AI summary by TwinMind
The Pulitzer Prize: A major award! | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
48m 55s
Introduction and Overview
- Josh and Chuck discuss Pulitzer Prize, major American award with prestige
- Next ceremony May 8th at Columbia University, New York City
- 23 different categories total
- Pronunciation clarification: "Pulitzer" not "Pitzer"
- Awards for distinguished American works across journalism, books, drama, music
- Founded by Joseph Pulitzer, Hungarian immigrant
Joseph Pulitzer Background
- Born April 10, 1847 into wealthy Hungarian family
- Immigrated to America, fought in Civil War for Union (Lincoln Cavalry, 1 year)
- Became newspaper publisher at age 25
- Owned St. Louis Dispatch by age 31
- Took over New York World in 1883
- Made New York World first national newspaper (like USA Today of its time)
- Suffered poor health, noise sensitivity, failing vision
- Retired as editor-in-chief at age 43 but maintained control
- Died 1911
Yellow Journalism Legacy
- Pulitzer helped create yellow journalism using sensationalism, hyperbole
- Rival: William Randolph Hearst (former protégé) with New York Journal American
- Competition over "Yellow Kid" comic character (Hogan's Alley)
- Race to bottom journalism blamed for starting Spanish-American War
- Pulitzer quote: "journalism is or ought to be one of the great intellectual professions"
Prize Establishment
- 1892: Approached Columbia University about journalism graduate school (rejected)
- 1902: Proposed journalism awards after Nobel Prizes launched (1901)
- 1904: Left $250,000 in will for prizes (~$9 million today)
- Also left $2 million for Columbia journalism school (~$71 million today)
- Nicholas Butler (new Columbia president) accepted the money
- First awards given 1917 (6 years after Pulitzer's death)
- Missouri University opened first journalism school 1908
Prize Categories Evolution
- Original 8 awards: 4 journalism, 4 books/drama
- Current 23 categories: 15 journalism, 5 books, 1 drama, 1 music, 1 fellowship
Current Journalism Categories
- Public Service Award: Only category with engraved medal ("Big Daddy")
- Usually goes to entire newsroom organizations
- Breaking News Reporting: Captures events quickly and accurately
- Winners: Denver Post (Columbine), New Orleans Times-Picayune (Katrina 2006)
- Investigative Reporting: Wall Street Journal 2023 (federal agency stock trading conflicts)
- Explanatory Reporting: Complex topics broken down clearly
- Local Reporting: Easier for smaller organizations to win
- National Reporting: Usually larger organizations
- International Reporting: Usually larger organizations
- Feature Writing: Includes style and readability
- Commentary: For columnists, not editorials
- Criticism: Roger Ebert won 1975, Michiko Kakutani
- Editorial Writing: Editorial boards, op-ed writers
- Illustrated Reporting: Editorial cartoons
- 2023 winner: Mona Chalabi (Jeff Bezos wealth illustrations)
- Amazon employee would need to work 4.5 million years (since Pliocene epoch) to reach Bezos wealth
- Breaking News Photography: Usually tragedy, iconic photos
- Feature Photography: Photo series that tells story
- Audio Reporting: New category for podcasts, radio features
Book Categories
- Fiction: Formerly "novels," preferably about American life
- History: American history focus
- Biography: American subjects
- Memoir/Autobiography: Brand new category
- Poetry: American poets
- General Non-fiction: Not memoir/autobiography/biography
Drama and Music
- Drama: Great American plays
- Winners: David Mamet (Glengarry Glen Ross), Lin-Manuel Miranda (Hamilton), August Wilson (Fences)
- Music: Controversial, usually classical music
- Hip-hop: Only Kendrick Lamar won (2017)
- Few jazz artists have won
- Stuffy selection reveals board preferences
Submission Process
- Must pay $75 submission fee
- Hard copy publication required (excludes most self-published ebooks)
- Journalism: Must be from regularly publishing news outlet
- Can be online-only publications
- Broadcast media writers eligible for website content
- Must be published in award year
- Anyone can nominate if they qualify
- "Pulitzer nominated" just means submitted with fee
Selection Process
- ~100 volunteer jurors across 22 categories
- Photography jurors judge both breaking news and feature categories
- Jurors: Former winners, field experts (e.g., Roxane Gay on poetry committee)
- Serve multiple years then rotate out
- Unpaid volunteer positions
Book Jury Workload Mystery
- 6 book juries with 5 jurors each (30 judges total)
- Conflicting information: 300 books per judge vs. 30 books per judge
- 300 books = ~6 books per week (impossible with regular jobs)
- Likely 30 books each, present favorites to committee
- Process deliberately secretive
Final Selection
- February/March meeting at Columbia University
- Jurors narrow to 3 finalists per category
- Board selects winner from finalists (usually)
- Board can select outside finalist pool with 3/4 vote
- Board can move entries between categories
- Example: George Floyd biography moved from biography to general non-fiction
- Can result in no award (happened 12 times in fiction)
- 2021: No editorial cartoon winner despite 3 finalists
- 2012: Three-way tie in fiction, no winner
Organizational Winners
- New York Times: 132 Pulitzers
- Washington Post: 70+ Pulitzers
- Associated Press: 58 Pulitzers
- Big organizations dominate due to budget for extensive reporting
Small Organization Success Stories
- 2017 Storm Lake Times: Editorial writing winner
- Twice-weekly paper, 9 staff, 3,000 circulation, rural Iowa
- Beat New York Times and Wall Street Journal
- 1990 Washington Daily News (North Carolina): Public service winner
- 8,644 circulation
- Exposed city council cover-up of carcinogenic drinking water
- Small town reporters face greater pressure from local officials
Major Controversies
- Janet Cooke (1981): First Black woman journalism winner
- "Jimmy's World" - fabricated story about 8-year-old heroin addict
- Sparked citywide search by Mayor Marion Barry
- Resume fabrication exposed by Toledo Blade
- Returned Pulitzer, moved to France
- Teresa Carpenter received award instead
- Alex Haley (1977): "Roots: The Saga of an American Family"
- Claimed family research basis, later unverified
- Admitted plagiarizing parts from other novels
- Special citation not rescinded
- Walter Duranty (1932): Moscow bureau chief, New York Times
- Won for Stalin dictatorship reporting
- Actually Stalin apologist, covered up Ukrainian deaths
- Quote: "you can't make an omelet without breaking eggs"
- Calls for rescinding award continue, especially during Ukraine war
Criticisms
- Secrecy: Deliberation process not transparent
- Subjectivity: Impossible to compare different topics objectively
- Liberal bias: Tends toward progressive populist issues
- Elitism: Columbia University/academic bent
- Frequency: Same major organizations win repeatedly
- Deadlock possibility: Can result in no winner
Evolution and Modernization
- Pulitzer designed prizes to evolve with times
- Recent additions: Audio reporting, memoir/autobiography
- Upcoming: Broadcast media eligibility expansion
- Board conscious of public perception, responds to criticism over time
- Tied journalism prestige to established arts (drama, music, fiction)
