AI summary by TwinMind
The race to mine the bottom of the ocean
Vox
11m 12s
Historical Context and Discovery
- 2012: Canadian mining company sent exploration ship to Clarion-Clipperton Zone (CCZ)
- Located few hundred miles southeast of Hawaii
- Seafloor contains billions of dollars worth of metals/minerals thousands of meters below surface
- 1870s: British HMS Challenger first discovered metallic bounty
- Found peculiar black oval bodies (apple-sized rocks) packed with manganese, cobalt, nickel
- Three types of seafloor metal deposits discovered:
- Hydrothermal vents (underwater hot springs)
- Encrusted slopes/summits of undersea mountains
- Rocks on vast flat plains (most abundant in CCZ)
UN Laws of the Sea Development
- 1958: UN began establishing laws of the sea
- Territorial boundaries established:
- 12 miles from coast = sovereignty territory
- 200 miles = exclusive economic zone (fishing, oil/gas drilling, mining rights)
- Beyond 200 miles = "The Area" (72% of deep ocean)
- Designated "common heritage of all mankind"
- CCZ located in this zone
- 1960s-70s: Multinational companies (China, Japan, Soviet Union, Australia, US, Europe) tested mining equipment in CCZ
- Maltese UN delegate warned against repeating colonialism mistakes
- Feared "handful of nations" would monopolize resources
- "Strong would get stronger, rich richer"
International Seabed Authority (ISA) Formation
- 1982: UN adopted additional laws of the sea, signed by 100+ countries
- Three main mining conditions for "The Area":
- Must benefit all humankind regardless of location
- Consider special interests/needs of developing countries
- Ensure marine environment protection
- ISA established in Kingston, Jamaica to enforce rules
- Current membership: 168 countries + European Union
- 36 countries voted in every few years to review mining applications
Current Mining Applications and Exploration
- ISA approval process:
- 75,000 square kilometer portions granted to applicants
- Equal value portion reserved for developing countries
- Other countries/companies can access reserved areas by partnering with developing nations
- The Metals Company (Canada) partnerships:
- 2012: Partnered with Nauru (Pacific Island nation)
- 2015 & 2020: Added Kiribati and Tonga sponsorships
- Current status: ISA approved all 31 exploration applications
- 22 different companies/countries involved
- 17 applications in CCZ specifically
- 17 exploration ships currently operating (16 beyond original Canadian company)
Mining Technology and Environmental Concerns
- Mining method: Large robotic vacuum sweeps up rocks, pulls to surface
- Proponent arguments:
- Less impact than land-based mining
- Cobalt mining in Congo contaminates waterways
- Nickel mining in Indonesia deforested 1+ million acres rainforest
- Environmental opposition concerns:
- CCZ rocks took millions of years to form
- Unique species adapted to extreme environment (sponges, mollusks, sea cucumbers, starfish)
- Thousands of new species still being discovered
- Mining introduces noise, light, massive sediment plumes traveling miles underwater
- 2020 Japan mining test study results:
- 43% decline in fish/shrimp populations for up to 1 year after sediment plume
- Similar plumes expected from CCZ mining
- 21 countries called for moratorium/ban on deep sea mining
Recent Developments and Future Timeline
- 2021: The Metals Company went public on NYSE
- CEO: "The future is metallic"
- Company and Nauru sent notice to ISA council planning to apply for mining
- Two-year rule triggered: ISA deadline to establish specific mining regulations
- July 2023: ISA meeting reached stalemate
- Pro-mining countries (China, Norway, UK): Clean energy transition needs more metals
- Opposition countries: Insufficient knowledge, risk of irreversible damage, unfair profit sharing
- No regulations issued
- 2024: The Metals Company announced mining application submission
- Resets clock for ISA consensus on regulations
- May win "race to bottom of ocean"
Clean Energy Transition Context
- Current land-based mineral deposits meeting needs so far
- Decarbonization requires up to 6x more metals for clean energy
- CCZ estimates contain more metals than all land-based deposits combined
- Parallel research race: Ships documenting CCZ ecosystem before potential mining damage
