AI summary by TwinMind

The Speed of Outrage: Tom Scott at Thinking Digital 2015

Tom Scott

11m 15s

Opening Context & Frustration with Technological Stagnation

  • Speaker (Tom Scott) originally planned to predict 2020 general election by analyzing patterns from 2010
  • Major problem: minimal meaningful change in last 5 years (2010-2015)
  • 2015 essentially same as 2010 technologically
    • Smartphones already mainstream in 2010 (iPhone 4, decent Android)
    • Facebook and Twitter existed for years
    • All subsequent developments mere iterations ("shiny screen curved at edges")
  • Ed Balls tweet still punchline 4 years later - demonstrates stagnation
  • Predictions from 2010 about Flash, social change, accelerating society now seem normal

Key Change: Accelerated Speed of Online Outrage

  • One significant change: speed of reactions/backlash
  • Memories Pizza case study:
    • TV interview: owners said wouldn't cater gay wedding under new state laws
    • First wave: immediate viral backlash, forced/chose to close shop, owners went into hiding
    • Second wave: conservative Christians donated $800,000 in few days
    • "Terrifyingly fast overreaction from both sides"
  • "Shirtgate" controversy pattern:
    • Scientist wore shirt with scantily clad women at press conference
    • Predictable ritual: reasonable initial comments → immediate polarization → straw man arguments
    • Both sides refuse backing down, fear other side "winning"
    • Media amplifies: inflammatory headlines, bigger tweet images, clickbait for numbers
    • Worked in newsroom 18 months - witnessed requirements for numbers
    • Extreme positions necessary to avoid criticism from own side

Live Streaming Technology Assessment

  • 2015: Two competing apps - Periscope vs Meerkat
    • Meerkat launched first, Twitter acquired Periscope, killed Meerkat's access
    • Neither truly mainstream - technology not ready
  • Comparison to early tech:
    • Like Friendster (Facebook predecessor - good but too early)
    • Like Palm Pilot (good but not iPhone - timing issue)
  • Live demo experience: 200-300-400 people watching London stream
  • Current limitations: shaky mobile networks, not fully figured out
  • Prediction: Someone will crack live streaming (5-10 years)
    • Pet theory: Apple cameras in earbuds (cable + battery available)
    • People now comfortable holding up cameras

Future Implications of Ubiquitous Live Streaming

  • Step change effect similar to Twitter
  • Real-time knowledge "to the second" vs current "chunky five minutes ago"
  • Shift from "why didn't you do this" to "why don't you do this"
  • Proper ubiquitous surveillance capabilities

Media/Journalism Impact

  • Sky News already uses webcam interviews (Anbar Province example)
  • Picture quality irrelevant - speed matters
  • Amateur reporters on ground anywhere, anytime
  • Coverage during events, not after

Mob Targeting Concerns

  • 2020 online mobs could watch/broadcast targets live in public
  • Organized anonymous angry mobs searching geotag live streams
  • Comparison: bomb/mass shooting threats over video game criticism
  • "If people angry about something so trivial, what when they actually care?"

Positive Applications: Social Justice Documentation

  • Baltimore and Ferguson examples
  • Historical narrative control:
    • Previously: press releases, edited interviews, news organizations, pundits, tabloid/TV controllers
    • 2015: filter bubbles, hot takes, clickbait journalism ("BuzzFeed turned wrong")
  • Current limitation: selective sharing based on favorable optics
  • Live streaming provides unfiltered real-time perspective

Transformative Potential

  • Future major events: thousands/tens of thousands believing "they were there"
  • Shift from "where were you when you found out X happened" to "were you watching when it did"
  • Multiple eyewitness perspective:
    • Not 1-2 eyewitnesses + editable film
    • 10,000 eyewitnesses seeing same thing simultaneously
  • Live streaming terminology will become commonplace like "tweeted" today
  • Won't be Periscope that wins mainstream adoption

Conclusion

  • Change happening through slow incremental steps, not spectacle
  • About changing opinions, reaching future gradually
  • "Things getting a little bit better day after day"
  • Closing: "Enjoy the next five years"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome