AI summary by TwinMind

The myth of bringing your full, authentic self to work | Jodi-Ann Burey

TED

15m 37s

Halloween Party Metaphor Introduction

  • Speaker uses analogy of being invited to "non-Halloween" party on October 31st
  • Friend insists "come as you are" - no costume needed
  • Arrival reveals everyone in costumes, costume contest underway
  • Attendee receives no votes for following instructions
  • Feeling of anxiety, upset, bewilderment at being "odd one out" for doing what told

Workplace Authenticity Parallel

  • Corporate messaging: "bring your full, authentic self to work"
  • Recruiters/managers/executives/CEOs say:
    • "We want people of color to feel like they belong here"
    • "Looking for passionate people who can bring fresh perspective"
    • "Our diversity is our strength"
    • "Come just as you are"

Historical Context of Professionalism

  • Long-standing expectation for underrepresented people to contort into "caricature of professionalism"
  • Professionalism defined as "distorted elaboration of white cultural norms"
  • Standards meet comforts of those holding social/institutional power
  • Invitation to authenticity signals safe space to "shed the guise"
  • Promise: differences seen as assets, not liabilities

The Authenticity Trap

  • Speaker shows up with: Afro, family photos, disability accommodation needs, questions, pushback, perspective from lived experience
  • Performs job with excellence
  • When time comes for: stretch projects, promotion, equal pay, recognition, mentors, sponsors - overlooked
  • Feedback received:
    • "Need to work on being more team player"
    • "Your approach makes it difficult to work with you"
    • "Try to help others feel more comfortable around you"
    • "You are hurting relationships when you talk about racism"
  • Result: no promotion, no mentor, no votes

Systemic Analysis

  • Cannot compete in costume contest without costume and expect to win
  • Call for authenticity "undeservedly disadvantages people of color"
  • Already burdened with "chronically battling bias"
  • Culture shift work designed to cost mental/physical health
  • If authenticity makes us "difficult" - compromises careers
  • One person/few people cannot change company culture alone
  • Change impossible alongside rewards for coded definitions of "fit"

Authenticity as Inadequate Solution

  • Authenticity becomes "palatable proxy" masking need to end:
    • Racism, ageism, ableism, sexism, homophobia, xenophobia
  • Without accountability to examine systems of bias/power - call fails
  • Fails to question: who's in room, who sits at table, who gets heard
  • Fails to demand truth about how racism impacts these decisions
  • Even when people of color present: "bodies wanted in room, but not voices"

Personal Experience - Senior Leadership Meeting

  • Called into unscheduled check-in with executive after brainstorming meeting
  • Executive praised contributions to project success
  • Then suggested: be more agreeable, help give others wins
  • Feedback should be sent via email instead of voiced in meetings
  • Speaker felt contributions mattered, seat at table pivotal
  • Had opted outside usual guardedness, stopped hiding opinions
  • Felt could "take off costume" for first time
  • Realized this was mistake

DARVO Response Framework

  • Speaker mentioned treatment consistent with how women of color/Black women treated at work
  • Executive's response followed DARVO pattern:
    • Deny: "This has nothing to do with your race"
    • Attack: "You're being too sensitive and angry"
    • Reverse Victim/Offender: "If you play race card every time I give feedback, hard to work together. I just want you successful, trying to support you"
  • Attempts at gaslighting/psychological manipulation were futile
  • Experience not unique for: Black women, people of color, people with disabilities, nonbinary people, deaf people, LGBTQIA+ people

The Costume We Wear

  • Being authentic privileges those already part of dominant culture
  • Easier to be yourself when who you are is all around you
  • Coming as we are when we're "first, only, different, or one of few" proves too risky
  • So we wear costume, keep truer parts hidden:
    • Straighten curly hair for interviews
    • Pick up hobbies we don't enjoy
    • Restate directives as optional suggestions
    • Talk about weather instead of police brutality
    • Mourn for Breonna Taylor alone
    • Ignore racist supervisor comments
    • Stop correcting mispronounced names
    • Ask fewer questions
    • Learn to say nothing and smile
    • Omit parts of our stories
  • History shows this as best path for success

Societal Tipping Point

  • Society reaching new tipping point
  • Inequities, racism, bigotry finding fewer places to cower
  • Silences becoming harder to keep
  • Radical collective imaginations for racial justice reaching new possibilities
  • Call for denied inclusion people to dedicate authentic fullness to making space everywhere

Direct Challenge to Power Holders

  • Key statement: "Black people do not need to be any more authentic"
  • "This Black disabled immigrant woman will not be bringing her full, authentic self to work"
  • Instead asking those with:
    • Power of positions
    • Protection of whiteness
    • Other unearned societal privileges
  • To take on that risk instead

Concrete Action Items for Change

  • Make working effectively across racial/cultural differences core competency in hiring/performance management
  • Define good product design as centering most underserved people
  • Close racial gender pay gap, starting with Latinx women
  • Build responsive people systems to manage racial conflict with equity/justice
  • These decisions can be implemented today, in next meeting
  • Not about changing hearts/minds - about closing gap between what you say and how we're treated

Final Challenge

  • "You do the work to make it safe for me to come just as I am with my full, authentic self"
  • "That's your job, not mine"
  • "It's your party, not mine"
  • "You set the rules and rewards"
  • Final question: "What will it take to win in your contest?"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome