AI summary by TwinMind

The Spectacular Rise (and Imminent Collapse) of Private Equity

How Money Works

13m 12s

Private Equity Definition and Business Model

  • Private equity = investment into assets not listed on public markets
  • Hundreds of thousands of profitable businesses unavailable through public exchanges
  • Private companies lack reporting requirements, making valuation difficult/time-consuming
  • PE firms act as middlemen offering rich investors access to untapped markets
  • Pitch to billionaires/pension fund managers: higher returns than stock market, less volatility, safer from crashes
  • Employed "crack team of best analysts" to find/buy private companies and extract maximum money

Reason 1: Misleading Returns Through Valuation Manipulation

  • Returns weren't as great as they appeared due to "Schrödinger's cat" valuation trick
  • Private company values hard to determine even by insiders with full financial access
  • No instantaneous stock price updates like public companies
  • Shares harder to buy/sell/value than public markets
  • Investors previously expected liquidity premium for compensation
  • Liquidating private assets takes minimum 1 week, requires intermediaries taking cuts
  • PE firms exploit biggest weakness as marketing tool: never sell assets, never release statements
  • Can claim higher portfolio values annually without verification

Encap/Southland Royalty Case Study

  • Encap formed Southland with $1+ billion investment (80% = $880 million)
  • Acquired oil/gas fields in San Juan Basin (New Mexico), Green River Basin (Wyoming)
  • Purchased 313,000 acres from another oil company
  • Setup in 2015 hoping for oil price recovery from 2014 drop
  • Oil prices: June 2014 = ~$100/barrel, June 2015 = $55/barrel
  • Prices never recovered, fields underproduced expectations
  • September 2019: still valued close to original investment
  • November 2019: marked down to $0, filed bankruptcy
  • "Marking to market" = accurate fair value representation on books
  • PE firms compete for investor funds, not always honest about underperformers
  • Reinforced illusion by only selling highest performing assets

Reason 2: Massive Industry Growth Creating Oversaturation

  • Previously elite strategy for ultra-wealthy sophisticated investors
  • Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway early success through PE-like acquisitions (Nebraska Furniture Mart, Hines)
  • Morgan Stanley/Financial Times data: 1,400% growth in assets under management since 2000
  • Growth equity strategies: 10,000% more capital than 24 years ago
  • Exponential growth charts historically unsustainable in finance

Competition Impact on Returns

  • Original advantage: only buyer in town, could set prices for sellers/renters
  • Example: Business generating $500K EBITDA annually, bought for $1.5M all-debt
  • Loan paid down in 3+ years, sell for same price = $1.5M profit
  • Bidding wars with other PE firms push acquisition prices to $5M
  • No longer beating regular market returns
  • Investors withdraw money if can't beat market, managers lose multi-million bonuses

Reason 3: Underperformance Driving Desperate Cost-Cutting Measures

  • PE managers' income depends on delivering returns exceeding broad market performance
  • Cambridge Associates/Capital IQ/Bloomberg data: competition pushed valuations up
  • Average PE fund underperforms S&P 500 before fees (using EBITDA/EV measure)
  • Managers resort to maximum leverage + expense cutting to increase earnings

Layoffs and Service Quality Degradation

  • Private Equity Stakeholder Project report: 4.4% average job losses post-acquisition
  • Context: most companies add employees over time, national unemployment fell 4.5%
  • Cost cutting resulted in worse customer service quality
  • Affected businesses: fast food franchises, nursing homes, preschools, hospitals, prisons
  • National Bureau of Economic Research studies + Atlantic/NYT/Bloomberg reports
  • Endless margin pressure responsible for tens of thousands of premature deaths among vulnerable populations

Reason 4: Regulatory Crackdown and Political Attention

  • Industry size attracting regulator attention with harsh crackdowns
  • End of year: Senate Budget Committee announced bipartisan investigation into PE hospital ownership
  • White House announced crackdown on anti-competitive practices
  • Congress pushing bill limiting tax breaks for corporate investors in single-family homes
  • Current tax advantages: interest/depreciation writeoffs making family homes attractive asset class
  • Large funds unable to acquire more private businesses turning to residential real estate

Industry Transformation and Future Outlook

  • 20 years ago: niche investment strategy, unknown to public
  • Rapid growth/high returns attracted big investors who "ruined good thing"
  • Now attracting attention from: young people unable to afford homes, elderly needing care, politicians pressured to act
  • Author writing article on best/worst PE firms for free newsletter "Compound and Daily"
  • Bonus fourth reason: industry never built for longevity

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome