AI summary by TwinMind
The ULTIMATE Fingerprint Scanner SPEED Test.
Mrwhosetheboss
5m 38s
Test Setup and Methodology
- Fingerprint scanner speed test across 5 flagship smartphones
- 100 unlock attempts per device to eliminate anomalies
- Testing multiple factors beyond just scan speed:
- Finger placement ease/difficulty
- Error rates
- Overall unlock experience
- Devices tested: Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus, Vivo NEX S, Huawei P20 Pro, iPhone 8 Plus, OnePlus 6
Device Performance Analysis
Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus
- Fingerprint scanner mounted on back, center of device
- Easy to reach, finger naturally rests in place
- Opening animation after unlock not the snappiest
- Finished 4th place
- Performance: middle of pack with top 4 devices closely bunched
Vivo NEX S (In-Display Scanner)
- By far the slowest performer
- Trailing significantly behind other devices early in test
- Three main problems:
- Must turn screen on first when phone stationary/motionless (power saving)
- Higher error rate - false "wrong finger" accusations
- Very specific touch point required on display
- Missing scanner if slightly below or to side
- Performance: 70-75% speed of S9 Plus, even slower vs others
- Scanning time itself not longer - other aspects cause inconvenience
Huawei P20 Pro
- Fingerprint scanner on bottom of device (similar location to NEX S but not in-display)
- Fast scanner but not most pleasant to use
- Sensor completely flush/flat with front of phone
- Cannot feel for it with hands alone - must look at home button
- Performance: middle-of-line, nothing exceptional but fast enough
iPhone 8 Plus
- Hand naturally guided into place
- Touch ID very fast
- First phone to finish 100 unlocks
- Most instantaneous response between scanning and display activation
OnePlus 6
- Very similar to S9 Plus unlock experience
- Fingerprint scanner almost exactly same position and shape as S9 Plus
- But faster than S9 Plus
- Processing time almost identical to iPhone 8 Plus
- Only difference: delay between scanning finger and turning on display vs iPhone's instantaneous response
Final Results and Times
- 1st Place: iPhone 8 Plus - 2 minutes 17 seconds
- Really impressive performance, better than expected
- 2nd Place: OnePlus 6 - 2 minutes 38 seconds
- Processing time nearly identical to iPhone
- Difference: display activation delay vs iPhone's instantaneous response
- 3rd Place: Huawei P20 Pro - 2 minutes 43 seconds
- Just 5 seconds behind OnePlus 6
- Middle-of-line performance, easily fast enough
- 4th Place: Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus - Not specified but closely bunched with top 4
- 5th Place: Vivo NEX S - Significantly slower, raises concerns
Technology Assessment
- In-display fingerprint scanner (Vivo NEX S):
- Cool feature, gets great reactions when shown
- Not quite ready for practical use
- Works but has significant limitations
- Would choose rear-mounted scanner for practical purposes
- Top 4 devices closely bunched in performance
- Real-world performance differences mainly in user experience factors
