AI summary by TwinMind
The Three Gorges Dam, Examined
Asianometry
15m 36s
Dam Overview and Physical Specifications
- World's biggest dam located in Three Gorges area, Chongqing municipality
- Concrete gravity dam, maximum height 185 meters (45-story building equivalent)
- Normal pool height designed for 175 meters
- Three main sections:
- Center: 23-section spillway dam, 483 meters long
- Both sides: 26 powerhouse dam sections, additional 1.2 kilometers
- Part of Three Gorges Project with three components:
- Dam itself
- Powerhouses at dam foot
- Navigation facilities for ship crossing
Reservoir Characteristics
- Extends nearly 600 kilometers upstream (San Francisco to Los Angeles distance)
- Total water storage capacity: 40 cubic kilometers
- Seven times bigger than California's Shasta Lake reservoir
- Located on Yangtze River (Asia's longest river, China's major waterway)
Historical Context and Development
- Yangtze River: cradle of Chinese civilization, hundreds of millions live in basin
- Chinese have dammed Yangtze for centuries
- Dujiangyan Dam in Chengdu area: 2,200+ years old, still operational
- Dam concept originated with Sun Yat-sen in 1919 article "A Plan to Develop Industry"
- Mao Zedong strong personal interest after 1956 Yangtze swim in Wuhan
- Wrote poem about man triumphing over nature
- Swimming impressive feat given river's pollution (other swimmers got sick)
- 1960s: technically not feasible
- 1970s: too expensive
- 1982: Chinese government began investigating mega dam possibility
- Initial international support from major agencies
- Strong environmentalist resistance caused delays
- Feasibility studies lukewarm due to sediment/resettlement problems
- 1989 Tiananmen incident ended international involvement
- 1992: Premier Li Peng revived project
- Passed with two-thirds vote (close by Chinese standards)
- Jailed Three Gorges activists, squashed public debate
Primary Benefits - Flood Control
- Yangtze prone to flooding: 200+ floods between 185 BC and 1911 (roughly one per decade)
- Basin susceptible due to water level barely higher than plain
- High silt content raises river levels, causes spillover
- Historical flood casualties:
- 1931, 1935, 1954 floods: 300,000 deaths combined
- 1870 flood: 240,000 deaths
- 1998 flood: 3,000 deaths, 300 million affected, $50 billion damages
- Existing levee system partially effective but created consequences
- Jingjiang levee reinforcement since 1950s diverted silt to Dongting Lake
- Dongting Lake capacity reduced 50%, less flood absorption
- Dam provides definitive flood solution:
- 22 billion cubic meters flood control capacity
- Reduces decade floods to century floods (climate change notwithstanding)
- Saves hundreds of millions in economic damage
Electricity Generation Benefits
- China's fast growth requires massive electricity
- Self-sustaining renewable energy source, clean and carbon-friendly
- 34 generators produce 20x more electricity than Hoover Dam
- Generates 92 terawatt-hours annually
- Powers 9 provinces and 2 major cities, including Shanghai (24 million people)
Additional Benefits
- Easier boat navigation in Three Gorges area
- Fresh water storage for drought alleviation
- Water management control
Environmental and Social Costs
- World Bank and international agencies discourage major dam funding due to high environmental/social costs
- Multiple complex issues beyond scope of single discussion
Flood Control Limitations
- Dam not ideally placed to prevent majority of Yangtze floods
- 1954 and 1998 floods caused by storms downstream from Three Gorges
- Sanmenxia Dam on Yellow River better positioned (controls 92% of watershed)
- Silt problem parallels Yellow River dam issues:
- Sanmenxia Dam required substantial renovation 2 years after completion
- Yangtze fourth most silt-heavy river globally (Yellow River is first)
- Silt deposits reduce reservoir capacity and power generation
- Requires constant maintenance to prevent spillover/collapse
Displacement and Land Loss
- 600 square kilometers of land flooded
- Reservoir will inundate:
- 4,000 villages
- 140 towns
- 13 cities
- 100,000 acres farmland
- 1.3-1.6 million people relocated
- Contamination from flooded areas:
- 1,300 factories and mines
- 40,000 graveyards
- 200 garbage dumps
- Water treatment plants built 10 years after dam completion (too late)
- Submerged vegetation decay generates CO2, creates local climate change
- Counterbalances renewable energy green benefits
Cultural Heritage Loss
- 1,282 cultural heritage sites submerged
- Government addressed only 453 sites:
- Some relocated (Dangfei Temple moved 32 km, cost $6 million)
- Some protected (1,200-year-old Bai Helang stone in underwater museum)
- Most simply photographed before flooding
- UNESCO site preservation efforts insufficient
- Ancestral homes and cultural sites lost permanently
Construction Process (Three Phases)
Project Organization
- Supervised by Three Gorges Project Construction Committee
- Headed by State Council Premier
- Includes ministry heads and provincial governors of Hubei, Hunan, Chongqing
- State Council founded corporation with $670 million assets
- China Yangtze River Three Gorges Project Development Corporation owns dam
Technology Transfer and Materials
- Anglo-French GEC Alstom and Switzerland's ABB won first 7 generators tender
- Required technology sharing with state-owned Harbin Power Equipment Company
- Harbin built 8th generator based on learnings
- German-Canadian consortium built remaining turbines with Dongfang Machinery
- Cement from Hubei Huaxin Cement Company and Sichuan Jinding Corporation
- Materials used:
- 463,000 tons steel (enough for 63 Eiffel Towers)
- 27 million cubic meters concrete
- Foundation: high-strength homogeneous granite, mostly intact
- 886 faults identified at dam site (most small, low risk)
Construction Timeline
- Phase 1 (December 14, 1994): Lee Peng opening ceremony
- Built support structures
- Closed Yangtze main channel for diversion
- Phase 2 (1998-2003):
- Built 1.7 km long, 185m high left bank dam section
- First powerhouses and turbine generators
- Ship lock construction
- Began reservoir filling to 135 meter mark
- Started people relocation
- Phase 3: Final resettlement completion
- 1.2 million people moved
- Water level raised to final 175 meters
Global Dam Context
- Large dams important in human development for millennia
- 45,000 large dams built in past 100 years
- China: world's biggest dam building country
- 22 big dams (over 15m tall) in 1949
- Over 22,000 today
- United States: 6,390 dams (country same size as China)
- Dams controversial due to uncertain long-term environmental/economic effects
- Balance between benefits and potential excess
