AI summary by TwinMind

The Truth About Pumped Hydro

Real Engineering

16m 53s

Energy Storage Context and Renewable Energy Economics

  • Energy storage identified as most important technology for climate change battle
  • Solar/wind technologies reached maturity, capable of providing sufficient energy for humanity at fraction of fossil fuel costs
  • 2017 fossil fuel subsidies: $447 billion worldwide vs $128 billion for renewables
  • Renewables provided ~75% of new electricity generation capacity in 2017
  • Renewables cheaper, cleaner, sustainable despite subsidy arguments
  • Primary factor holding renewables back: energy storage problem
  • Lithium-ion batteries becoming forerunners for energy storage needs
  • Hydrogen positioned for long duration energy storage applications

Pumped Hydro Technology Overview

  • Oldest, most dominant form of energy storage
  • Converts electricity to potential energy by pumping water to elevated reservoir
  • Water later released to drive impeller when electricity needed
  • Rugged, long-lived, mature technology
  • Provided valuable service to grids for more than a century
  • Calls worldwide to increase energy storage capacity in this technology
  • Infrastructure investment not simple solution

Turlock Hill Ireland Case Study

Construction and Operations

  • Ireland's first and only pumped hydro station
  • Construction began 1968, operational 1974 after 6 years excavation
  • Required only one overhaul in 2012 (38 years into operation)
  • Impressive lifecycle demonstrating technology durability
  • Historically used thermal power from coal, oil, peat stations that couldn't turn off at night
  • Released power during day when needed most
  • Today: valuable resource as Ireland increases wind power generation
  • Helps gradually decommission heavily polluting fossil fuel plants

Ireland's Wind Power Potential

  • Windy position on Atlantic edge provides prime real estate
  • Growing offshore and onshore wind resources
  • With energy storage help, can become net energy exporter to UK and wider Europe

Technical Specifications and Calculations

Energy Storage Physics

  • 1 cubic meter water = 1,000 kg mass
  • Every 1 meter height gain = 9,810 joules energy = ~2.75 watt hours
  • Could run 100W light bulb for 98.1 seconds
  • Turlock Hill ~80% efficient, reduces to 78.5 seconds
  • At 286m head (Turlock Hill height): 1 cubic meter could power 100W bulb for 6.2 hours

Physical Infrastructure

  • Tunnel: 600m long, granite blasted with explosives
  • Internal cavern: 28m high, 23m wide, 82m long
  • Four 73MW generators deep inside mountain
  • Upper level: pony motors (electric motors taking grid electricity)
  • Lower level: impellers for pumping water uphill
  • Single machine capable of both pumping and generating electricity
  • Fixed speed generator locked to grid's 50Hz frequency
  • Wicked gates allow throttling down to 5MW
  • Compressed air evacuation system for quick impeller chamber emptying
  • Allows quick switching from generation to pumping

Operational Specifications

  • Maximum flow rate: 28.3 cubic meters/second per generator
  • Total with all four generators: 111.3 cubic meters/second
  • 111 metric tons water/second at full capacity
  • Upper reservoir: 2.3 million cubic meters
  • Full drainage time: 5.5 hours at maximum flow
  • Water pressure: 29 atmospheres when valve opens
  • Driveshaft: 500 RPM rotation
  • Total capacity: 292MW (four 73MW generators)
  • Provides ~4.8% of Ireland's total electricity needs
  • Ireland's peak demand: ~6,000MW at 5:30 PM daily

Irish Grid Analysis and Storage Requirements

Wind Generation Variability

  • Last month wind generation: maximum 4,249MW (80% of max demand) to minimum 300MW (5% of max demand)
  • Grid operator skilled in forecasting wind generation using weather data
  • Ability to predict power availability allows planning for quick response generators

Storage Needs Calculation

  • Average generation past month: 4,840MW
  • ~50% from fossil fuels = 2,420MW replacement needed
  • Would require 8.3 Turlock Hill-sized stations for instant demand
  • But 5.5-hour runtime requires 4-5 groups of 8 stations for 24-hour coverage
  • Total requirement: ~37 equivalent stations
  • Ireland population smaller than NYC, making 37 facilities massive undertaking
  • Single massive reservoir equivalent: 85 million cubic meters (size of Ireland's 9th largest lake)

Site Selection Challenges

Technical Requirements

  • Two reservoirs with massive water volumes
  • Meaningful height separation (minimum 200m)
  • Short horizontal distance between reservoirs
  • Head height to horizontal distance ratio: maximum 1:10 for economic viability
  • 200m head = maximum 2km horizontal distance
  • Turlock Hill ratio: ~1.5
  • Proximity to population centers (avoid transmission losses)
  • Fresh water supply access

Environmental and Logistical Issues

  • Fresh water resources valuable with environmental concerns
  • Closed-loop system still experiences evaporation
  • Ireland's frequent rain replaces evaporation via groundwater
  • Algorithms designed to scour map databases for suitable sites
  • Plenty proposed sites seeking permission/under construction
  • Insufficient sites to satisfy total energy storage needs

Alternative Approaches and Future Developments

Seawater Pumped Storage

  • Uses saltwater instead of fresh water
  • Opens locations where fresh water scarce
  • Japanese experimental facility tested with limited success, eventually closed due to lack of electricity demand
  • Valuable for places like California (fresh water valuable, solar abundant)
  • County Mayo, Ireland proposal: flat-topped mountain next to sea using Atlantic as lower reservoir

Underground Storage

  • Quid Net Energy: pumping water into underground rock layers under pressure
  • Released to drive generator when needed

Current Project Status

  • Ireland: one active site seeking construction permission
  • Estimated cost: $948 million
  • Uses disused strip mine as lower reservoir
  • Has EU backing but no construction start (decade after first proposal)
  • High initial capital cost and environmental concerns block suitable sites
  • Progress too slow for current needs

Future Energy Storage Mix

Multi-Technology Approach

  • Pump storage under pressure from cheaper batteries
  • Batteries don't require massive $1 billion investments
  • Pump storage ability to store energy for longer durations ensures continued use
  • Multiple methods needed, not single solution

2050 Storage Mix Projection

  • Batteries: fast frequency response and short duration load shifting
  • Pumped hydro: longer duration storage (12-72 hours)
  • Hydrogen: only feasible method for longer duration storage
  • Holistic grid analysis required
  • Electricity generation just one aspect of sustainable human adaptation

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome