AI summary by TwinMind
The Semiconductor Bust. Still Coming?
Asianometry
14m 13s
Video Introduction & Context
- Follow-up to previous "Coming Semiconductor Bust" video from year ago
- Acknowledges not being semiconductor industry expert
- Recommends Semi-Analysis and Fabricated Knowledge newsletters for professional analysis
Memory vs Logic Market Dynamics
- Intel CEO Pat Gelsinger interview with Ben Thompson: last logic surplus over decade ago vs memory surplus 3.5 years ago
- Memory chips (DRAM, NAND): commodity products, short life cycles, fierce price competition
- Logic chips (microcontrollers, AI accelerators, CPUs, GPUs): more customization, complexity, specialization
- Logic business cycles more resilient due to non-commodity nature
2019 Memory Bust Analysis
- Global semiconductor sales declined 12% from 2018
- Memory drove decline: 30% revenue drop (quarter of market)
- Samsung, SK Hynix, Micron all saw ~30% revenue declines
- Non-memory products declined only 1.7% in 2019
- Supports Gelsinger's thesis about logic resilience
Fab Capacity Expansion Plans 2022-2025
- Logic fab projects: 33 total announced
- Companies: Intel, TSMC, Samsung, UMC, Texas Instruments, Tower, ST Micro, Toshiba, Infineon, SMIC
- Projected 1.2 million new logic wafers by 2025
- Three-quarters from Intel, TSMC, SMIC alone
- Memory fab projects: 10 total announced
- Companies: Micron, SK Hynix, Winbond, Nanya, Kioxia, Samsung
- Projected 513,000 new memory wafers by 2025
Capacity Impact Calculations
- 2021: 14.8 billion square inches semiconductor shipments
- Assuming half logic: adding ~20% additional logic capacity 2024-2025
- Industry projections: 10% growth in 2022 alone
- Haven't seen 20%+ three-year growth since period leading to 2019 bust
Demand Shift: Mobile to Cloud Computing
- Previous decade: smartphone growth drove logic industry post-2008 crisis
- iPhone 3G, App Store, Android fueled rapid performance demands
- Q1 2020: TSMC 50% revenue from smartphones, but -9% quarter-over-quarter growth
- Smartphone sales hit steady state 2016, 80% ownership, less frequent upgrades
- 5G expected to drive next wave but pandemic changed dynamics
Cloud Computing Explosion
- Pandemic drove unexpected data center demand
- Drivers: video games, streaming, work-from-home, AI/ML adoption
- Hyperscalers (Amazon, Google, Microsoft) growing 30% year-over-year
- Q4 2021: AWS $18 billion revenue, 40% growth, $71 billion run rate
- Q1 2022: Microsoft Azure 50% growth
- Hyperscalers spending estimated $150 billion capex 2022
TSMC Revenue Shift
- Q1 2022: 41% revenue from High Performance Computing (HPC/cloud)
- Two years ago: 30% from HPC
- HPC grew 26% quarter-over-quarter
- Automotive also growing but smaller segment
Pandemic Play Reversals
- Netflix lost 35% market cap, first subscriber loss in 10 years
- Zoom conversion rates returning to pre-pandemic levels
- E-commerce share reverting to secular trend from 2020 highs
- Wall Street Journal noted e-commerce snapback hurting scaled-up companies
Future Outlook Factors
- Some permanent changes: partial work-from-home, streaming retention, cloud migration, AI/EV growth
- Secular trend still positive but growth may decelerate
- Cloud may not maintain 30-50% year-over-year growth rates
Predictions
- Cloud computing revenue growth will decelerate due to law of large numbers or return to pre-pandemic normal
- Semiconductor bust more likely in memory than logic
- Memory makers more affected as products remain commodities
- Hyperscaler data centers have big memory demand
- Massive logic capacity buildout won't cause 2009-style crash
- May result in slightly lower prices and broken promises
- Leading edge slowdown won't affect trailing edge shortages
- 65nm+ nodes have different dynamics
- Specialty technologies (MEMS, analog) also different
- No prediction on individual chip company stocks
