AI summary by TwinMind

The Ultimate Smartphone Camera Comparison.

Mrwhosetheboss

9m 12s

Test Setup & Devices

  • Ultimate camera test comparing top 5 most requested devices
  • Devices tested: Samsung S9+, iPhone X, Google Pixel 2, Huawei P20 Pro, Sony Xperia XZ2
  • OnePlus 5T excluded due to imminent replacement

Portrait Mode Performance

  • Five images look completely different despite same subject/position
  • S9+ and P20 Pro focus on making subject look good (70-80% population preference)
  • iPhone X and Pixel 2 focus on realism
  • S9+ has best edge detection (improved since launch)
  • Pixel 2 and Xperia XZ2 have single camera setup
    • Xperia lacks Google's software trickery
    • No portrait mode available on Xperia

Video Recording Quality

  • All phones shoot 4K resolution (same pixel count)
  • S9+, Pixel 2, P20 Pro produce more vibrant images
  • Better high dynamic range handling on above three phones
  • iPhone X and Xperia XZ2 appear dull/lifeless in color
  • Significant detail loss in sky on both phones
  • Xperia has worst performance - barely visible cloud detail

Video Stabilization (1080p)

  • Xperia XZ2 only phone without optical image stabilization
  • Surprisingly handles stabilization well despite lack of OIS
  • iPhone X most affected by stepping motion

Slow Motion Video

  • S9+, P20 Pro, XZ2 can shoot 960fps (much slower than others)
  • Pixel 2 and iPhone X limited to 240fps
  • 960fps only available for short periods
  • Xperia XZ2 wins this section - only phone shooting super slow-motion at 1080p while maintaining quality

Low Light Performance

  • Surprising divergence between cameras
  • Google Pixel 2 shows noticeable grain in semi-low light
  • iPhone X struggles in very low light conditions
  • Pixel 2 has bright image but artificially enhanced with noise
  • Samsung's dual aperture system excels in ultra-low light
    • Aperture opens up for sufficient light capture
    • Clear winner with very little noise
  • At 2 Lux (invisible to human eye): S9+ produces reasonable image, P20 Pro close behind
  • Samsung huge win in low light, but rare usage conditions for most people

Daylight Photography

  • Huawei AI system recognizes blue sky, boosts saturation to maximum
  • Very dividing feature - love it or hate it
  • Inconsistency problem when AI doesn't recognize subjects (flat looking images)
  • Xperia loses almost all sky detail again
  • Pixel 2 on top 80% of time for simple landscape shots
    • Makes adjustments to contrast, structure, sharpness
    • Images instantly ready to post
  • All five phones retained foreground detail in challenging backlit subjects

Shutter Speed Performance

  • Tested with fast-moving water fountain shots
  • All phones captured very quickly (almost stagnant appearance)
  • At 6x crop: Huawei P20 Pro does best job capturing quickly
  • Sony Xperia does worst in shutter speed

Zoom Capabilities

  • Huawei P20 Pro: 3x optical zoom (three camera setup)
  • S9+ and iPhone X: 2x optical zoom (dual camera)
  • Pixel 2 and Xperia: no optical zoom (single camera)
  • Huawei way ahead - not close competition
  • Usage frequency consideration important

Selfie Camera Performance

  • Similar trend to portrait mode
  • Samsung S9+ and Huawei P20 Pro make you look good successfully
  • iPhone X and Pixel 2 produce grungier photos with more sharpness/contrast
  • Less exposure dialing retains more background detail
  • P20 Pro has most detail (24MP front camera)
  • Sony has 5MP front camera - poor performance
  • First four phones offer selfie focus (front portrait mode)
  • Google Pixel 2 only front camera that looks as good as rear camera

Macro Photography

  • Samsung's dual aperture system: F1.5 in dark, F2.4 in daylight
  • Less light into sensor in daylight vs rivals
  • Less blur/bokeh in background (doesn't look as good)
  • Google Pixel and Huawei P20 Pro with fixed F2.0 aperture perform better
  • Xperia suffers similar fate without Samsung's flexibility

Detail & Resolution

  • Huawei has 40MP sensor but users won't typically shoot 40MP
    • Longer capture time
    • Huge space requirements
    • Lack of zoom options
  • Uses pixel binning for 10MP photos (40MP sensor not wasted)
  • Sony Xperia XZ2 has highest resolution at 19MP
  • At 8x zoom: Xperia notably sharper than other four phones
  • Other phones trade blows on photo-by-photo basis
  • Google Pixel 2 has weakest detail level on average

Final Verdict

  • No single best phone outright
  • Samsung: makes you look great, kills low-light
  • iPhone X: very balanced performance
  • Pixel 2: excels at scenic shots and front-facing portrait mode
  • Huawei: forward-thinking camera with innovative features
  • Sony: best super slow motion video but weakest overall performance

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome