AI summary by TwinMind

The Race to Take Down the Greatest Insider Trader

Newsthink

19m 5s

Steven Cohen's Background & Rise

  • Born middle-class family Long Island, brightest of 8 siblings
  • Mastered poker in high school, taught art of making money
  • Attended Wharton Business School, felt need to prove himself vs wealthy classmates
  • First job at Gruntal trading firm out of college
    • Made $5-10 million/year in commissions in early 20s
    • Exceptional trading talent recognized by colleagues
  • Early SEC scare: bought RCA shares days before General Electric takeover
    • SEC investigated for insider trading, pled fifth, never charged
    • Ex-wife Patricia said he panicked, feared prison
    • Close call taught him to be more careful

SAC Capital Launch & Strategy

  • 1992: launched SAC Capital hedge fund
  • Hedge fund concept: way for rich to diversify, get stable returns
  • Strategy: buy best companies, short sell poor performers
    • Shorting: borrow stock, sell it, repurchase cheaper to repay loan
    • Dual strategy provides hedge against market fluctuations
  • SAC focused on quick trades vs long-term investing (opposite Warren Buffett)
  • Performance fee: charged whopping 50% vs typical 20%
  • $15 billion managed, 30% average annual returns for 20 years
  • Tech boom '90s benefited SAC significantly

Competitive Edge Through Information

  • Faced increased competition, hired best traders/analysts for "inside scoop"
  • Technically illegal to use proprietary non-public information
  • "Black Edge" like doping in cycling/steroids in baseball - everyone doing it
  • Cohen was best at it, favorite sector: healthcare

Matthew Martoma & Alzheimer's Drug Case

  • Hired Matthew Martoma, biotechnology specialist from Boston
    • MBA from Stanford, $200K base salary + millions in bonuses
  • Martoma focused on Elan Corporation & Wyeth
    • Testing Alzheimer's drug Bapineuzumab ("Bappy")
    • Speculated to be biggest selling drug of all time
  • Connected with Dr. Sydney Gilman via matchmaking firm
    • Chair of safety monitoring committee for Bappy clinical trials
    • Experts compensated $1,000 per 30-minute phone call
    • Gilman signed confidentiality agreement, initially refused to share confidential info

The Gilman-Martoma Relationship

  • Gilman began sharing confidential information as relationship developed
  • Spoke often on phone, sometimes for hours
  • Gilman saw Martoma as son he lost to suicide
  • Martoma capitalized on friendship to access confidential areas
  • Brain swelling side effects discussed - Gilman said sign drug working
    • Alzheimer's caused by beta amyloid plaque buildup
    • Bappy designed to attack plaque, swelling might indicate clearing
  • Martoma sent Cohen memo: conviction rating 9/10 on drug promise
    • Rating system protected Cohen from employee behavior details

The $700 Million Position

  • Spring 2008: Cohen built $700 million positions in Elan & Wyeth based on Martoma's advice
  • Other SAC health traders skeptical, didn't understand huge positions
  • Elan particularly risky as smaller company
  • All during 2008 financial crisis
  • When skeptical analysts approached Cohen with concerns, he accused them of "pissing on the parade"

The Critical Meeting & Information Leak

  • July 2008: Dr. Gilman set to present full drug trial results at International Conference on Alzheimer's Disease, Chicago
  • Martoma arranged meeting claiming to visit late uncle's grave nearby
  • Met at Gilman's University of Michigan office
  • Gilman showed confidential PowerPoint presentation marked "Do not distribute"
  • Results disappointing: Bappy only effective for small group (those without Alzheimer's gene predisposition)
  • Treatment didn't improve with higher doses
  • Martoma explained market doesn't like drug helping only half population

The Massive Trade & Profit

  • July 20, 2008: Martoma emailed Cohen "Is there good time to catch up? It's important"
  • 20-minute phone call between them
  • Next 9 days: SAC liquidated entire Elan position, almost all Wyeth position
    • 17.7 million shares worth ~$700 million
  • Used low visibility accounts & dark pools (anonymous private exchanges)
  • Also shorted nearly 8 million shares of Elan & Wyeth
  • Total profits & avoided losses: $275 million
  • Ironically, SAC hired former SEC chairman to discuss insider trading with employees

Market Reaction & Aftermath

  • When drug failure announced, Elan dropped from $33.75 to below $10 in 3 days
  • Other SAC traders expected disaster, learned SAC had sold positions
  • Dr. Gilman (recovering from cancer) surprised Martoma didn't check on him
  • Martoma received $9 million bonus for drug trades
  • RBC Capital Markets trader noticed unusual activity, filed regulatory complaint

Federal Investigation Begins

  • 2009: arrested Raj Rajaratnam (Galleon Group founder) on securities fraud
  • Wall Street Journal November 2010 article exposed investigation
  • Donald Longgueuil (former SAC manager) panicked, destroyed USB/hard drives
    • Threw them in garbage trucks at night
    • Confessed to Noah Freeman (fellow SAC manager)
    • Freeman was FBI informant wearing wire, recorded conversation
  • Longgueuil pled guilty to insider trading, but didn't implicate Cohen much

Dell Case & Email Evidence

  • SAC analyst John Horvath tipped by Jesse Tortora about Dell earnings disappointment
  • Information chain: Dell insider → hedge fund analyst → Tortora → Horvath
  • Horvath told boss Michael Steinberg: "I have secondhand read from someone at company"
  • Steinberg responded: "Please be discreet"
  • Steinberg shorted Dell, pocketed $1 million profit
  • Cohen sold entire 500,000 share long position 2 days before earnings
  • After earnings: Cohen complimented "Nice job on Dell"
  • Steinberg: "Thanks. This old dog can still hunt"
  • Email reached Cohen through multiple managers

Legal Defense & Convictions

  • Cohen's lawyer Marty Klotz argued Cohen received thousands daily emails
  • Even if seen, no clear evidence of insider trading since source unknown
  • December 18, 2013: Steinberg found guilty, fainted before verdict
  • Sentenced 3.5 years prison, refused to cooperate with authorities
  • SAC structure described as bicycle wheel: portfolio managers as spokes, Cohen as hub

Martoma's Refusal to Cooperate

  • FBI certain Martoma would flip on Cohen to avoid 10-year sentence
  • Surprisingly refused to turn against Cohen
  • Even after SAC fired him as "one-trick pony"
  • Pled fifth, refused to incriminate self or boss
  • Martoma's lawyer on SAC payroll
  • Cohen admitted investing in Elan based on Martoma's advice, never specified what advice was
  • Never mentioned Dr. Gilman

Trial & Sentencing

  • Dr. Gilman painted as victim - lonely older man charmed by young trader
  • Resigned from University of Michigan in disgrace
  • Gilman said Martoma reminded him of deceased son who committed suicide
  • FBI agent told Gilman: "I am only grain of sand, as is Mr. Martoma. They are really after Steven A. Cohen"
  • Three theories for Martoma's silence:
    • Honor (didn't want to snitch)
    • Fear of retribution
    • Hope Cohen would repay loyalty financially
  • Martoma's father cited ninth commandment: "Thou shalt not bear false witness"
  • Martoma found guilty securities fraud, sentenced 9 years prison
  • Day Martoma started sentence: Cohen spent $101 million at Sotheby's on Alberto Giacometti sculpture "The Chariot"

Cohen's Outcome & Aftermath

  • Never charged with insider trading
  • SEC dropped insider trading charge, instead charged failure to supervise Steinberg & Martoma
  • No criminal charges against Cohen personally
  • SAC Capital pled guilty, paid $1.8 billion fines
  • SAC agreed to stop managing outside money, convert to family office
  • Could only manage personal $10 billion wealth
  • SAC rebranded to Point72 Asset Management
  • 2018: family office reopened to outside investors
  • Last year generated $2.4 billion profit
  • 2020: bought New York Mets for $2.4 billion
  • Continued buying art & trading

Personal Details

  • Lived in 35,000 sq ft Greenwich, Connecticut mansion
  • Flew to work by helicopter
  • Art collection valued $1 billion including $8 million shark suspended in formaldehyde
  • Nicknamed "ultimate predator" for trading instincts

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome