AI summary by TwinMind

The Pulitzer Prize: A major award! | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

48m 55s

Introduction and Overview

  • Josh and Chuck discuss Pulitzer Prize, major American award with prestige
  • Next ceremony May 8th at Columbia University, New York City
  • 23 different categories total
  • Pronunciation clarification: "Pulitzer" not "Pitzer"
  • Awards for distinguished American works across journalism, books, drama, music
  • Founded by Joseph Pulitzer, Hungarian immigrant

Joseph Pulitzer Background

  • Born April 10, 1847 into wealthy Hungarian family
  • Immigrated to America, fought in Civil War for Union (Lincoln Cavalry, 1 year)
  • Became newspaper publisher at age 25
  • Owned St. Louis Dispatch by age 31
  • Took over New York World in 1883
  • Made New York World first national newspaper (like USA Today of its time)
  • Suffered poor health, noise sensitivity, failing vision
  • Retired as editor-in-chief at age 43 but maintained control
  • Died 1911

Yellow Journalism Legacy

  • Pulitzer helped create yellow journalism using sensationalism, hyperbole
  • Rival: William Randolph Hearst (former protégé) with New York Journal American
  • Competition over "Yellow Kid" comic character (Hogan's Alley)
  • Race to bottom journalism blamed for starting Spanish-American War
  • Pulitzer quote: "journalism is or ought to be one of the great intellectual professions"

Prize Establishment

  • 1892: Approached Columbia University about journalism graduate school (rejected)
  • 1902: Proposed journalism awards after Nobel Prizes launched (1901)
  • 1904: Left $250,000 in will for prizes (~$9 million today)
  • Also left $2 million for Columbia journalism school (~$71 million today)
  • Nicholas Butler (new Columbia president) accepted the money
  • First awards given 1917 (6 years after Pulitzer's death)
  • Missouri University opened first journalism school 1908

Prize Categories Evolution

  • Original 8 awards: 4 journalism, 4 books/drama
  • Current 23 categories: 15 journalism, 5 books, 1 drama, 1 music, 1 fellowship

Current Journalism Categories

  • Public Service Award: Only category with engraved medal ("Big Daddy")
    • Usually goes to entire newsroom organizations
  • Breaking News Reporting: Captures events quickly and accurately
    • Winners: Denver Post (Columbine), New Orleans Times-Picayune (Katrina 2006)
  • Investigative Reporting: Wall Street Journal 2023 (federal agency stock trading conflicts)
  • Explanatory Reporting: Complex topics broken down clearly
  • Local Reporting: Easier for smaller organizations to win
  • National Reporting: Usually larger organizations
  • International Reporting: Usually larger organizations
  • Feature Writing: Includes style and readability
  • Commentary: For columnists, not editorials
  • Criticism: Roger Ebert won 1975, Michiko Kakutani
  • Editorial Writing: Editorial boards, op-ed writers
  • Illustrated Reporting: Editorial cartoons
    • 2023 winner: Mona Chalabi (Jeff Bezos wealth illustrations)
    • Amazon employee would need to work 4.5 million years (since Pliocene epoch) to reach Bezos wealth
  • Breaking News Photography: Usually tragedy, iconic photos
  • Feature Photography: Photo series that tells story
  • Audio Reporting: New category for podcasts, radio features

Book Categories

  • Fiction: Formerly "novels," preferably about American life
  • History: American history focus
  • Biography: American subjects
  • Memoir/Autobiography: Brand new category
  • Poetry: American poets
  • General Non-fiction: Not memoir/autobiography/biography

Drama and Music

  • Drama: Great American plays
    • Winners: David Mamet (Glengarry Glen Ross), Lin-Manuel Miranda (Hamilton), August Wilson (Fences)
  • Music: Controversial, usually classical music
    • Hip-hop: Only Kendrick Lamar won (2017)
    • Few jazz artists have won
    • Stuffy selection reveals board preferences

Submission Process

  • Must pay $75 submission fee
  • Hard copy publication required (excludes most self-published ebooks)
  • Journalism: Must be from regularly publishing news outlet
  • Can be online-only publications
  • Broadcast media writers eligible for website content
  • Must be published in award year
  • Anyone can nominate if they qualify
  • "Pulitzer nominated" just means submitted with fee

Selection Process

  • ~100 volunteer jurors across 22 categories
  • Photography jurors judge both breaking news and feature categories
  • Jurors: Former winners, field experts (e.g., Roxane Gay on poetry committee)
  • Serve multiple years then rotate out
  • Unpaid volunteer positions

Book Jury Workload Mystery

  • 6 book juries with 5 jurors each (30 judges total)
  • Conflicting information: 300 books per judge vs. 30 books per judge
  • 300 books = ~6 books per week (impossible with regular jobs)
  • Likely 30 books each, present favorites to committee
  • Process deliberately secretive

Final Selection

  • February/March meeting at Columbia University
  • Jurors narrow to 3 finalists per category
  • Board selects winner from finalists (usually)
  • Board can select outside finalist pool with 3/4 vote
  • Board can move entries between categories
  • Example: George Floyd biography moved from biography to general non-fiction
  • Can result in no award (happened 12 times in fiction)
  • 2021: No editorial cartoon winner despite 3 finalists
  • 2012: Three-way tie in fiction, no winner

Organizational Winners

  • New York Times: 132 Pulitzers
  • Washington Post: 70+ Pulitzers
  • Associated Press: 58 Pulitzers
  • Big organizations dominate due to budget for extensive reporting

Small Organization Success Stories

  • 2017 Storm Lake Times: Editorial writing winner
    • Twice-weekly paper, 9 staff, 3,000 circulation, rural Iowa
    • Beat New York Times and Wall Street Journal
  • 1990 Washington Daily News (North Carolina): Public service winner
    • 8,644 circulation
    • Exposed city council cover-up of carcinogenic drinking water
    • Small town reporters face greater pressure from local officials

Major Controversies

  • Janet Cooke (1981): First Black woman journalism winner
    • "Jimmy's World" - fabricated story about 8-year-old heroin addict
    • Sparked citywide search by Mayor Marion Barry
    • Resume fabrication exposed by Toledo Blade
    • Returned Pulitzer, moved to France
    • Teresa Carpenter received award instead
  • Alex Haley (1977): "Roots: The Saga of an American Family"
    • Claimed family research basis, later unverified
    • Admitted plagiarizing parts from other novels
    • Special citation not rescinded
  • Walter Duranty (1932): Moscow bureau chief, New York Times
    • Won for Stalin dictatorship reporting
    • Actually Stalin apologist, covered up Ukrainian deaths
    • Quote: "you can't make an omelet without breaking eggs"
    • Calls for rescinding award continue, especially during Ukraine war

Criticisms

  • Secrecy: Deliberation process not transparent
  • Subjectivity: Impossible to compare different topics objectively
  • Liberal bias: Tends toward progressive populist issues
  • Elitism: Columbia University/academic bent
  • Frequency: Same major organizations win repeatedly
  • Deadlock possibility: Can result in no winner

Evolution and Modernization

  • Pulitzer designed prizes to evolve with times
  • Recent additions: Audio reporting, memoir/autobiography
  • Upcoming: Broadcast media eligibility expansion
  • Board conscious of public perception, responds to criticism over time
  • Tied journalism prestige to established arts (drama, music, fiction)

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome