AI summary by TwinMind
The Real Life Sci-Fi of Vertical Take-Off Planes
Real Engineering
8m 41s
Historical Development of VTOL Aircraft
- German WWII experiments to eliminate runway dependency
- Erich Baucom's tail-sitting rocket-powered BP 349
- Pilot took control in final flight stages to guide to target
- Only manned test resulted in pilot death, idea abandoned
- Three-propeller aircraft with Ram Jets at blade tips
- Functioned like helicopter for takeoff, transitioned to forward flight
- Required nose-up position for adequate lift (no wings)
- Only reached basic wind tunnel testing
- Erich Baucom's tail-sitting rocket-powered BP 349
Early Post-War VTOL Attempts
- Lockheed XF-90 Pogo planes (1950s)
- Used massive counter-rotating turboprop propellers
- Only managed brief hover while transitioning horizontal to vertical flight
- Convair XFV Pogo (Lieutenant Colonel James Coleman)
- First aircraft to successfully fly in both forward aerodynamic and vertical flight
- Both programs canceled due to flying difficulty, lack of speed/lifting power
- Propeller-driven engines insufficient for necessary lift
- Required increased rotor velocity or diameter
- Decreased max horizontal speed as blade tips approached sound barrier
Jet-Powered VTOL Breakthrough
- Rolls-Royce thrust measuring rig ("flying bedstead")
- First aircraft using jet propulsion for vertical takeoff
- Influenced Lunar Lander training vehicle design
- NASA developed for Neil Armstrong and astronauts
- Engine mounted on gimbal for downward thrust
- Simulated moon's gravity
- Hydrogen peroxide rockets for control
- Armstrong credited success of moon landing to this training
Harrier Design and Engineering
- Rolls-Royce Pegasus engine development
- Required thrust to lift entire aircraft weight
- Carbon-fiber composites used for weight reduction (first planes to use these materials)
- Engine configuration
- Similar to traditional jet: low-pressure compressor fan, high-pressure compressor, combustion chamber, high/low pressure turbines
- Four nozzle outlets instead of single opening
- First two nozzles: air from low-pressure compressors
- Final two: air from higher pressure turbines
- Low-pressure nozzles placed further from center of gravity than high-pressure nozzles for balance
Control Systems and Limitations
- Vertical takeoff mode control challenges
- No airflow over wings for control surfaces
- Air-bleed nozzles on nose, tail, and wingtips for roll/pitch/yaw control
- Less reliable than aerodynamic lift (not self-correcting)
- Ground effect from own jet causes oscillations that can overwhelm control system
- Pilots often dropped plane heavily from few meters to avoid oscillations
- Weight and fuel limitations
- Vertical takeoff severely limited max takeoff weight
- Burned significant fuel in intensive maneuver, reducing range
- Most takeoffs partial vertical: runway acceleration + angled nozzles
- Max takeoff weight: 9.4 metric tons (vertical) to 14 metric tons (partial)
Performance Comparisons
- Harrier vs FA-18 Hornet specifications
- Harrier: 14 metric tons max takeoff, 0.9 Mach subsonic speed
- FA-18: 23.5 tonnes max takeoff, 1.8 Mach maximum speed
- Hornet more capable attack platform but requires large carriers
- Harrier launches from amphibious assault ships (USS America)
- Harrier emergency landing on cargo ship when pilot lost radio contact and fuel
Future Development: F-35
- Both Harrier and Hornet slated for F-35 replacement
- F-35 VTOL capabilities
- Directional rear thrust and shaft-driven lift fan
- Futuristic VR helmets for pilot to see through plane
- Six infrared cameras surrounding aircraft
- Advanced laser targeting and radar capabilities
- Stealth technology integration
- Development challenges
- Deeply entrenched in US politics
- Huge developmental costs
- Supports thousands of American jobs
- Repeated delays due to ambitious technological leap
- Will become most advanced plane in history when operational
