AI summary by TwinMind

The Wobbly Future of the Hard Disk Drive Industry

Asianometry

18m 29s

HDD Industry Overview and Decline

  • Big three companies: Seagate, Western Digital, Toshiba in decline
  • SSD rise: faster, more reliable, consume less power
  • Technology evolution: began 30 years ago replacing audio tapes/answering machines
  • Current market: $60 billion
  • HDD unit volume sales will never return to previous levels
  • Consumer shift: no longer buy HDDs for iPods, laptops, desktops

Enterprise Market Lifeline

  • New market: growing demand from enterprise companies
  • Nearline storage: data accessible but not frequently/immediately needed
  • Companies producing data faster than affordable storage capacity
  • HDDs advantage: cheaper per bit storage costs
  • Challenge: triple gridlock of technical problems ended HDD capacity gains

HDD Technical Fundamentals

  • Basic operation unchanged since IBM RAMAC
  • Data storage: digital bits on thin magnetized film on disc platters
  • Bit arrangement: concentric circles/tracks
  • Bit composition: randomly packed cluster of magnetic grains (5-15 nm wide)
  • Platter operation: spins 1,200-7,000+ RPM
  • Read/write head: flies few nanometers over platter sides

Aerial Density Evolution

  • 50 years since 1957: bits per square inch increased 300 million times
  • Aerial density (AD) calculation: track density × linear density
  • Original RAMAC: 20 bits track density, 100 bits linear density = 2,000 bits per square inch
  • Growth patterns:
    • First 10 years: 50%+ annually
    • 1970-1990: 25% annually average
    • 1988: Giant magnetoresistance discovery by Albert Fert (French) and Peter Grünberg (German)
    • 2007 Nobel Prize in Physics for discovery
    • 1990s: reached 100 billion bits per square inch

Longitudinal to Perpendicular Transition

  • Longitudinal Magnetic Recording (LMR): bits magnetized horizontally
  • LMR fundamental problems:
    • Neighboring bits interference with opposite magnetization
    • Super paramagnetic limits: grains too small destabilize data storage
    • Energy threshold lowered to ordinary thermal energy level
    • Hard cap: ~100 billion bits per square inch
  • Perpendicular Magnetic Recording (PMR): bits magnetized vertically (up/down)
  • PMR invention: Professor Shunichi Iwasaki (1975)
  • Commercial breakthrough: December 2004 Toshiba announcement
    • 1.8-inch drives: 40GB and 80GB capacity
    • 133 billion bits per square inch
  • PMR transition: 2005-2006 (last major technological transition)

Current Scaling Challenges

  • PMR/Shingled Magnetic Recording: scaled to 1.2 trillion bits per square inch
  • Peak reached: 2015 (8 years ago)
  • Historical growth: 30-60% compound annual growth rate
  • Current compensation: adding more discs/heads
    • 2022-2023: 22 terabyte HDD with 10 platters
    • 2013: 7 platters
  • SSD competition: 3D NAND 176-layer reaching 6.4 trillion bits per square inch

The Trilemma Problem

  • Three interconnected technical limits:
    1. Shrinking grains: super paramagnetic limit prevents further reduction
    2. Fewer grains per bit: reduces signal-to-noise ratio, increases error rates
    3. Higher coercivity materials: traditional read/write heads cannot generate sufficient magnetic field
  • Magnetic saturation fields limited to ~2.4 Tesla
  • Solution approach: energy assisted recording

Energy Assisted Recording Concept

  • Strategy: switch to thermal resistant magnetic grain materials
  • Temporary energy delivery lowers bit coercivity
  • Allows magnetic field to flip bits
  • Analogy: heating chocolate to make it manipulable

HAMR (Heat Assisted Magnetic Recording)

  • Seagate and Western Digital development: over decade-long effort
  • Technology: laser integrated into read/write head
  • Operation: laser heats spot to 400°C+
  • Spot size: 10×60 nm wide for 1 trillion bits per square inch
  • Nearfield transducer: focuses laser beam smaller than wavelength
  • Cooling: nanosecond return to prior coercivity levels
  • Historical background: 1954 RCA patent, 1999 Japanese scientists invention

HAMR Development Timeline

  • 2012: Seagate COO hinted HAMR coming 2014
  • 2013: Western Digital displayed prototype in China
  • Predictions: 1-5 trillion bits per square inch
  • Future technology: bit patterned media using nano imprint lithography
  • 2015: Showa Denko delayed shipment to 2018
  • Helium-sealed HDDs introduction prolonged existing PMR paradigm
  • Challenge: reliable nearfield transducer (original gold transducers deformed)

MAMR (Microwave Assisted Magnetic Recording)

  • October 2017: Western Digital announced split from HAMR
  • Technology basis: 2003 Kristoff Theon discovery
  • Operation: nanoscale microwave field via spin torque oscillator
  • Frequency: 15-20 GHz exciting cobalt-platinum alloy grains
  • Advantages: easier integration, no heat/new materials
  • 2017 predictions: production by 2019, 4.5 trillion bits per square inch by 2025
  • Equivalent: 40 terabyte HDDs

Technology Competition and Resolution

  • Seagate disagreement: HAMR had more lasting power for smaller grains
  • 2-year face-off: Seagate vs Western Digital
  • January 2020: Western Digital returned to HAMR roadmap
  • MAMR repositioned after ePMR (energy assisted PMR)
  • Western Digital stopped discussing MAMR

Industry Challenges and Future

  • COVID-19 impact: supply chain issues, demand fluctuations
  • Revenue decline: 2023 down 30% from previous years
  • HAMR launch timing: 2024 expected for Seagate Mosaic 3+ platform
  • Competition threats:
    • SSDs with superior performance
    • Optical discs revival
    • Magnetic tape: 20 terabyte cartridges, cheap, reliable, offline, energy efficient
    • DNA storage: immature but huge advantages in capacity, energy, retention
  • HAMR comparison: "HDD's EUV" - must deliver technological benefits or face consolidation

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome