oral history of entire expedition
  • Witnessed events, knew locations, understood what happened
  • European explorers consistently ignored or dismissed their knowledge
  • Inuit reports: 4 survivors remained until 1851-1852 (including dog)
  • Search expeditions active while survivors still alive but never found them
  • Inuit accurately pointed to ship locations century before discovery

Evidence and Theories of Death

  • Normal expedition hazards: bad weather, under-preparation, heavy equipment
  • Clothing held water which froze
  • Didn't listen to local Inuit survival knowledge
  • Lead poisoning theory (Dr. Owen Beattie, 1981): high lead levels in bones
  • Rushed tin soldering by Goldner leaked lead into food
  • Possible botulism contamination in poorly sealed tins
  • Lemon juice may have been boiled (destroying vitamin C), causing scurvy despite supplies

Cannibalism Evidence

  • Cut marks on leg bones
  • Intentionally broken skulls
  • Bone clusters indicating deliberate disposal
  • Long bones found separately (portable food)
  • All markers consistent with known cannibalism sites
  • Confirmed Inuit testimony and John Rae's reports

Modern Discoveries

  • 2014: HMS Erebus found in 30 feet of water
  • 2016: HMS Terror discovered off King William Island
  • Ships remarkably intact due to cold water conditions
  • Dishes, bottles, desks still in place
  • Closed drawers likely contain expedition documentation
  • Parks Canada underwater videos show preserved interiors

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome