AI summary by TwinMind
The radical act of choosing common ground | Nisha Anand
TED
15m 58s
Personal Background and Family History
- Speaker: Nisha Anand, discussing concept of "radical common ground"
- Family origin: Father born during 1947 Indian partition
- 15 million people trapped on wrong side of new borders
- 2 million people died during partition
- Father youngest baby in Hindu family on wrong side of border
- Family went into hiding from armed men
- Muslim family took them in, swore on Quran they weren't hiding anyone
- Chose shared humanity over politics of division
- Speaker born late 1970s as first-generation American
- Brown girl in Black and white South (Atlanta, Georgia)
- Perfect Indian daughter (straight As, debate team captain) + radical feminist punk-rock activist
- Natural bridge-builder between cultures and identities
Early Activism and Political Tribalism
- Moved to Bay Area 2001, start of second Iraq War
- Organized with activists but stayed in narrow circles
- "Great anarchist versus communist soccer tournament of 2001" - example of limited bridge-building
- Wouldn't work with liberal Democrats or local electeds ("bridge too far")
- 2020 division worse: won't sit at dinner with people who voted differently
- Cancel culture over mean tweets that don't fit worldview
- Purity politics preventing progress
The Commons Concept
- Historical idea: shared place in center of town (town square, quad)
- Place where community comes together despite differences
- Listened to different ideas on soapboxes
- "Together we're stronger than being apart"
- Modern commons: collectively owned resources
- Air we breathe
- Schools, parks
- Intelligence shared in libraries/internet
- Internet has potential for shared humanity but not being used that way
- Must choose love to enter commons
- "Can't lead people you don't love"
- "Can't change world saying 'only for people like me'"
Echo Chambers and Silos
- Current reality: separate information ecosystems
- Speaker's Berkeley Democratic Socialist commons vs father's "bootstrappy immigrant Republican commons"
- Different media consumption (MSNBC example)
- Won't know same things or know each other
- Need to find way back to commons
Criminal Justice Reform Case Study
- 1994 Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act (crime bill)
- Terrible law enabling mass incarceration
- Mandatory minimums, three-strikes laws, expanded death penalty
- Bipartisan support: GOP House Speaker Newt Gingrich + Democratic President Bill Clinton
- Speaker protested crime bill as high school senior in 1994
- 2015: Photo with Newt Gingrich starting movement for First Step Act
- Van Jones mentorship 7 years ago
- Predicted bipartisan criminal justice reform
- Speaker initially laughed (seemed like oxymoron)
- Had protested at 2000 Republican National Convention with no Republicans present
Coalition Building Strategy
- Left perspective: issue of dignity and justice
- System racist since start
- Discriminates against poor people and people of color
- Right perspectives identified:
- Fiscal Conservatives: economic incentive
- System costs taxpayers money with terrible results
- Doesn't make communities safer
- Libertarian Right: less government belief
- Mass incarceration = expansion of government control
- Antithetical to their values
- Religious Right: second chances and redemption values
- Criminal justice system doesn't reflect these values
- Fiscal Conservatives: economic incentive
- Built bipartisan coalition under leadership of formerly incarcerated folks
First Step Act Results
- 87 senators voted in favor
- President Trump signed into law
- New York Times called it "most significant reform in criminal justice in a generation"
- Impact in just last year:
- 20,000 people impacted
- 7,000 people home who wouldn't have been
- 17,000 years of human freedom restored
- Current election cycle: Republicans and Democrats running on criminal justice reform platforms
- Office receives videos of people coming home almost daily
- 2.2 million people still behind bars
Expanding to Other Issues
- Challenge: make this approach possible across other issues
- Human rights, immigration, health care, mental health
- Example partnerships:
- Jenny Kim, deputy general counsel at Koch Industries
- Serious about second-chance hiring
- Pathway to jobs for formerly incarcerated
- Amazing organizer on this issue
- Climate change partnership potential
- Trump's Department of Defense report: future wars will be about resources/climate
- Seeking partnership with military
- Speaker was national organizer for War Resisters League (oldest pacifist organization)
- Jenny Kim, deputy general counsel at Koch Industries
Call to Action Framework
- Need to find love and shared humanity
- Step into courage like Muslim family did for Hindu family
- Feeling uncomfortable precedes every major breakthrough in human history
- "That feeling that comes before a moonshot"
- Exercise for audience:
- Think of issue you care deeply about (national/global scale)
- What would resolution look like?
- Can't get there with just circle of friends
- Where is common ground to be found?
- Who are unlikely allies/strange partners?
- Who's in your way? Is there room for them in circle?
- Final questions: "Who's your Newt? Who's the military in your story?"
