AI summary by TwinMind
The Power of Unconventional Thinking | David McWilliams | TED
TED
18m 11s
Opening and Context Setting
- Speaker originally scheduled for first TED session, moved to last slot by Chris
- References Mike Tyson quote: "everybody has a plan until they get a punch in the face"
- Notes pressure of going last at TED, jokes about sobriety being the real problem
- Observes TED speeches focused on pace of change affecting demographics, politics, society, economics
Historical Crisis Analysis Through Poetry
- Quotes Vladimir Lenin: "there are decades when nothing happens and there are weeks when decades happen"
- Introduces W.B. Yeats' 1919 poem "The Second Coming" as crisis prediction framework
- Historical context 1919: German, Austrian, Ottoman empires collapsed; Ireland declared independence war against Britain
- Yeats' key lines: "Things Fall Apart the center cannot hold / mere Anarchy is loosed on the world / the best lack all conviction / the worst are full of passionate intensity"
Yeats vs. Economists Predictions
- Yeats predicted center wouldn't hold (1919)
- 3-4 years later: Mussolini in power (Italy), Stalin ascending (Soviet Union), Hitler orchestrated Munich putsch
- Economists predicted return to gold standard, resumed trade, German reparations payment, WWI as "war to end all wars"
- Yeats proved right, economists completely wrong
Educational System and Intelligence Types
- Reflects on school experience at age 13
- Describes "gang of five" friends who looked out windows, didn't fit school system but became successful
- School system only recognized one intelligence type: "walking filing cabinet" - absorb information, regurgitate in June exams
- Thousands of clever people left school feeling stupid
- Daughter is dyslexic, hated every school day
Institutional Groupthink Problem
- High-achieving students join banks, firms, insurance companies, consultancies on fast track
- Confirmation bias: surround ourselves with people who confirm our biases
- Interview process becomes "Tinder for people who can do Algebra"
- Results in groupthink - everyone thinking same way
- Breeds overconfidence in people who were always "right answer" kids
Dunning-Krueger Effect
- Overconfident people overestimate competences at critical moments
- Bank robbery story: man covered face with lemon juice thinking he'd be invisible (true story)
- Effect more prevalent in men than women
- Personal example: son fails exams despite confidence ("Jesus he stop man no problem")
2008 Financial Crisis Example
- Biggest financial crisis world has ever seen
- Vast majority of economists in Fed, Bank of England, European Central Bank, Wall Street missed it
- Queen of England asked LSE economists: "if you chaps were so clever how come none of you saw this coming?"
- They were all "wearing the juice" - the economics juice
Conventional Thinking Problem
- J.K. Galbraith quote: "when faced with choice between changing his mind and finding proof not to do so, conventional man always gets busy looking for proof"
- Leonard Cohen: "there is a crack in everything and that is how the light gets in"
- Need to look for cracks to see big picture
Call to Action
- Applies Yeats' analysis to current world
- If best people lack conviction and withdraw, worst people with passionate intensity win
- Yeats advocated for poets, artists, musicians as part of solution
- They see possibilities from different angles
- Core message: "listen less to my tribe the economists and listen more to Yeats's tribe the poets"
