AI summary by TwinMind
The Rise of the "Trauma Essay" in College Applications | Tina Yong | TED
TED
12m 47s
Personal Immigration Story Context
- Speaker immigrated to Canada at age 10 with family
- Only Asian kid in grade, experienced racism, teasing for broken English, Asian features, ethnic lunches
- Ate lunch alone in bathroom, begged mom for PB&J sandwiches
- Used this story in academic essays, job interviews, university applications
- Despite truth, speaker has come to hate this narrative
The Trauma Essay Phenomenon
- Common pattern: immigrant kids across country regurgitate similar stories to prestigious universities
- Universities consume these stories, return acceptance letters
- Story contents vary (immigration, death, illness, racism) but moral remains constant: "bad thing happened but made me good person"
- Overwhelming pressure on high school students to write about deepest traumas
- Goal: appear resilient and interesting enough for admission spot
Admissions Counselor Influence
- MIT admissions blog example comparing two essay introductions:
- First: "I'm honored to apply... love affair with books since 11, wanted to be librarian"
- Second: "When I was 11 great-aunt Gretchen passed away, left me 5,000 books library"
- Author notes second introduction "much more striking, leaves better impression"
- College essay advice from scguy.com: "get personal, include painful memories and learnings"
- Claims this approach makes applicants appear "humble, accessible, likable, mature"
Racial Disparities in Essay Content
- Aya Waller Bay (former Georgetown admissions officer) observed differences:
- Black students highlighted resilience through survival stories
- White students wrote casual essays about service abroad, sporting championships
- "Black students shared their pain, white students shared their passions"
Why Trauma Essays Are Harmful
Psychological Burden
- Writing about difficult experiences is inherently difficult
- Requires reliving events while suppressing negative emotions
- Emotional labor especially taxing for young applicants who haven't processed trauma
- Confessing to faceless stranger who makes consequential life decisions creates heavy psychological burden
- Analogy: therapist who only responds with rejection/acceptance email months later
Problematic Assumptions
- Assumes trauma is always learning opportunity for confidence/skill development
- Reality: "sometimes it's just a sucky thing that really sucks"
- Asking students to prove pain-to-progress transformation ignores truth
- Falls into toxic positivity narrative that "everything happens for a reason"
- Ignores valid resentment and anger victims still feel
Commodification of Pain
- Writing shapes how we view experiences, not just reflects them
- Writing trauma to prove worthiness requires sanitizing pain
- Must make trauma "marketable and strategic"
- Scrub away suffering to fit "narrow margins of what is palatable"
- Fundamental contradiction: seems to allow vulnerability but actually restricts it
The Trauma Essay Formula
- Must be "just sad enough" for sympathy but not "so sad" seems beyond help
- "Just critical enough" to inspire change but not criticize systemic structures
- "Just honest enough" to seem real but not "so unfiltered" creates discomfort
- Protagonist must overcome struggle by 500-word count
- Instills optimism that despite inequality, possible to "rise through ranks and overcome all isms"
Speaker's Personal Reflection
- Settled for "familiar story of stinky lunch" devoid of real meaning
- Avoided discussing:
- Ongoing social/political disenfranchisement of immigrants
- Permanent loss of cultural identity
- Sense of disbelonging from grammar mistakes, name mispronunciations
- These struggles "never really go away" but tucked away because don't fit linear narrative
University Responsibility
- Universities never explicitly ask for trauma dumping
- Many admissions experts discourage explicit trauma discussion
- But trauma essays seem to be "working" - appear successful
- Anne Trebek (Oberlin College essay helper) ethical dilemma:
- "By pushing students to reveal horror stories I risk taking away dignity"
- "By not pushing I could be hindering chances of getting into dream school"
- Unclear if trauma essays actually causally correlated with acceptance
- Universities fail to "resolutely clear up speculation" about whether trauma essays rewarded/discouraged
- Indirectly enabling rise of trauma essay through lack of clarity
Proposed Solutions
Root Causes
- Problem deeper than individual universities or higher education institution
- Rooted in cultural obsession with appropriating trauma, making it consumable
- Systemic tendency to tokenize oppressed people and experiences
University Actions
- Be more transparent about admissions guidelines
- If don't want to reward trauma storytelling, be forthcoming about expectation
- Restructure prompts to avoid pressure about past hardships/adversities
- Refocus prompts on future goals and academic interests
- Train admissions counselors to be trauma-informed and skilled working with BIPOC students
- Counselors should wield power responsibly, not pressure students to discuss unprocessed trauma
For Applicants
- "Remember you are more than bad things that happen to you"
- When classmates writing "HBO original drama" essays, your experiences still worth discussing
- "Find your voice and use it"
Alternative Essay Possibilities
- Speaker reflects on what she might have written without pressure:
- Overcoming fear of public speaking, becoming comfortable as loudest voice
- How trashy reality TV sparked interest in political science
- Still immigrant story but "on my own terms"
- Not "one-dimensional trauma-turned triumph drama"
- Story reflecting who she is today
- Acknowledging ongoing journey that doesn't begin/end with racial identity
Conclusion
- Wishes everyone could have ownership over their story
- "Now it's up for universities to decide whether they get to tell it"
