AI summary by TwinMind

The Tariff Paradoxes of Latin America and Asia

Asianometry

18m 1s

Introduction & Research Context

  • Analysis based on papers by economists Michael Clemens and Jeffrey Williamson
  • Explores economic paradox: pre-WWI Latin America had highest global tariff rates, East Asia had fraction as high
  • Latin American countries grew faster than Asian ones during these decades
  • Regional definitions: Latin America (Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Cuba, Mexico, Peru, Uruguay); Asia (Burma, Siam, China, Egypt, India, Indonesia, Japan, Philippines, Thailand, Turkey)
  • Tariff rate calculation: total revenue from import duties ÷ value of imports per year

Latin America Post-Independence (1820s)

  • Wars of independence from Spain/Portugal created Brazil, Grand Colombia, Peru, Bolivia, Central America, Mexico
  • Pre-independence: mercantalist network favoring Europe, export of raw goods (silver, sugar, coffee)
  • Import restrictions protected nascent manufacturing, no need for tariffs under colonial rule

Revenue Crisis & Tariff Adoption

  • Wars shattered traditional revenue collection abilities
  • Heavy borrowing for armies, continued military conflicts over borders
  • Promise to lift exploitative European tax burdens on working populations
  • Indigenous head tax especially hated
  • Lacked infrastructure/bureaucracy for traditional tax collection
  • Wars left 1+ million dead, destroyed infrastructure
  • Tariffs at central ports easiest revenue source
  • Early tariffs: 30-40% to fund government activities
  • 1820-1890: tariffs produced 57.8% of government revenue for 11 Latin American republics

Mexico Case Study

  • Independence 1821, first tariff law raised textile imports to 25%
  • 60% of imports first decade were textiles for upper class
  • Half of Mexican government revenue in 1820s from tariffs
  • 1828: Puebla riots by cotton industry helped Vicente Guerrero gain presidency
  • Guerrero promised cotton import ban 1829, delayed 6 months, eventually rescinded due to revenue concerns

Peru Case Study

  • Military loss to Chile in War of the Pacific 1880s
  • Economy suffering from Guano Industries collapse
  • Raised tariffs to pay for war, relied on them for majority of late 1800s revenue

Asia's Low Tariff Situation

  • By 1885: Latin America had tariff rates 5x higher than Asia
  • Primary reason: many Asian nations colonized/semicolonized 1800s-early 1900s, little tariff control

Colonial Control Examples

  • India: British Empire, followed free trade attitude, low tariff rates
  • Burma, Siam, Indonesia: Dutch Empire influence
  • China: Opium Wars losses, unequal treaties of Nanking and Tiansen until 1929, standard 5% tariff rate
  • Japan: Matthew Perry's gunboats, unequal treaties limiting tariffs 3.75%-5%, some autonomy 1899, items under low duties until 1911
  • Thailand (Siam): avoided colonization, adopted 3% tariffs via Bowring Treaty 1855 with Britain until 1890
  • Philippines: unusually high 21% tariff rate 1900-1913 due to US control (US was protectionist), just 2 points below US rates

Additional Factors for Low Asian Tariffs

  • Larger populations offered larger internal markets, dampening tariff demand
  • Latin America's smaller populations (historic plagues) more urbanized, urban populations more apt to organize for trade protection
  • Natural trade barriers: Asian countries had little inland train access, difficult goods transport to coast
  • Latin America: Atlantic regions (Brazil, Cuba, Uruguay) had good European market access, more railroad track pre-1914 from mining investments
  • Trading partner influence: Asia's partners were free trade oriented (mostly Britain), Latin America traded with protectionist US

Economic Growth Comparison Pre-WWI

  • Latin America: steady growth via natural resource exports, freed from Spanish taxes, direct European/North American trade
  • Leandro Prados de la Escosura estimate: 1820-1870 Latin America per capita income grew 0.5% annually (global average)
  • Lagged Western Europe/US but those at different development stages
  • US per capita income 1820s nearly 2x Latin countries
  • Comparing similar starting income rates (China, India, Japan, Africa): Latin America grew faster, made up ground vs US while China/India declined
  • Clemens/Williamson finding: pre-WWI Latin America's growth rates with 5x higher tariffs far outpaced East Asia
  • Correlation ≠ causation emphasized

Post-WWI Changes

  • Tariff gap between Latin America and Asia largely closed after WWI
  • Asian countries (China, India, Siam, Burma) adopted protectionist policies
  • Only Philippines and Japan did not substantially raise tariff rates
  • Factors: war funding needs, Great Depression excess capacity, global tariff rise (Smoot-Hawley Act)
  • End of 1930s: Asian tariff rates about equal to Latin American rates

Japan's Unique Approach

  • Domestic industries faced import competition (German dyes)
  • Couldn't raise tariffs without retaliation
  • Used non-tariff protections: import restrictions, subsidies, company cartels/conglomerates
  • Currency manipulation: 1929 attempted gold standard return, dropped due to depression/overvalued currency
  • Currency crashed 40%, real wages crashed 30%
  • Combined with automation enabled export boom, economic growth return
  • Japanese textiles flooded British markets (China, India, Hong Kong, Southeast Asia)
  • Focused on specific industries (cars, steel) encouraging scale combinations

British Response

  • 1932 Ottawa Conference: raised trade barriers outside empire, allowed Dominions tariff autonomy
  • India raised tariff rate 4x: 5.5% (1920) to 27.5% (1939)
  • Burma and Ceylon had tariff raises, less dramatic
  • Japan turned to exporting to colonies (Korea, Taiwan) and semicolonies (Manchuria, Guangdong)

Post-WWII Reversal

  • Strange paradox: after WWII correlation broke/reversed
  • Fastest growing countries were industrializing states that lowered tariffs/trade barriers
  • Paper co-authored with Christopher Blattman explores reasons

Core Industrial Countries Advantage

  • France, UK, US, Germany had: big domestic markets, infrastructure, capital, skilled labor for industrialization
  • Tariffs not just for government revenue but to protect industrial base until ready for global competition

Successful Tariff Strategy Principles

  • Tariffs exist for different reasons, must be used correctly
  • Work best when nurturing industrial base (example: China EV industry 2010s)
  • Albert Hirschman's import substitution success factors:
    • Targeted: core industries that are "demanding" (sports cars, high-performance CPUs)
    • Temporary: protections must eventually be lifted, foreign competition reintroduced
    • Discipline and productivity from demanding industries flows to other sectors
  • China example: lithium ion ecosystem → EVs, Intel CPUs → PC boom
  • Failure example: Latin America post-1950 economic stagnancy from permanent protections

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome