AI summary by TwinMind

The Semiconductor Neon Shortage

Asianometry

9m 22s

Ukraine's Role in Global Neon Supply

  • Ukraine is world's leading supplier of neon gas (over 50% of global production)
  • Houses several large air separation units (ASUs)
  • Russia's invasion creates major potential effects on global semiconductor production
  • Not due to semiconductor fabs in these countries, but critical material supply disruption

Neon Gas Properties and Production

  • Noble gas found naturally in air at 18.2 parts per million concentration
  • High purity: colorless, odorless, inert
  • Most known for characteristic glowing signs (legitimate neon = reddish orange hue)
  • Industrial uses: vacuum tubes, aerospace, chemistry, cryogenics, infrared imaging systems, OLED flat panel displays

Air Separation Plant (ASU) Production Process

  • Neon extracted as byproduct in multi-million dollar ASUs
  • Primary purpose: extract oxygen for chemical/metallurgical facilities
  • Process accumulates crude neon-helium mixtures (NHM)
  • NHM interferes with main operations, must be removed
  • Extra work required to purify from 30-40% to 99.999% purity
  • Most ASUs just vent gas byproducts due to high energy costs
  • Only largest ASUs find purification economically viable
  • Process pioneered by French chemist George Claude ("Edison of France")
  • Led to foundation of Air Liquide (now $60 billion company)

Semiconductor Industry Usage

  • Photolithography takes 70% of global neon production
  • Fastest growing market in $20 billion industry
  • Critical material for excimer lasers in DUV lithography steppers
  • Used in 193 nanometer argon fluoride excimer lasers
  • Most advanced commercial photolithography systems short of EUV
  • 193i immersion lithography technically feasible until 7nm node
  • Economics of 7nm without EUV unclear

Excimer Laser Operation

  • Manufacturers: Cymer, Gigaphoton
  • High power output, stability, reliability
  • Cavity filled with gas blend (argon, fluorine, neon)
  • Neon comprises over 95% of mix despite "argon fluoride" name
  • Electrode introduces high energy electrical pulse discharge
  • Ionizes argon and fluorine atoms
  • Ions temporarily excited, merge into argon fluoride
  • Argon fluoride disassociates, releases deep ultraviolet photons
  • Photons bounce between mirrors (one fully reflective, one partially)
  • Light bursts through partially reflective mirror onto wafer
  • Neon increases excitation rate of argon fluoride reaction
  • Can be replaced with helium/other noble gases but less effective or more costly

Gas Degradation and Replacement

  • Neon exposed to energetic ions, degrades and accumulates impurities
  • Requires replacement every couple weeks
  • Either total replacement or occasional partial injection

Industry Response to Supply Concerns

2015-2016 Shortage Response

  • Unrest in Ukraine led to semiconductor industry availability concerns
  • Multi-step response process implemented

Short-term Solutions

  • Cymer reverted to older, less gas-intensive methodologies
  • Achieved 50% gas savings immediately
  • Stretched intervals between refreshes and injections
  • Modified algorithms controlling gas injections
  • Achieved additional 30-50% usage reduction without performance compromise

Long-term Solutions: Neon Recycling Technology

  • Cymer, Gigaphoton introduced recycling systems
  • Previously exhausted noble gases vented to atmosphere (except toxic fluorine)
  • Used gases now extracted from laser chamber
  • Transported to external facility for purification
  • Continuously funneled into recovery tank under clean room floor
  • Full tank air filtered using absorption columns
  • Removes nitrogen, oxygen, argon impurities
  • Sent back into laser chamber
  • 85-92% efficiency process
  • Can be done within fab itself
  • No effect on laser performance, energy stability, wafer loss

Economic Considerations

  • Recycling 15x cheaper energy-wise than generating new gas in ASU
  • Gas is commodity, rather cheap to acquire
  • Fabs not incentivized for cost reasons alone
  • Requires re-engineering excimer laser design
  • External scrubber unit under clean room floor
  • Production must stop for installation
  • Substantial financial trade-off

Cost Analysis

  • Recycling saves ~$450,000/year per system
  • Based on $3/liter neon price assumption
  • End of January 2022: cost ~$9/liter
  • Might make more sense to buy gas even at higher prices
  • Cymer 2016: 16% adoption rate across 2,500+ unit base

Current Industry Status

Company Responses

  • TSMC: impact to supply chain will be limited
  • Many other wafer fabs (especially DUV machines) on short margins
  • Probably didn't invest in recycling equipment/processes
  • Companies with recycling investment should be fine

Supply Alternatives

  • China: growing supplier
  • Other facilities elsewhere
  • Extended shortage can cause supply issues if alternatives insufficient
  • Industry has experience with previous shortages
  • Expects ultimately minor impact

Other Applications

  • Medical: 193nm lasers for LASIK surgery
  • Nuclear fusion applications

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome