AI summary by TwinMind
The Pig War - OverSimplified
OverSimplified
38m 43s
Post-Revolutionary War Border Disputes
- Revolutionary War ended with British granting Americans generous western territory
- Benjamin Franklin expressed interest in acquiring Canadian territory
- Border agreement established from northwestern point of Lake of the Woods westward to Mississippi River
- Maps were inaccurate - lake shape wrong, Mississippi location wrong
- War of 1812 resulted in draw, necessitated border renegotiation
1814 Border Settlement and Oregon Territory
- New border: from Lake of the Woods to 49th parallel, straight line to Rocky Mountains
- Territory beyond Rockies remained disputed - both sides claimed it
- America believed in Manifest Destiny - divine right to expand across continent
- Britain controlled territory through Hudson's Bay Company for beaver fur trade
- Columbia River deemed vital for British beaver business
- Joint occupation agreement established for Northwestern territory (temporary)
American Expansion and Oregon Trail Migration
- James Douglas - Hudson's Bay Company chief factor at Fort Vancouver
- Thousands of Americans migrated via Oregon Trail to Oregon territory
- Americans outnumbered British 6:1 in Oregon
- President Polk claimed entire region for America, threatened war
- British forced to relocate north due to American settlement pressure
- 1846 agreement: border continued straight to Strait of Georgia, then south through channel to Pacific
- British retained Vancouver Island
San Juan Islands Boundary Ambiguity
- Treaty language: "middle of the channel and thence southerly through the middle of said channel"
- Multiple channels existed - treaty wording too vague
- British claimed Rosario Strait = islands were British
- Americans claimed Haro Strait = islands were American
- Islands held in dispute, governments focused on other priorities
British Settlement Attempt
- 1853: James Douglas (now Governor of Vancouver Island) sent Charles Griffin to establish sheep farm
- Griffin set up operation with 1,369 sheep and prized Berkshire pigs
- 1854: American customs collector demanded taxes on British property
- Americans threatened seizure, British threatened arrest
- Sheriff Barnes seized 34 breeding rams for unpaid taxes ($80.33)
- Both governments told local officials to back down
- Boundary commission established but failed to reach agreement
Fraser Canyon Gold Rush and American Settlement
- Gold discovered in Fraser Canyon - attracted American miners
- Many unsuccessful miners settled in area, including San Juan Island
- ~12 American settlers moved to San Juan Island late 1850s
- Lyman Cutler built cabin in middle of British sheep run
- Cutler planted potatoes with inadequate three-sided fence
The Pig Incident
- Griffin's Berkshire pig repeatedly entered Cutler's potato garden
- Cutler confronted Griffin multiple times about pig trespassing
- June 15, 1859: Cutler shot and killed Griffin's pig
- Griffin demanded $100 compensation (outrageous sum at time)
- Cutler refused payment, threatened to shoot more animals
- British officials threatened to arrest Cutler, take him to Victoria for trial
General Harney's Intervention
- General William S. Harney - commander of Department of Oregon
- Reputation: court-martialed 4 times, called "imbecile" and "laughing stock"
- Hated British, wanted personal glory, possibly presidential ambitions
- July 1859: visited San Juan Island, learned of situation
- Devised plan to use pig incident to start war with Britain
- Ordered Captain George Pickett to occupy island with troops
Military Escalation
- Pickett landed troops on disputed territory (extremely provocative)
- Set up exposed camp, posted sign declaring only American laws applied
- British officials demanded American withdrawal
- Douglas ordered Royal Navy ships to island
- Captain Hornby arrived with multiple warships, guns aimed at American camp
- Pickett hastily relocated camp (still in exposed position)
- Douglas planned joint military occupation, ordered British troop landing
Near-War Crisis
- Pickett threatened to open fire if British troops landed
- British had orders to land, Americans threatened to shoot
- Captain Hornby refused to follow Douglas' landing order
- Rear Admiral Baynes arrived, outranked Douglas
- Baynes canceled all Douglas' orders, pursued non-interference policy
- Crisis averted by level-headed naval officers
Government Response
- News took 6 weeks to reach Washington DC and London
- Both governments shocked by near-war situation
- President Buchanan overwhelmed (facing secession crisis)
- General Winfield Scott sent to Pacific Northwest to resolve situation
- Scott negotiated joint military occupation agreement
- Condition: Pickett removed from command, replaced by Captain Hunt
- Harney defied Scott, put Pickett back on island
- Scott removed Harney from command
Joint Occupation Period
- British and American troops coexisted peacefully
- Attended each other's national celebrations
- Pickett befriended British counterpart
- Civil War (1861) made San Juan issue low priority
- Harney remained in Union army but removed from St. Louis command
- Pickett became Confederate General, famous for Pickett's Charge at Gettysburg
Final Resolution
- Post-Civil War: US-British relations soured over Confederate support
- 1872: Issue submitted to German arbitration
- Americans presented more compelling argument
- Germany awarded San Juan Islands to United States
- November 25, 1872: Last British troops left island
- British removed flagpole as final gesture
- Griffin had already left island, Hudson's Bay Company sold sheep farm
