AI summary by TwinMind
The Trouble with the Electoral College
CGP Grey
6m 31s
Electoral College Vote Distribution Issues
- Electoral College = 538 votes determining presidency
- Fair distribution would be 1 vote per 574,000 people
- Current system gives votes to states, not people proportionally
- Example: Ohio has 11.5M people, should get 20 votes but only gets 18
- Rhode Island has 1.1M people, should get 2 votes but gets 4
- Every state gets minimum 3 votes regardless of population
Vote Redistribution Impact by State
- States missing electoral votes due to redistribution:
- Georgians, Virginians, Michiganders, Jerseyites: missing 1 vote each
- Pennsylvanians, North Carolinians, Ohioans, Hoosiers: missing 2 votes each
- Floridians: missing 4 votes
- New Yorkers: missing 5 votes
- Texans: missing 6 votes
- Californians: missing 10 votes
- Vote power disparity examples:
- 1 Vermonter's vote = 3 Texans' votes
- 1 Wyomingite's vote = 4 Californians' votes
Campaign Attention Analysis
- Previous election candidate visits in final 2 months:
- Only 18 of 50 states received any candidate visits
- Only 2 small states (Maine, New Hampshire) got visits
- Most small states in certain regions completely ignored
- Largest states (California, Texas, New York) also ignored
- Top 4 states (Ohio, Florida, Pennsylvania, Virginia) received majority of attention
- Same pattern applies to campaign spending
Winner-Take-All System Problems
- Candidates need just 50%+1 to win 100% of state's electoral votes
- No difference between winning by millions vs. single vote
- Forces candidates to focus only on close swing states
- Ignores states with large margins (safe states)
Population Distribution Reality
- Total US population: 309 million
- NYC (largest city): 8 million (2.6% of population)
- LA: 3.8 million, Chicago: 2.7 million
- 10th largest city (San Jose): under 1 million
- Top 10 cities combined: only 7.9% of popular vote
- Top 100 cities (down to Spokane): still under 20% of population
- Mathematical impossibility for candidates to win by only targeting big cities
Extreme Electoral College Scenario
- Possible to win presidency with only 22% of popular vote
- Strategy: target states with highest electoral vote per capita ratios
- Starting with Wyoming: 0.18% of population, 0.56% of electoral votes
- Need only half+1 voters in each state due to winner-take-all
- Sequence through smallest states up to New Jersey
- Result: Electoral majority while 78% of population votes against
Historical Failure Rate
- 3 times in 55+ elections, popular vote winner lost presidency
- 5% failure rate in democratic system
- Comparison to sports: 5% chance loser wins would be unacceptable
- Higher stakes make this percentage "dangerously high"
Solution Proposal
- Abolish Electoral College
- Implement direct citizen voting for president
- Would eliminate all current problems
- Make everyone's vote equal
