AI summary by TwinMind

The race to mine the bottom of the ocean

Vox

11m 12s

Historical Context and Discovery

  • 2012: Canadian mining company sent exploration ship to Clarion-Clipperton Zone (CCZ)
    • Located few hundred miles southeast of Hawaii
    • Seafloor contains billions of dollars worth of metals/minerals thousands of meters below surface
  • 1870s: British HMS Challenger first discovered metallic bounty
    • Found peculiar black oval bodies (apple-sized rocks) packed with manganese, cobalt, nickel
  • Three types of seafloor metal deposits discovered:
    • Hydrothermal vents (underwater hot springs)
    • Encrusted slopes/summits of undersea mountains
    • Rocks on vast flat plains (most abundant in CCZ)

UN Laws of the Sea Development

  • 1958: UN began establishing laws of the sea
  • Territorial boundaries established:
    • 12 miles from coast = sovereignty territory
    • 200 miles = exclusive economic zone (fishing, oil/gas drilling, mining rights)
    • Beyond 200 miles = "The Area" (72% of deep ocean)
      • Designated "common heritage of all mankind"
      • CCZ located in this zone
  • 1960s-70s: Multinational companies (China, Japan, Soviet Union, Australia, US, Europe) tested mining equipment in CCZ
  • Maltese UN delegate warned against repeating colonialism mistakes
    • Feared "handful of nations" would monopolize resources
    • "Strong would get stronger, rich richer"

International Seabed Authority (ISA) Formation

  • 1982: UN adopted additional laws of the sea, signed by 100+ countries
  • Three main mining conditions for "The Area":
    • Must benefit all humankind regardless of location
    • Consider special interests/needs of developing countries
    • Ensure marine environment protection
  • ISA established in Kingston, Jamaica to enforce rules
  • Current membership: 168 countries + European Union
  • 36 countries voted in every few years to review mining applications

Current Mining Applications and Exploration

  • ISA approval process:
    • 75,000 square kilometer portions granted to applicants
    • Equal value portion reserved for developing countries
    • Other countries/companies can access reserved areas by partnering with developing nations
  • The Metals Company (Canada) partnerships:
    • 2012: Partnered with Nauru (Pacific Island nation)
    • 2015 & 2020: Added Kiribati and Tonga sponsorships
  • Current status: ISA approved all 31 exploration applications
    • 22 different companies/countries involved
    • 17 applications in CCZ specifically
  • 17 exploration ships currently operating (16 beyond original Canadian company)

Mining Technology and Environmental Concerns

  • Mining method: Large robotic vacuum sweeps up rocks, pulls to surface
  • Proponent arguments:
    • Less impact than land-based mining
    • Cobalt mining in Congo contaminates waterways
    • Nickel mining in Indonesia deforested 1+ million acres rainforest
  • Environmental opposition concerns:
    • CCZ rocks took millions of years to form
    • Unique species adapted to extreme environment (sponges, mollusks, sea cucumbers, starfish)
    • Thousands of new species still being discovered
    • Mining introduces noise, light, massive sediment plumes traveling miles underwater
  • 2020 Japan mining test study results:
    • 43% decline in fish/shrimp populations for up to 1 year after sediment plume
    • Similar plumes expected from CCZ mining
  • 21 countries called for moratorium/ban on deep sea mining

Recent Developments and Future Timeline

  • 2021: The Metals Company went public on NYSE
    • CEO: "The future is metallic"
    • Company and Nauru sent notice to ISA council planning to apply for mining
  • Two-year rule triggered: ISA deadline to establish specific mining regulations
  • July 2023: ISA meeting reached stalemate
    • Pro-mining countries (China, Norway, UK): Clean energy transition needs more metals
    • Opposition countries: Insufficient knowledge, risk of irreversible damage, unfair profit sharing
    • No regulations issued
  • 2024: The Metals Company announced mining application submission
    • Resets clock for ISA consensus on regulations
    • May win "race to bottom of ocean"

Clean Energy Transition Context

  • Current land-based mineral deposits meeting needs so far
  • Decarbonization requires up to 6x more metals for clean energy
  • CCZ estimates contain more metals than all land-based deposits combined
  • Parallel research race: Ships documenting CCZ ecosystem before potential mining damage

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome