AI summary by TwinMind
The PLA’s Biggest Corruption Scandal
Asianometry
8m 15s
Background on Xi Jinping's Anti-Corruption Campaign
- Shu Taiho: one of China's "big tigers" in Xi Jinping's anti-corruption drive
- Demonstrated even Politburo Standing Committee members not protected from prosecution
- Zhou Yongkang case showed goal extends to China's powerful military
- People's Liberation Army (PLA): world's largest army, probably second most powerful
- Party controls PLA through Central Military Commission chaired by China's most senior generals/party members
- Military corruption largely unexplored topic, basically state secret
- Prosecuting Shu characteristic of Xi Jinping's style of shaking up status quo
Shu Taiho's Military Career Rise
- Born June 1943 in Liaoning province
- Joined PLA at age 20 after graduating from well-respected military feeder academy
- Rose quickly through ranks based on formal education
- Deng Xiaoping wanted PLA reform after Cultural Revolution turmoil
- Sought educated people for reform and fresh perspectives
- 1990: became political commissar with rank of major general
- Role: keeping fighting forces aligned with political ideology
- Political department had immense power over promotions/personnel recommendations
- No third-party oversight made senior political positions ripe for corruption
- 1992: promoted to assistant director of PLA's General Political Department
- Beneficiary of high-level military purge initiated by Zhang Zhenmin after Tiananmen Square incident
- 1999: made full general, entered China's Central Military Commission
- 2013: retired as vice chairman of CMC
- Made him one of most powerful people in China
- Likely involved in promotion of many senior military officers over past two decades
Downfall and Investigation
- Shortly after retirement, things unraveled
- Diagnosed with terminal bladder cancer
- Party's anti-corruption body (CCDI) began investigating him and fellow vice chairman Guo Boxiong
- Investigation focused on cash-for-ranks corruption scandal
Cash-for-Ranks Corruption Scheme
- Military considers corruption information state secret - limited concrete evidence
- Most knowledge based on rumors and what military chooses to share
- Simple concept: bribe required for promotion to certain positions
- Bribes not available to everyone - needed right connections (guangxi)
- Largely required for uniform officers
- PLA officers selling positions due to little financial retirement security
- Veterans stayed in jobs as long as possible, blocking advancement pathways
- Bribery reinforced existing social networks within military
- Scheme origins: simple rewards from promoted officers to patrons as genuine thanks
- Evolved into costly purchases where buyers monetized investment by reselling down the line
- Small percentage kickbacks given up to original sellers
- Took on aspects of huge multi-level marketing scheme
- Undermined people's confidence in own military
Key Subordinates and Land Corruption
- CCDI style: roll up subordinates first before taking down main targets
- Notable underling: General Logistics Department Deputy Gu Junshan
- Taken into isolation and held without release/accusation after 2012
- General Logistics handled procurement of supplies and management of army's massive land holdings
- Purchased public land at below market prices
- Received kickback fees from land developers bidding on developments
- Diaoyu Tai Number Seven example:
- Cluster of high-end luxury apartments in heart of Beijing
- Homes cost ~$46,000 USD per square meter
- Land requisitioned by army for "scientific research"
- Gu ended up with this plum logistics position largely because of Shu
- Gu allegedly gave Shu's daughter $3.2 million cash card at party as compensation/kickbacks
- Shu protected Gu from prior anti-corruption investigations and removals
- Shu's former position as secretary on PLA's anti-corruption force branch especially helped with protection
Arrests and Convictions
- CCDI detained General Shu December 2013 for investigation
- Also arrested: wife, daughter, mistress, personal secretary - all convicted
- Investigation began March 2014
- October 2014: Shu expelled from military and party
- Investigation/expulsion muddled by national security concerns and terminal cancer diagnosis
- Officials raided home, reportedly found over one ton of jewelry, jade stones, and cash in basement
- Less detail available compared to Zhou Yongkang trial
- China's propaganda organs called him "two-faced demon" and "national thief"
- Shu spared truly onerous punishment due to imminent death from cancer
- Died March 2015 in hospital from cancer
- Shu's partner in crime received life sentence
- Gu Junshan (corrupt logistics officer) received death sentence with two-year reprieve in 2015
- Still appears to be alive based on latest internet searches
Broader Impact and Aftermath
- Two years after Shu's arrest: ~30 high-level PLA officers investigated and removed
- Many were political commissars and logistics department members
- Made sense since these officers best positioned to profit from rank
- Party regularly cites Shu Taiho alongside Zhou Yongkang as one of big tigers in anti-corruption drive
- Proof to public that no rank/position powerful enough to provide full immunity
- Shu's journey not as dramatic as Zhou Yongkang's spectacular rise and fall
- Government hidden many details to avoid disclosing military secrets
- PLA considers any third-party analysis of possible corruption as hostile intrusive action
- No army wants dirty laundry aired out
Current Status of Anti-Corruption Drive
- Over five years passed since Shu's arrest and removal
- Anti-corruption drive continues to this day
- State-owned media doesn't trumpet each arrest as much
- Shown to reduce certain corruption types (cronyism within party's provincial ranks)
- Same could be said for PLA ranks but reality remains opaque to outside observers
