AI summary by TwinMind
The Mysterious Disappearance of the Franklin Expedition | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
50m 27s
Introduction and Northwest Passage Context
- Franklin Expedition: famous Arctic expedition from mid-19th century
- All 129 crew members died - extremely rare even for Arctic exploration
- Last seen by whaling ships at voyage beginning, then vanished
- Mystery endured for over century with scant evidence
- Northwest Passage: route from Atlantic to Pacific through Arctic
- Difficult navigation due to 30,000 islands, moving ice, unpredictable conditions
- British Royal Navy wanted to chart remaining 300 miles of unknown Arctic territory
- Mid-19th century: everything else globally charted except Arctic question mark
John Franklin Background
- Born 1786, not wealthy but extensive naval combat experience
- 1819: transitioned from military to Arctic exploration career path
- Previous expeditions: mixed results, failures but gained notoriety
- First expedition: half crew died, Franklin ate leather boots to survive, wrote bestselling book, knighted despite failure
- Second expedition: also problematic, bailed out by Inuit both times
- 1837: appointed lieutenant governor Van Diemen's land (Tasmania)
- Wife Lady Jane Franklin pushed for final Arctic expedition to restore family name
Ships and Preparations
- Two ships: HMS Erebus and HMS Terror
- Originally warships (mortar vessels), retrofitted for Arctic
- Iron plates on front for ice breaking
- Steam engines added to sailing vessels for emergency power
- Steam system provided central heating and water distillation
- Retractable propellers for shallow/icy water
- Supplies: 32,000 lbs beef, 33,000 lbs tinned meat, fresh vegetables, livestock
- Pets: monkey (gift from Lady Jane), dog named Neptune, unnamed cat
- 7,000+ lbs tobacco, 4,000 gallons rum/wine, 3,000 lbs candles
- 930 gallons lemon juice (1 oz daily per crew member for scurvy prevention)
- 8,000 tins from contractor Stephen Goldner (rushed timeline)
The Voyage Begins
- Departed May 1845, left Disco Bay Greenland July 1845
- 134 crew originally, 5 left behind in Greenland for swearing/drunkenness
- Final crew: 129 men
- Last sighting: whaling ships Enterprise and Prince of Wales at Lancaster Sound
- Forced south immediately due to ice conditions
First Winter and Early Progress
- Wintered at Beachy Island (first winter 1845-46)
- Three deaths during first winter (considered poor record)
- Successfully navigated through first summer
- Made progress charting and exploring
- Reached northwest corner King William Island by second winter
The Disaster Unfolds
- September 1846: iced in for second winter off King William Island
- Expected 3-year supply duration, initially not worried
- Summer 1847: ice didn't melt - unprecedented situation
- May 1847: team left message in Royal Navy form under cairn
- June 11, 1847: Franklin died while team was away
- Francis Crozier took command, James Fitz James third in command
- Remained iced in from September 1846 through 1848 and beyond
- Ships never moved within ice pack
Abandonment and Death March
- Crozier's decision: wait for ice to melt vs. walk to safety
- Chose to abandon ships and walk toward mainland Canada
- Dragged heavy sleds loaded with supplies across ice
- Few dozen made it to mainland Canada but still in extreme danger
- Inuit location name: "Tuk-tu-nu-nee" (back of beyond)
- Ice core samples later showed two worst winters in 700 years
Search Period (1847-1859)
- Over 30 search expeditions launched
- Royal Navy offered £20,000 reward (£2.2M today, $2.8M USD)
- Lady Jane Franklin led public campaign
- Search expeditions contributed more Arctic charting than original expedition
- John Rae: key searcher who listened to Inuit testimony
- Rae reported cannibalism based on Inuit accounts
- Lady Jane Franklin and Charles Dickens publicly attacked Rae
- Dickens wrote racist diatribe dismissing Inuit testimony
Inuit Knowledge and Testimony
- Inuit had detailed oral history of entire expedition
- Witnessed events, knew locations, understood what happened
- European explorers consistently ignored or dismissed their knowledge
- Inuit reports: 4 survivors remained until 1851-1852 (including dog)
- Search expeditions active while survivors still alive but never found them
- Inuit accurately pointed to ship locations century before discovery
Evidence and Theories of Death
- Normal expedition hazards: bad weather, under-preparation, heavy equipment
- Clothing held water which froze
- Didn't listen to local Inuit survival knowledge
- Lead poisoning theory (Dr. Owen Beattie, 1981): high lead levels in bones
- Rushed tin soldering by Goldner leaked lead into food
- Possible botulism contamination in poorly sealed tins
- Lemon juice may have been boiled (destroying vitamin C), causing scurvy despite supplies
Cannibalism Evidence
- Cut marks on leg bones
- Intentionally broken skulls
- Bone clusters indicating deliberate disposal
- Long bones found separately (portable food)
- All markers consistent with known cannibalism sites
- Confirmed Inuit testimony and John Rae's reports
Modern Discoveries
- 2014: HMS Erebus found in 30 feet of water
- 2016: HMS Terror discovered off King William Island
- Ships remarkably intact due to cold water conditions
- Dishes, bottles, desks still in place
- Closed drawers likely contain expedition documentation
- Parks Canada underwater videos show preserved interiors
