AI summary by TwinMind
The Ultimate Smartphone Camera Comparison.
Mrwhosetheboss
9m 12s
Test Setup & Devices
- Ultimate camera test comparing top 5 most requested devices
- Devices tested: Samsung S9+, iPhone X, Google Pixel 2, Huawei P20 Pro, Sony Xperia XZ2
- OnePlus 5T excluded due to imminent replacement
Portrait Mode Performance
- Five images look completely different despite same subject/position
- S9+ and P20 Pro focus on making subject look good (70-80% population preference)
- iPhone X and Pixel 2 focus on realism
- S9+ has best edge detection (improved since launch)
- Pixel 2 and Xperia XZ2 have single camera setup
- Xperia lacks Google's software trickery
- No portrait mode available on Xperia
Video Recording Quality
- All phones shoot 4K resolution (same pixel count)
- S9+, Pixel 2, P20 Pro produce more vibrant images
- Better high dynamic range handling on above three phones
- iPhone X and Xperia XZ2 appear dull/lifeless in color
- Significant detail loss in sky on both phones
- Xperia has worst performance - barely visible cloud detail
Video Stabilization (1080p)
- Xperia XZ2 only phone without optical image stabilization
- Surprisingly handles stabilization well despite lack of OIS
- iPhone X most affected by stepping motion
Slow Motion Video
- S9+, P20 Pro, XZ2 can shoot 960fps (much slower than others)
- Pixel 2 and iPhone X limited to 240fps
- 960fps only available for short periods
- Xperia XZ2 wins this section - only phone shooting super slow-motion at 1080p while maintaining quality
Low Light Performance
- Surprising divergence between cameras
- Google Pixel 2 shows noticeable grain in semi-low light
- iPhone X struggles in very low light conditions
- Pixel 2 has bright image but artificially enhanced with noise
- Samsung's dual aperture system excels in ultra-low light
- Aperture opens up for sufficient light capture
- Clear winner with very little noise
- At 2 Lux (invisible to human eye): S9+ produces reasonable image, P20 Pro close behind
- Samsung huge win in low light, but rare usage conditions for most people
Daylight Photography
- Huawei AI system recognizes blue sky, boosts saturation to maximum
- Very dividing feature - love it or hate it
- Inconsistency problem when AI doesn't recognize subjects (flat looking images)
- Xperia loses almost all sky detail again
- Pixel 2 on top 80% of time for simple landscape shots
- Makes adjustments to contrast, structure, sharpness
- Images instantly ready to post
- All five phones retained foreground detail in challenging backlit subjects
Shutter Speed Performance
- Tested with fast-moving water fountain shots
- All phones captured very quickly (almost stagnant appearance)
- At 6x crop: Huawei P20 Pro does best job capturing quickly
- Sony Xperia does worst in shutter speed
Zoom Capabilities
- Huawei P20 Pro: 3x optical zoom (three camera setup)
- S9+ and iPhone X: 2x optical zoom (dual camera)
- Pixel 2 and Xperia: no optical zoom (single camera)
- Huawei way ahead - not close competition
- Usage frequency consideration important
Selfie Camera Performance
- Similar trend to portrait mode
- Samsung S9+ and Huawei P20 Pro make you look good successfully
- iPhone X and Pixel 2 produce grungier photos with more sharpness/contrast
- Less exposure dialing retains more background detail
- P20 Pro has most detail (24MP front camera)
- Sony has 5MP front camera - poor performance
- First four phones offer selfie focus (front portrait mode)
- Google Pixel 2 only front camera that looks as good as rear camera
Macro Photography
- Samsung's dual aperture system: F1.5 in dark, F2.4 in daylight
- Less light into sensor in daylight vs rivals
- Less blur/bokeh in background (doesn't look as good)
- Google Pixel and Huawei P20 Pro with fixed F2.0 aperture perform better
- Xperia suffers similar fate without Samsung's flexibility
Detail & Resolution
- Huawei has 40MP sensor but users won't typically shoot 40MP
- Longer capture time
- Huge space requirements
- Lack of zoom options
- Uses pixel binning for 10MP photos (40MP sensor not wasted)
- Sony Xperia XZ2 has highest resolution at 19MP
- At 8x zoom: Xperia notably sharper than other four phones
- Other phones trade blows on photo-by-photo basis
- Google Pixel 2 has weakest detail level on average
Final Verdict
- No single best phone outright
- Samsung: makes you look great, kills low-light
- iPhone X: very balanced performance
- Pixel 2: excels at scenic shots and front-facing portrait mode
- Huawei: forward-thinking camera with innovative features
- Sony: best super slow motion video but weakest overall performance
