AI summary by TwinMind
The Worst Crash That Never Happened
neo
21m 44s
Air Canada Flight 759 San Francisco Incident (July 2017)
- Flight Details: Air Canada 759 approaching SFO at midnight, cleared for runway 28R
- Airport Configuration: Runway 28L closed for maintenance, lights turned off
- Pilot Error: Confused taxiway Charlie (with 4 aircraft lined up) for runway 28R
- Expected to see two parallel runways based on previous experience
- Mistook center runway for 28L, taxiway for 28R
- Aircraft at Risk: Over 1,000 passengers total
- United One (Boeing 787)
- Philippine Airlines 115 (Airbus 340)
- Two additional United flights
Contributing Factors
- NOTAM Issues: Runway closure listed in Notice to Airmen but missed by crew
- NOTAMs typically several pages long, difficult to extract relevant details
- Visual Approach: Clear weather conditions, normal procedure
- Could have used ILS (Instrument Landing System) for backup confirmation
- First officer failed to dial in frequency manually for runway 28R
- Crew Fatigue:
- Long day from Toronto, inner clock at 3:03 AM
- Canadian fatigue rules less stringent than US regulations
- Captain had no significant rest for 19 hours
- Flight Path Design: Approach comes at slight angle from right to reduce noise pollution
- Tower perspective shows aircraft appearing left of runway centerline as normal
Critical Moments
- Pilot Confirmation: "Tower, just wanna confirm... we see some lights on the runway there"
- Tower Response: 5-second delay, confirmed clearance for 28R, "no one on 28R but you"
- United Pilot Alert: "Where is this guy going? He's on the taxiway" (no call sign to save time)
- Go-Around: Air Canada missed tail fins by only few meters
- Outcome: Potential largest general aviation accident in history avoided
Post-Incident Changes
- NTSB Investigation: Full investigation launched with comprehensive recommendations
- Policy Changes:
- Visual approaches at night prohibited when adjacent runway closed at SFO
- Two air traffic controllers required during late night arrival rush
- Ongoing Concerns: Unprecedented number of close calls at US airports in recent years
JFK Airport Incident (January 13, 2023)
- Aircraft Involved: American Airlines 106 (departing) and Delta 1943 (taking off)
- Taxi Instructions: American 106 told to taxi left Bravo, hold short of Kilo for runway 4L
- Communication Error: Pilot didn't read back runway assignment, only taxi route
- Navigation Error: American 106 continued straight on Juliet instead of turning right on Kilo
- Crossed runway 31L where Delta 1943 was departing
- Contributing Factors:
- Winds 340° at 18 knots, gusts 24 knots (favored runway 31L)
- Operational reasons required using runway 4L
- Separate frequencies: American on ground, Delta on tower
- Resolution: Tower controller stopped Delta 1943 about 1,000 feet from intersection
- Classification: Category B runway incursion
Austin Airport Incident (February 2023)
- Aircraft: FedEx 1432 (Boeing 767 cargo) landing, Southwest 708 departing
- Weather: Dense fog layer 1,000 feet thick, Category 3 ILS approach required
- Visibility: RVR touchdown 1,400 feet, midpoint 600 feet, rollout 1,800 feet
- Sequence:
- FedEx 5.4 miles out, cleared to land 18L
- Southwest cleared for takeoff with "traffic 3 miles final is heavy 767"
- Southwest delayed takeoff by 60 seconds
- Critical Moment: FedEx at 150 feet saw Southwest still rolling slowly
- Direct Communication: FedEx told Southwest "abort" directly (violation of protocol)
- Outcome: Aircraft came within 100 feet of each other, FedEx successfully climbed over Southwest
Aviation Safety Statistics
- Runway Incursion Categories: A (most serious) through D, plus actual accidents
- Historical Trends:
- 2007: 22 Category A incidents
- Past decade: Never more than 9 Category A incidents per year
- Category B: Typically 10-20 per year, 2023 tracking for over 20
- 2023 Status: 8 runway incidents reported, 3 classified as Category B
Historical Context: Tenerife Disaster (1977)
- Deadliest Aviation Accident: Two Boeing 747s (KLM and Pan Am) collided on runway
- Circumstances: Deteriorated weather, neither aircraft nor tower could see each other
- Cause: KLM pilot assumed runway clear, began takeoff while Pan Am was taxiing
