AI summary by TwinMind
The Truth About the Copilot Changes
Theo - t3․gg
9m 18s
Initial Copilot Experience
- Initially skeptical about GitHub Copilot but completely changed opinion
- Now struggles to develop without it - not due to dependency but reduced tedium
- Enjoys the "game" of learning to write comments/variable names to trigger right code
- Found perfect balance: makes coding faster without getting in the way
Copilot Chat Introduction
- New feature that looks/feels like ChatGPT
- Can ask random questions about code (e.g., "write me a react component with counter button")
- Outputs code as expected from traditional ChatGPT
Workspace Context Integration
- Problem: ChatGPT/GPT-4 has limited context window - can't handle whole codebase
- Solution: New @workspace directive for pre-processing
- Figures out most useful context for GPT-4 before prompting
- Much more likely to get useful results
- Demo in UploadThing mono repo (open source packages)
Practical Testing Examples
- Query: "Where are type definitions for upload button?"
- Without @workspace: AI has no access
- With @workspace: Successfully located correct file with clickable links
- Complex type explanation: UploadBuild type
- Successfully identified as builder pattern
- Explained methods: input, middleware, onUploadComplete, onUploadError
- Provided contextual usage examples from sandbox/minimal-page
- Code generation request: Adding minimal SolidJS example
- Provided step-by-step instructions including npm init, dependencies
- Generated SolidJS code despite no SolidJS existing in current repo branch
- Included Vite bundler setup and configuration
Performance & Reliability Concerns
- Noticeably slower than traditional Copilot autocompletion
- ~50% success rate for complex problems
- 50% chance of wasting time vs speeding up work
- Occasional crashes/bugs during testing
Workflow Philosophy Differences
- Original Copilot: Accelerates existing workflow
- Shows preview while typing
- Press tab to accept or keep typing to ignore
- Non-intrusive, pushes developer forward
- Copilot Chat: Requires workflow change
- Must stop coding to interact
- Word problems into phrases, wait for response
- More intrusive, potentially disruptive to experienced developers
Voice Support Feature
- New voice interaction capability announced
- Developer has no interest in talking to computer about code
- Prefers human interaction over AI voice interface
- Refers viewers to VS Code Channel for voice demos
Overall Assessment
- Chat features feel more like demos than actual workflow improvements
- Original Copilot better at augmenting without changing how developers write code
- Uncertainty about daily usage value
- Potential benefit for onboarding new projects
- Questions whether it meaningfully changes development experience
