AI summary by TwinMind
The myth of bringing your full, authentic self to work | Jodi-Ann Burey
TED
15m 37s
Halloween Party Metaphor Introduction
- Speaker uses analogy of being invited to "non-Halloween" party on October 31st
- Friend insists "come as you are" - no costume needed
- Arrival reveals everyone in costumes, costume contest underway
- Attendee receives no votes for following instructions
- Feeling of anxiety, upset, bewilderment at being "odd one out" for doing what told
Workplace Authenticity Parallel
- Corporate messaging: "bring your full, authentic self to work"
- Recruiters/managers/executives/CEOs say:
- "We want people of color to feel like they belong here"
- "Looking for passionate people who can bring fresh perspective"
- "Our diversity is our strength"
- "Come just as you are"
Historical Context of Professionalism
- Long-standing expectation for underrepresented people to contort into "caricature of professionalism"
- Professionalism defined as "distorted elaboration of white cultural norms"
- Standards meet comforts of those holding social/institutional power
- Invitation to authenticity signals safe space to "shed the guise"
- Promise: differences seen as assets, not liabilities
The Authenticity Trap
- Speaker shows up with: Afro, family photos, disability accommodation needs, questions, pushback, perspective from lived experience
- Performs job with excellence
- When time comes for: stretch projects, promotion, equal pay, recognition, mentors, sponsors - overlooked
- Feedback received:
- "Need to work on being more team player"
- "Your approach makes it difficult to work with you"
- "Try to help others feel more comfortable around you"
- "You are hurting relationships when you talk about racism"
- Result: no promotion, no mentor, no votes
Systemic Analysis
- Cannot compete in costume contest without costume and expect to win
- Call for authenticity "undeservedly disadvantages people of color"
- Already burdened with "chronically battling bias"
- Culture shift work designed to cost mental/physical health
- If authenticity makes us "difficult" - compromises careers
- One person/few people cannot change company culture alone
- Change impossible alongside rewards for coded definitions of "fit"
Authenticity as Inadequate Solution
- Authenticity becomes "palatable proxy" masking need to end:
- Racism, ageism, ableism, sexism, homophobia, xenophobia
- Without accountability to examine systems of bias/power - call fails
- Fails to question: who's in room, who sits at table, who gets heard
- Fails to demand truth about how racism impacts these decisions
- Even when people of color present: "bodies wanted in room, but not voices"
Personal Experience - Senior Leadership Meeting
- Called into unscheduled check-in with executive after brainstorming meeting
- Executive praised contributions to project success
- Then suggested: be more agreeable, help give others wins
- Feedback should be sent via email instead of voiced in meetings
- Speaker felt contributions mattered, seat at table pivotal
- Had opted outside usual guardedness, stopped hiding opinions
- Felt could "take off costume" for first time
- Realized this was mistake
DARVO Response Framework
- Speaker mentioned treatment consistent with how women of color/Black women treated at work
- Executive's response followed DARVO pattern:
- Deny: "This has nothing to do with your race"
- Attack: "You're being too sensitive and angry"
- Reverse Victim/Offender: "If you play race card every time I give feedback, hard to work together. I just want you successful, trying to support you"
- Attempts at gaslighting/psychological manipulation were futile
- Experience not unique for: Black women, people of color, people with disabilities, nonbinary people, deaf people, LGBTQIA+ people
The Costume We Wear
- Being authentic privileges those already part of dominant culture
- Easier to be yourself when who you are is all around you
- Coming as we are when we're "first, only, different, or one of few" proves too risky
- So we wear costume, keep truer parts hidden:
- Straighten curly hair for interviews
- Pick up hobbies we don't enjoy
- Restate directives as optional suggestions
- Talk about weather instead of police brutality
- Mourn for Breonna Taylor alone
- Ignore racist supervisor comments
- Stop correcting mispronounced names
- Ask fewer questions
- Learn to say nothing and smile
- Omit parts of our stories
- History shows this as best path for success
Societal Tipping Point
- Society reaching new tipping point
- Inequities, racism, bigotry finding fewer places to cower
- Silences becoming harder to keep
- Radical collective imaginations for racial justice reaching new possibilities
- Call for denied inclusion people to dedicate authentic fullness to making space everywhere
Direct Challenge to Power Holders
- Key statement: "Black people do not need to be any more authentic"
- "This Black disabled immigrant woman will not be bringing her full, authentic self to work"
- Instead asking those with:
- Power of positions
- Protection of whiteness
- Other unearned societal privileges
- To take on that risk instead
Concrete Action Items for Change
- Make working effectively across racial/cultural differences core competency in hiring/performance management
- Define good product design as centering most underserved people
- Close racial gender pay gap, starting with Latinx women
- Build responsive people systems to manage racial conflict with equity/justice
- These decisions can be implemented today, in next meeting
- Not about changing hearts/minds - about closing gap between what you say and how we're treated
Final Challenge
- "You do the work to make it safe for me to come just as I am with my full, authentic self"
- "That's your job, not mine"
- "It's your party, not mine"
- "You set the rules and rewards"
- Final question: "What will it take to win in your contest?"
