AI summary by TwinMind
The Speed of Outrage: Tom Scott at Thinking Digital 2015
Tom Scott
11m 15s
Opening Context & Frustration with Technological Stagnation
- Speaker (Tom Scott) originally planned to predict 2020 general election by analyzing patterns from 2010
- Major problem: minimal meaningful change in last 5 years (2010-2015)
- 2015 essentially same as 2010 technologically
- Smartphones already mainstream in 2010 (iPhone 4, decent Android)
- Facebook and Twitter existed for years
- All subsequent developments mere iterations ("shiny screen curved at edges")
- Ed Balls tweet still punchline 4 years later - demonstrates stagnation
- Predictions from 2010 about Flash, social change, accelerating society now seem normal
Key Change: Accelerated Speed of Online Outrage
- One significant change: speed of reactions/backlash
- Memories Pizza case study:
- TV interview: owners said wouldn't cater gay wedding under new state laws
- First wave: immediate viral backlash, forced/chose to close shop, owners went into hiding
- Second wave: conservative Christians donated $800,000 in few days
- "Terrifyingly fast overreaction from both sides"
- "Shirtgate" controversy pattern:
- Scientist wore shirt with scantily clad women at press conference
- Predictable ritual: reasonable initial comments → immediate polarization → straw man arguments
- Both sides refuse backing down, fear other side "winning"
- Media amplifies: inflammatory headlines, bigger tweet images, clickbait for numbers
- Worked in newsroom 18 months - witnessed requirements for numbers
- Extreme positions necessary to avoid criticism from own side
Live Streaming Technology Assessment
- 2015: Two competing apps - Periscope vs Meerkat
- Meerkat launched first, Twitter acquired Periscope, killed Meerkat's access
- Neither truly mainstream - technology not ready
- Comparison to early tech:
- Like Friendster (Facebook predecessor - good but too early)
- Like Palm Pilot (good but not iPhone - timing issue)
- Live demo experience: 200-300-400 people watching London stream
- Current limitations: shaky mobile networks, not fully figured out
- Prediction: Someone will crack live streaming (5-10 years)
- Pet theory: Apple cameras in earbuds (cable + battery available)
- People now comfortable holding up cameras
Future Implications of Ubiquitous Live Streaming
- Step change effect similar to Twitter
- Real-time knowledge "to the second" vs current "chunky five minutes ago"
- Shift from "why didn't you do this" to "why don't you do this"
- Proper ubiquitous surveillance capabilities
Media/Journalism Impact
- Sky News already uses webcam interviews (Anbar Province example)
- Picture quality irrelevant - speed matters
- Amateur reporters on ground anywhere, anytime
- Coverage during events, not after
Mob Targeting Concerns
- 2020 online mobs could watch/broadcast targets live in public
- Organized anonymous angry mobs searching geotag live streams
- Comparison: bomb/mass shooting threats over video game criticism
- "If people angry about something so trivial, what when they actually care?"
Positive Applications: Social Justice Documentation
- Baltimore and Ferguson examples
- Historical narrative control:
- Previously: press releases, edited interviews, news organizations, pundits, tabloid/TV controllers
- 2015: filter bubbles, hot takes, clickbait journalism ("BuzzFeed turned wrong")
- Current limitation: selective sharing based on favorable optics
- Live streaming provides unfiltered real-time perspective
Transformative Potential
- Future major events: thousands/tens of thousands believing "they were there"
- Shift from "where were you when you found out X happened" to "were you watching when it did"
- Multiple eyewitness perspective:
- Not 1-2 eyewitnesses + editable film
- 10,000 eyewitnesses seeing same thing simultaneously
- Live streaming terminology will become commonplace like "tweeted" today
- Won't be Periscope that wins mainstream adoption
Conclusion
- Change happening through slow incremental steps, not spectacle
- About changing opinions, reaching future gradually
- "Things getting a little bit better day after day"
- Closing: "Enjoy the next five years"
