AI summary by TwinMind

The Rise of the "Trauma Essay" in College Applications | Tina Yong | TED

TED

12m 47s

Personal Immigration Story Context

  • Speaker immigrated to Canada at age 10 with family
  • Only Asian kid in grade, experienced racism, teasing for broken English, Asian features, ethnic lunches
  • Ate lunch alone in bathroom, begged mom for PB&J sandwiches
  • Used this story in academic essays, job interviews, university applications
  • Despite truth, speaker has come to hate this narrative

The Trauma Essay Phenomenon

  • Common pattern: immigrant kids across country regurgitate similar stories to prestigious universities
  • Universities consume these stories, return acceptance letters
  • Story contents vary (immigration, death, illness, racism) but moral remains constant: "bad thing happened but made me good person"
  • Overwhelming pressure on high school students to write about deepest traumas
  • Goal: appear resilient and interesting enough for admission spot

Admissions Counselor Influence

  • MIT admissions blog example comparing two essay introductions:
    • First: "I'm honored to apply... love affair with books since 11, wanted to be librarian"
    • Second: "When I was 11 great-aunt Gretchen passed away, left me 5,000 books library"
    • Author notes second introduction "much more striking, leaves better impression"
  • College essay advice from scguy.com: "get personal, include painful memories and learnings"
  • Claims this approach makes applicants appear "humble, accessible, likable, mature"

Racial Disparities in Essay Content

  • Aya Waller Bay (former Georgetown admissions officer) observed differences:
    • Black students highlighted resilience through survival stories
    • White students wrote casual essays about service abroad, sporting championships
    • "Black students shared their pain, white students shared their passions"

Why Trauma Essays Are Harmful

Psychological Burden

  • Writing about difficult experiences is inherently difficult
  • Requires reliving events while suppressing negative emotions
  • Emotional labor especially taxing for young applicants who haven't processed trauma
  • Confessing to faceless stranger who makes consequential life decisions creates heavy psychological burden
  • Analogy: therapist who only responds with rejection/acceptance email months later

Problematic Assumptions

  • Assumes trauma is always learning opportunity for confidence/skill development
  • Reality: "sometimes it's just a sucky thing that really sucks"
  • Asking students to prove pain-to-progress transformation ignores truth
  • Falls into toxic positivity narrative that "everything happens for a reason"
  • Ignores valid resentment and anger victims still feel

Commodification of Pain

  • Writing shapes how we view experiences, not just reflects them
  • Writing trauma to prove worthiness requires sanitizing pain
  • Must make trauma "marketable and strategic"
  • Scrub away suffering to fit "narrow margins of what is palatable"
  • Fundamental contradiction: seems to allow vulnerability but actually restricts it

The Trauma Essay Formula

  • Must be "just sad enough" for sympathy but not "so sad" seems beyond help
  • "Just critical enough" to inspire change but not criticize systemic structures
  • "Just honest enough" to seem real but not "so unfiltered" creates discomfort
  • Protagonist must overcome struggle by 500-word count
  • Instills optimism that despite inequality, possible to "rise through ranks and overcome all isms"

Speaker's Personal Reflection

  • Settled for "familiar story of stinky lunch" devoid of real meaning
  • Avoided discussing:
    • Ongoing social/political disenfranchisement of immigrants
    • Permanent loss of cultural identity
    • Sense of disbelonging from grammar mistakes, name mispronunciations
  • These struggles "never really go away" but tucked away because don't fit linear narrative

University Responsibility

  • Universities never explicitly ask for trauma dumping
  • Many admissions experts discourage explicit trauma discussion
  • But trauma essays seem to be "working" - appear successful
  • Anne Trebek (Oberlin College essay helper) ethical dilemma:
    • "By pushing students to reveal horror stories I risk taking away dignity"
    • "By not pushing I could be hindering chances of getting into dream school"
  • Unclear if trauma essays actually causally correlated with acceptance
  • Universities fail to "resolutely clear up speculation" about whether trauma essays rewarded/discouraged
  • Indirectly enabling rise of trauma essay through lack of clarity

Proposed Solutions

Root Causes

  • Problem deeper than individual universities or higher education institution
  • Rooted in cultural obsession with appropriating trauma, making it consumable
  • Systemic tendency to tokenize oppressed people and experiences

University Actions

  • Be more transparent about admissions guidelines
  • If don't want to reward trauma storytelling, be forthcoming about expectation
  • Restructure prompts to avoid pressure about past hardships/adversities
  • Refocus prompts on future goals and academic interests
  • Train admissions counselors to be trauma-informed and skilled working with BIPOC students
  • Counselors should wield power responsibly, not pressure students to discuss unprocessed trauma

For Applicants

  • "Remember you are more than bad things that happen to you"
  • When classmates writing "HBO original drama" essays, your experiences still worth discussing
  • "Find your voice and use it"

Alternative Essay Possibilities

  • Speaker reflects on what she might have written without pressure:
    • Overcoming fear of public speaking, becoming comfortable as loudest voice
    • How trashy reality TV sparked interest in political science
    • Still immigrant story but "on my own terms"
    • Not "one-dimensional trauma-turned triumph drama"
    • Story reflecting who she is today
    • Acknowledging ongoing journey that doesn't begin/end with racial identity

Conclusion

  • Wishes everyone could have ownership over their story
  • "Now it's up for universities to decide whether they get to tell it"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome