AI summary by TwinMind
The University of Impossible-to-Get-Into (Update) | Freakonomics Radio
Freakonomics Radio Network
1h 18m 20s
Operation Varsity Blues and Elite College Scarcity
- 2019 FBI investigation revealed largest college admission scam ever prosecuted
- Wealthy parents paid bribes through consultant to get children into elite schools
- Fake test scores, athletic credentials, cash payments to coaches
- Lori Laughlin and husband paid $500K for daughters' USC crew team spots (neither rowed)
- 57 people charged including coaches, administrators, parents
- Highlighted extreme scarcity and value of elite college slots
- 4,000 US higher education institutions fall into two categories:
- Vast majority: effectively open enrollment
- Small minority: competitive/selective model (winning over time)
Elite University Application Trends
- Less selective universities and community colleges saw enrollment drop during pandemic
- Elite schools set new application records
- Harvard up 42% in 2021 after eliminating SAT requirement
- 5% drop in 2022 amid Claudine Gay controversy
- Penn, Dartmouth, Columbia, MIT saw increasing applications
- Elite schools charge $40K-$60K+ annually
- Admit only tiny share of applicants despite high demand
- Could double tuition and still fill seats
The Expansion Puzzle - Peter Blair's Research
- Harvard economist Peter Blair (former theoretical physicist from Bahamas)
- Over past 50 years, US college enrollment increased almost twofold
- Most schools expanded except top-tier institutions
- Schools in top 2% SAT distribution grew only 7% (1990-2015)
- Non-elite schools grew 60% in same period
- Elite colleges were historically largest institutions
- Between 1940-1980, Stanford and Princeton expanded significantly
- 1970s-80s: elite schools stopped expanding despite rising demand
Historical Admissions Rates vs. Current Selectivity
- 1990s admissions rates much higher than today
- University of Chicago, UPenn: 40-50% (coin flip odds)
- Columbia: ~30%
- Stanford, Harvard: ~20%
- Current rates dramatically lower:
- UChicago, UPenn: 8-9%
- Harvard, Stanford: 4-5%
- Lower rates not just due to students applying to more schools
- Competitive dynamics fostered by restricted spaces at elite institutions
Testing Explanations for Non-Expansion
- Student quality: Students now more qualified than ever
- Faculty quality: More PhD graduates available with strong credentials
- Physical space: Duke, Stanford have ample space; Columbia can build vertically
- Financial resources: Elite schools have massive endowments
- Harvard: ~$50 billion
- Yale: ~$41 billion
- Stanford: ~$36 billion
- None of these factors explain the puzzle
The Luxury Goods Model
- Elite universities operate like luxury goods market (Hermes example)
- Scarcity itself confers value on the product
- Universities compete on "prestige" - relative selectivity measure
- Blair-Smets economic model with three steps:
- Students choose colleges to apply to
- Colleges decide which students to admit
- Students pick which college to attend
- Model successfully replicated reality with prestige variable "on"
- With prestige "off": higher admissions rates, more applicants, more matriculants, lower test scores, decreased competition
US News Rankings Impact
- First college rankings published 1983 (same period elite schools stopped expanding)
- Blair doesn't claim causation but shows correlation
- Universities care about prestige as relative comparison
- Society celebrates exclusivity - parents, alumni, students all participate
- Alumni pride in increased selectivity ("wouldn't get in today")
Elite Education Value Debate
- Only 39 elite schools enroll 170,000 undergrads (1% of 17 million total)
- Morty Shapiro (former Northwestern president): disproportionate research focus on tiny segment
- Australia's "Group of Eight" educates 25% of students, 50% of doctors/dentists
- Elite schools expand internationally (Middle East, Asia) but not domestically
- NYU: Abu Dhabi, Shanghai campuses
- Qatar campuses: Georgetown, Carnegie Mellon, Northwestern
Student Perspectives on Brand vs. Education
- Columbia students interviewed about ivy league education vs. brand value
- Majority valued brand more than education
- "Same education available at non-ivy schools"
- Brand name justifies $80K annual cost
- Connections and CV impact primary motivations
- Network effects and post-graduation opportunities
Economic Returns to Elite Education
- College provides: knowledge acquisition, lifelong networks, peer effects, status signaling
- Stacy Bergdale-Alan Krueger study: 14,000+ students from 30 colleges
- Raw correlation: elite school graduates earn more
- Controlled analysis: no average earnings benefit from attending more elite vs. less selective school
- Exception: benefits for economically disadvantaged groups and minority students
- Signaling theory (Brian Kaplan): college degree as social signal
- Credential inflation: average education level rose 1.2 years (1970s-1990s) without job changes
Research vs. Teaching Quality Trade-offs
- Elite universities optimize for research production over instruction
- Best researchers often poor teachers (Isaac Newton example)
- Morty Shapiro study: students with non-tenure track professors in intro courses performed better in advanced courses
- Adjuncts paid much less but may provide better instruction
- Reputation trumps actual instruction quality
- Miguel Urola: elite universities have "margin of error" unlike restaurants
University of California Success Model
- UC system doubled in size over 30 years
- 1960 California Master Plan: educate top 12.5% of high school graduates
- Grew with California population expansion
- Built new campuses (UC Merced opened 2005, 10,000+ undergrads)
- Four UC campuses in top 25 US News global rankings
- Berkeley ranks 4th globally, above Cambridge
- Billions in federal research funding
- California weather advantage for faculty recruitment
- Structural advantage: campuses share resources, don't compete zero-sum
Coordination Solution Proposal
- Elite schools could coordinate expansion like climate change Paris Accords
- Individual university can't shift expansion norm alone
- Ivy League could agree to admit 10% more students collectively
- Antitrust laws currently prevent coordination
- 1990s: universities coordinated admissions/financial aid until ruled illegal by FTC
- Sherman Antitrust Act prohibits collusion
- Blair argues this case could increase social surplus, not decrease it
Recent Challenges and Scandals
- 2024: Eight colleges paid $100M+ to settle financial aid price-fixing claims
- 200,000 students allegedly harmed by "cartel"
- Universities face criticism from both political sides
- Right wing: suspicion of liberal orientation
- Left wing: perpetuating inequality machine
- Universities "abandoned" with "no one to protect them"
Current State of Higher Education Confidence
- Fewer than 40% of US adults express confidence in higher education (Gallup)
- Harvard specific controversies:
- Claudine Gay resignation over plagiarism and anti-Semitism testimony
- Supreme Court affirmative action decision (Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard)
- Pool of qualified applicants doubled since women admitted to Princeton (1969)
- Obvious solution: expand supply for diversity/opportunity
Causes of Declining Public Confidence
- Sticker price increases: $60K-$70K tuition common
- Spending on amenities vs. educational mission (stadiums, pools, gyms)
- Intellectual safety vs. intellectual growth problem
- 2016 post-Trump election: support rooms with puppies, coloring books
- Universities took political positions unpopular with constituencies
- Late adoption of institutional neutrality (Calvin Committee Report 1967)
- Social media amplification of individual voices over institutional positions
Proposed Solutions
- Allow federal government to mandate expansion as condition for resources
- Tax endowments more aggressively until supply expands
- Universities need clear argument for serving public good
- Expansion as demonstrable signal of opening opportunity
- Research impact examples: COVID vaccine development, major company creation
- Potential to find more innovators from underrepresented backgrounds
