AI summary by TwinMind
The Tariff Paradoxes of Latin America and Asia
Asianometry
18m 1s
Introduction & Research Context
- Analysis based on papers by economists Michael Clemens and Jeffrey Williamson
- Explores economic paradox: pre-WWI Latin America had highest global tariff rates, East Asia had fraction as high
- Latin American countries grew faster than Asian ones during these decades
- Regional definitions: Latin America (Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Cuba, Mexico, Peru, Uruguay); Asia (Burma, Siam, China, Egypt, India, Indonesia, Japan, Philippines, Thailand, Turkey)
- Tariff rate calculation: total revenue from import duties ÷ value of imports per year
Latin America Post-Independence (1820s)
- Wars of independence from Spain/Portugal created Brazil, Grand Colombia, Peru, Bolivia, Central America, Mexico
- Pre-independence: mercantalist network favoring Europe, export of raw goods (silver, sugar, coffee)
- Import restrictions protected nascent manufacturing, no need for tariffs under colonial rule
Revenue Crisis & Tariff Adoption
- Wars shattered traditional revenue collection abilities
- Heavy borrowing for armies, continued military conflicts over borders
- Promise to lift exploitative European tax burdens on working populations
- Indigenous head tax especially hated
- Lacked infrastructure/bureaucracy for traditional tax collection
- Wars left 1+ million dead, destroyed infrastructure
- Tariffs at central ports easiest revenue source
- Early tariffs: 30-40% to fund government activities
- 1820-1890: tariffs produced 57.8% of government revenue for 11 Latin American republics
Mexico Case Study
- Independence 1821, first tariff law raised textile imports to 25%
- 60% of imports first decade were textiles for upper class
- Half of Mexican government revenue in 1820s from tariffs
- 1828: Puebla riots by cotton industry helped Vicente Guerrero gain presidency
- Guerrero promised cotton import ban 1829, delayed 6 months, eventually rescinded due to revenue concerns
Peru Case Study
- Military loss to Chile in War of the Pacific 1880s
- Economy suffering from Guano Industries collapse
- Raised tariffs to pay for war, relied on them for majority of late 1800s revenue
Asia's Low Tariff Situation
- By 1885: Latin America had tariff rates 5x higher than Asia
- Primary reason: many Asian nations colonized/semicolonized 1800s-early 1900s, little tariff control
Colonial Control Examples
- India: British Empire, followed free trade attitude, low tariff rates
- Burma, Siam, Indonesia: Dutch Empire influence
- China: Opium Wars losses, unequal treaties of Nanking and Tiansen until 1929, standard 5% tariff rate
- Japan: Matthew Perry's gunboats, unequal treaties limiting tariffs 3.75%-5%, some autonomy 1899, items under low duties until 1911
- Thailand (Siam): avoided colonization, adopted 3% tariffs via Bowring Treaty 1855 with Britain until 1890
- Philippines: unusually high 21% tariff rate 1900-1913 due to US control (US was protectionist), just 2 points below US rates
Additional Factors for Low Asian Tariffs
- Larger populations offered larger internal markets, dampening tariff demand
- Latin America's smaller populations (historic plagues) more urbanized, urban populations more apt to organize for trade protection
- Natural trade barriers: Asian countries had little inland train access, difficult goods transport to coast
- Latin America: Atlantic regions (Brazil, Cuba, Uruguay) had good European market access, more railroad track pre-1914 from mining investments
- Trading partner influence: Asia's partners were free trade oriented (mostly Britain), Latin America traded with protectionist US
Economic Growth Comparison Pre-WWI
- Latin America: steady growth via natural resource exports, freed from Spanish taxes, direct European/North American trade
- Leandro Prados de la Escosura estimate: 1820-1870 Latin America per capita income grew 0.5% annually (global average)
- Lagged Western Europe/US but those at different development stages
- US per capita income 1820s nearly 2x Latin countries
- Comparing similar starting income rates (China, India, Japan, Africa): Latin America grew faster, made up ground vs US while China/India declined
- Clemens/Williamson finding: pre-WWI Latin America's growth rates with 5x higher tariffs far outpaced East Asia
- Correlation ≠ causation emphasized
Post-WWI Changes
- Tariff gap between Latin America and Asia largely closed after WWI
- Asian countries (China, India, Siam, Burma) adopted protectionist policies
- Only Philippines and Japan did not substantially raise tariff rates
- Factors: war funding needs, Great Depression excess capacity, global tariff rise (Smoot-Hawley Act)
- End of 1930s: Asian tariff rates about equal to Latin American rates
Japan's Unique Approach
- Domestic industries faced import competition (German dyes)
- Couldn't raise tariffs without retaliation
- Used non-tariff protections: import restrictions, subsidies, company cartels/conglomerates
- Currency manipulation: 1929 attempted gold standard return, dropped due to depression/overvalued currency
- Currency crashed 40%, real wages crashed 30%
- Combined with automation enabled export boom, economic growth return
- Japanese textiles flooded British markets (China, India, Hong Kong, Southeast Asia)
- Focused on specific industries (cars, steel) encouraging scale combinations
British Response
- 1932 Ottawa Conference: raised trade barriers outside empire, allowed Dominions tariff autonomy
- India raised tariff rate 4x: 5.5% (1920) to 27.5% (1939)
- Burma and Ceylon had tariff raises, less dramatic
- Japan turned to exporting to colonies (Korea, Taiwan) and semicolonies (Manchuria, Guangdong)
Post-WWII Reversal
- Strange paradox: after WWII correlation broke/reversed
- Fastest growing countries were industrializing states that lowered tariffs/trade barriers
- Paper co-authored with Christopher Blattman explores reasons
Core Industrial Countries Advantage
- France, UK, US, Germany had: big domestic markets, infrastructure, capital, skilled labor for industrialization
- Tariffs not just for government revenue but to protect industrial base until ready for global competition
Successful Tariff Strategy Principles
- Tariffs exist for different reasons, must be used correctly
- Work best when nurturing industrial base (example: China EV industry 2010s)
- Albert Hirschman's import substitution success factors:
- Targeted: core industries that are "demanding" (sports cars, high-performance CPUs)
- Temporary: protections must eventually be lifted, foreign competition reintroduced
- Discipline and productivity from demanding industries flows to other sectors
- China example: lithium ion ecosystem → EVs, Intel CPUs → PC boom
- Failure example: Latin America post-1950 economic stagnancy from permanent protections
