AI summary by TwinMind
The Three Gorges Dam Resettlement Problem
Asianometry
11m 7s
Historical Context of Dam Resettlement in China
- Post-communist takeover: 7.8 million people moved for dams over 20 years
- Early approach: minimal financial compensation, coercion using "good of the nation" rhetoric
- Forced relocation for those unconvinced by political appeals
- Poor planning: government officials barely considered consequences of mass displacement
Danjiangkou Reservoir Case Study (1958)
- Location: Hanjiang River, Gansu and Hubei provinces
- 100,000 people cleared out with no destination planning
- No farmland, housing, or residential land allocated
- Compensation: as little as 50 RMB per person
- Result: 66,000 displaced refugees attempted return
- Social chaos: peasants sold clothes for transportation back to underwater homes
- Fights between migrants over firewood, senior party intervention required
Policy Evolution Post-Cultural Revolution
- Recognition that old coercive methods unsustainable
- State Council increased resettlement compensation amounts
- New resources dedicated to resettlement (previously construction-only budgets)
Three Gorges Dam Resettlement Scale
- 1992 survey: 1.3-1.6 million people requiring relocation
- Infrastructure impact: 4,000 villages, 140 towns, 13 cities, 100,000 acres farmland
- Farmland loss: primarily garden plots and rice fields (crucial for farmer livelihood)
- Geographic challenge: 78% mountainous terrain in Three Gorges area
Agricultural Relocation Challenges
- Higher slope land: steep, rocky, thin soils
- Altitude issues: unsuitable weather for certain crops
- Forested land unavailable: Premier Zhu Rongji declined opening due to soil erosion concerns
- Villager concern: "How can we earn a living on the slopes?"
- Overcrowding: increased landslide risk as more migrants relocated uphill
Public Sentiment Survey Results
- Only 8% confident economic/social situation would improve
- 47% strongly opposed relocation
- 45% refused to answer survey questions (fear of repercussions)
Distant Urban Relocation Plan
- 125,000 rural migrants to Chongqing city and Hebei province
- Mix of rural and urban destinations
- Government promise: economic improvement through city job opportunities
- Migrant preference: 250+ families surveyed preferred slope resettlement over distant relocation
Economic Capacity Issues
- Chongqing example: 180 factories, 67,000 workers planned relocation
- Local unemployment: 108,500 already unemployed in Chongqing
- Over-capacity economy unable to absorb new migrants
- Alternative provinces: Hainan, Xinjiang, Inner Mongolia (not thriving metros)
Budget and Corruption
- Initial budget: $11.76 billion
- Final cost: $26 billion (staggering increase)
- Decentralized implementation: local officials given flexibility without oversight
- 1999 National Audit Office findings: 232 million RMB ($31 million USD) embezzled
- Corruption methods: inflated claims, kickbacks to unqualified contractors, shoddy work
Corruption Cases and Scale
- Local Union County: peasant petitions exposed corruption
- SCMP reports: 10,000+ resettled peasants complained of bait-and-switch
- Promised compensation: $5,000 USD
- Actual received: $700 USD
- 2005 convictions: 349 people, $7.1 million misused ($5.2 million recovered)
- 2007 audit: $36 million missing from $1.3 billion allocation
- Construction quality: nearly half of companies improperly awarded contracts
Implementation and Human Cost
- Government approach: "sheer force of will" like old days
- Protesters and petitioners jailed
- Impact on local governments: burden of hosting migrants competing with natives for jobs
- Densely populated agricultural area: generations of poorly educated farmers lost land-based livelihood
Global Infrastructure Export Implications
- China exporting dam expertise internationally
- Question: other countries lack same coercive capacity
- Reference to "another infamous mega dam" suggesting international challenges
