AI summary by TwinMind
The Semiconductor Neon Shortage
Asianometry
9m 22s
Ukraine's Role in Global Neon Supply
- Ukraine is world's leading supplier of neon gas (over 50% of global production)
- Houses several large air separation units (ASUs)
- Russia's invasion creates major potential effects on global semiconductor production
- Not due to semiconductor fabs in these countries, but critical material supply disruption
Neon Gas Properties and Production
- Noble gas found naturally in air at 18.2 parts per million concentration
- High purity: colorless, odorless, inert
- Most known for characteristic glowing signs (legitimate neon = reddish orange hue)
- Industrial uses: vacuum tubes, aerospace, chemistry, cryogenics, infrared imaging systems, OLED flat panel displays
Air Separation Plant (ASU) Production Process
- Neon extracted as byproduct in multi-million dollar ASUs
- Primary purpose: extract oxygen for chemical/metallurgical facilities
- Process accumulates crude neon-helium mixtures (NHM)
- NHM interferes with main operations, must be removed
- Extra work required to purify from 30-40% to 99.999% purity
- Most ASUs just vent gas byproducts due to high energy costs
- Only largest ASUs find purification economically viable
- Process pioneered by French chemist George Claude ("Edison of France")
- Led to foundation of Air Liquide (now $60 billion company)
Semiconductor Industry Usage
- Photolithography takes 70% of global neon production
- Fastest growing market in $20 billion industry
- Critical material for excimer lasers in DUV lithography steppers
- Used in 193 nanometer argon fluoride excimer lasers
- Most advanced commercial photolithography systems short of EUV
- 193i immersion lithography technically feasible until 7nm node
- Economics of 7nm without EUV unclear
Excimer Laser Operation
- Manufacturers: Cymer, Gigaphoton
- High power output, stability, reliability
- Cavity filled with gas blend (argon, fluorine, neon)
- Neon comprises over 95% of mix despite "argon fluoride" name
- Electrode introduces high energy electrical pulse discharge
- Ionizes argon and fluorine atoms
- Ions temporarily excited, merge into argon fluoride
- Argon fluoride disassociates, releases deep ultraviolet photons
- Photons bounce between mirrors (one fully reflective, one partially)
- Light bursts through partially reflective mirror onto wafer
- Neon increases excitation rate of argon fluoride reaction
- Can be replaced with helium/other noble gases but less effective or more costly
Gas Degradation and Replacement
- Neon exposed to energetic ions, degrades and accumulates impurities
- Requires replacement every couple weeks
- Either total replacement or occasional partial injection
Industry Response to Supply Concerns
2015-2016 Shortage Response
- Unrest in Ukraine led to semiconductor industry availability concerns
- Multi-step response process implemented
Short-term Solutions
- Cymer reverted to older, less gas-intensive methodologies
- Achieved 50% gas savings immediately
- Stretched intervals between refreshes and injections
- Modified algorithms controlling gas injections
- Achieved additional 30-50% usage reduction without performance compromise
Long-term Solutions: Neon Recycling Technology
- Cymer, Gigaphoton introduced recycling systems
- Previously exhausted noble gases vented to atmosphere (except toxic fluorine)
- Used gases now extracted from laser chamber
- Transported to external facility for purification
- Continuously funneled into recovery tank under clean room floor
- Full tank air filtered using absorption columns
- Removes nitrogen, oxygen, argon impurities
- Sent back into laser chamber
- 85-92% efficiency process
- Can be done within fab itself
- No effect on laser performance, energy stability, wafer loss
Economic Considerations
- Recycling 15x cheaper energy-wise than generating new gas in ASU
- Gas is commodity, rather cheap to acquire
- Fabs not incentivized for cost reasons alone
- Requires re-engineering excimer laser design
- External scrubber unit under clean room floor
- Production must stop for installation
- Substantial financial trade-off
Cost Analysis
- Recycling saves ~$450,000/year per system
- Based on $3/liter neon price assumption
- End of January 2022: cost ~$9/liter
- Might make more sense to buy gas even at higher prices
- Cymer 2016: 16% adoption rate across 2,500+ unit base
Current Industry Status
Company Responses
- TSMC: impact to supply chain will be limited
- Many other wafer fabs (especially DUV machines) on short margins
- Probably didn't invest in recycling equipment/processes
- Companies with recycling investment should be fine
Supply Alternatives
- China: growing supplier
- Other facilities elsewhere
- Extended shortage can cause supply issues if alternatives insufficient
- Industry has experience with previous shortages
- Expects ultimately minor impact
Other Applications
- Medical: 193nm lasers for LASIK surgery
- Nuclear fusion applications
