AI summary by TwinMind
The Spectacular Rise (and Imminent Collapse) of Private Equity
How Money Works
13m 12s
Private Equity Definition and Business Model
- Private equity = investment into assets not listed on public markets
- Hundreds of thousands of profitable businesses unavailable through public exchanges
- Private companies lack reporting requirements, making valuation difficult/time-consuming
- PE firms act as middlemen offering rich investors access to untapped markets
- Pitch to billionaires/pension fund managers: higher returns than stock market, less volatility, safer from crashes
- Employed "crack team of best analysts" to find/buy private companies and extract maximum money
Reason 1: Misleading Returns Through Valuation Manipulation
- Returns weren't as great as they appeared due to "Schrödinger's cat" valuation trick
- Private company values hard to determine even by insiders with full financial access
- No instantaneous stock price updates like public companies
- Shares harder to buy/sell/value than public markets
- Investors previously expected liquidity premium for compensation
- Liquidating private assets takes minimum 1 week, requires intermediaries taking cuts
- PE firms exploit biggest weakness as marketing tool: never sell assets, never release statements
- Can claim higher portfolio values annually without verification
Encap/Southland Royalty Case Study
- Encap formed Southland with $1+ billion investment (80% = $880 million)
- Acquired oil/gas fields in San Juan Basin (New Mexico), Green River Basin (Wyoming)
- Purchased 313,000 acres from another oil company
- Setup in 2015 hoping for oil price recovery from 2014 drop
- Oil prices: June 2014 = ~$100/barrel, June 2015 = $55/barrel
- Prices never recovered, fields underproduced expectations
- September 2019: still valued close to original investment
- November 2019: marked down to $0, filed bankruptcy
- "Marking to market" = accurate fair value representation on books
- PE firms compete for investor funds, not always honest about underperformers
- Reinforced illusion by only selling highest performing assets
Reason 2: Massive Industry Growth Creating Oversaturation
- Previously elite strategy for ultra-wealthy sophisticated investors
- Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway early success through PE-like acquisitions (Nebraska Furniture Mart, Hines)
- Morgan Stanley/Financial Times data: 1,400% growth in assets under management since 2000
- Growth equity strategies: 10,000% more capital than 24 years ago
- Exponential growth charts historically unsustainable in finance
Competition Impact on Returns
- Original advantage: only buyer in town, could set prices for sellers/renters
- Example: Business generating $500K EBITDA annually, bought for $1.5M all-debt
- Loan paid down in 3+ years, sell for same price = $1.5M profit
- Bidding wars with other PE firms push acquisition prices to $5M
- No longer beating regular market returns
- Investors withdraw money if can't beat market, managers lose multi-million bonuses
Reason 3: Underperformance Driving Desperate Cost-Cutting Measures
- PE managers' income depends on delivering returns exceeding broad market performance
- Cambridge Associates/Capital IQ/Bloomberg data: competition pushed valuations up
- Average PE fund underperforms S&P 500 before fees (using EBITDA/EV measure)
- Managers resort to maximum leverage + expense cutting to increase earnings
Layoffs and Service Quality Degradation
- Private Equity Stakeholder Project report: 4.4% average job losses post-acquisition
- Context: most companies add employees over time, national unemployment fell 4.5%
- Cost cutting resulted in worse customer service quality
- Affected businesses: fast food franchises, nursing homes, preschools, hospitals, prisons
- National Bureau of Economic Research studies + Atlantic/NYT/Bloomberg reports
- Endless margin pressure responsible for tens of thousands of premature deaths among vulnerable populations
Reason 4: Regulatory Crackdown and Political Attention
- Industry size attracting regulator attention with harsh crackdowns
- End of year: Senate Budget Committee announced bipartisan investigation into PE hospital ownership
- White House announced crackdown on anti-competitive practices
- Congress pushing bill limiting tax breaks for corporate investors in single-family homes
- Current tax advantages: interest/depreciation writeoffs making family homes attractive asset class
- Large funds unable to acquire more private businesses turning to residential real estate
Industry Transformation and Future Outlook
- 20 years ago: niche investment strategy, unknown to public
- Rapid growth/high returns attracted big investors who "ruined good thing"
- Now attracting attention from: young people unable to afford homes, elderly needing care, politicians pressured to act
- Author writing article on best/worst PE firms for free newsletter "Compound and Daily"
- Bonus fourth reason: industry never built for longevity
