AI summary by TwinMind
The Strange Unsolved Murder of Ken McElroy | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
45m 43s
Podcast Introduction & Content Warning
- Second episode of new year for "Stuff You Should Know"
- Major trigger warning issued for sexual assault, violence against minors
- Story involves clear-cut villain Ken Rex McElroy
- Multiple media adaptations: 1988 book "In Broad Daylight" by Harry MacLean, 2019 documentary "No One Saw a Thing", 1991 TV movie starring Brian Dennehy
Ken Rex McElroy Background
- Born 1934 in Skidmore, Missouri
- 15th of 16 children from poor family
- Either made it to age 15 in school or was illiterate
- Age 18: construction accident - heavy cribbing fell 30 feet, hit head, steel plate implanted
- Caused blackout episodes and pain throughout life
- Head injury common factor in violent criminals
- Started crime at young age for necessity and pleasure
Criminal Activities & Methods
- Cattle rustling (primary income source)
- Nodaway County led state in cattle thefts 6x higher than anywhere else
- Year before death: most thefts attributed to McElroy
- Also: hunting dog training, antique dealing
- Had cash to buy new cars, support 10+ kids
- Arrested/charged at least 21 times without conviction
- Attorney Richard Gene McFadden (Kansas City mob lawyer)
- McElroy threw fat cash roll on desk at first meeting
- McFadden used procedural delays
- McElroy intimidated witnesses and jurors
- Threatened lives, families
- Parked in driveways
- Brandished guns, shot guns outside houses
- Burned houses, killed pets
- Became "Teflon-coated hick" - charges never stuck
Pattern of Sexual Abuse
- Married first time 1952: age 18 to 16-year-old Oleta
- Preyed on girls as young as 12-13
- Pattern: groom, stalk, rape, threaten with death
- Would divorce current wife to marry rape victim (spousal privilege prevented testimony)
- Multiple marriages to avoid prosecution
- Sharon (15-year-old victim mentioned)
- Final wife: Trina McCloud
- Started relationship when she was 12-13
- School officials noticed but did nothing
- Pregnant at 14, moved into house with previous victim Alice
- Had son in 1973
- Held Trina's parents at gunpoint
- Burned down parents' house, killed family dog
- Doctor reported abuse to authorities
- Foster family protected Trina but she returned to McElroy
- Married at 15 with McFadden as witness
- Signed document recanting abuse allegations
Escalating Violence Examples
- July 1976: Shot Roma Henry (romaine lettuce farmer) in stomach with shotgun
- Henry asked McElroy to stop shooting pheasants out of season on his land
- McElroy got away with it through intimidation
- Threatened Highway Patrolman Richard Stratton's family
- Put shotgun in wife Margaret's face as she left for church
- County Magistrate Montgomery Wilson too fearful to take cases
- Intimidated judges, moved cases to other counties
The Bo Bowenkamp Incident (1980)
- B&B Grocery owners: Lois and Ernest "Bo" Bowenkamp (beloved elderly couple)
- McElroy's 4-year-old daughter Tanya caught stealing candy
- July 1980: McElroy shot 70-year-old Bo through neck (didn't kill)
- McElroy fled state, caught by Richard Stratton at Filmore, Missouri
- Stratton predicted McElroy would avoid roadblocks, take back roads to Kansas
- First conviction: second degree assault, 2 years jail
- Released on $40,000 bail (paid cash)
- McFadden appealed conviction
Final Confrontation Setup
- McElroy appeared at D&G Tavern with M1 carbine rifle with bayonet
- Threatened to "finish off" Bo Bowenkamp
- Pete Ward and sons filed complaint for bond revocation
- Bond hearing scheduled July 10, 1981
- American Legion Hall meeting: 80+ adults (most of town)
- Sheriff Danny Estes said nothing could be done legally
- Plan: form large group to follow McElroy for safety in numbers
- Hearing delayed another 10 days to July 20th
The Killing (July 10, 1981)
- Town group (50-60 people) went to D&G Tavern
- McElroy and Trina drinking there in morning
- McElroy bought six-pack, left with crowd following
- 30-60 people surrounded McElroy's Silverado in parking lot
- McElroy had cigarette, car running in park
- Shot in head with high-powered hunting rifle through back windshield
- Second shot to neck
- Two different bullet types/guns confirmed
- Trina covered in blood, urinated herself
- Initially told stay in car or be killed
- Hustled to nearby bank during 20 seconds of additional shooting
- McElroy's foot hit gas, engine revved and blew
- No one helped McElroy
- Town cleared out immediately
Investigation & Aftermath
- 30-60 witnesses present, "no one saw a thing"
- Town completely refused to cooperate
- One witness briefly mentioned Dell Clement speeding away, then recanted
- Trina identified Dell Clement (D&G Tavern co-owner) as shooter
- Clement had livestock stolen by McElroy, was hothead
- People interviewed 5-6 times, no one cracked
- FBI closed investigation September 2, 1982
- Police Chief Hal Riddle called it most frustrating case of career
- No arrests or charges ever filed
Key Figures' Fates
- Dell Clement: Never spoke about it, died 2009
- Trina McElroy: Filed $5M wrongful death suit 1985, settled $17,600
- Offered $5,000 reward for information (against future movie rights)
- Remarried 1983, died 2012
- Obituary made no mention of McElroy period
- Richard Gene McFadden: Proud of work, became lobbyist
- Handed out signed copies of MacLean's book to legislators
- Died 2012
- Richard Stratton: Said "they did what they did because we didn't do our job"
- Knew who did it but never said
- Local Vietnam vet Brit Small: Said mistake was letting Trina live
Institutional Failure Theme
- Local law enforcement repeatedly failed community
- Intimidation, corruption, or incompetence
- Community forced to take matters into own hands
- System couldn't stop serial predator and terrorist
