AI summary by TwinMind

The Worst Crash That Never Happened

neo

21m 44s

Air Canada Flight 759 San Francisco Incident (July 2017)

  • Flight Details: Air Canada 759 approaching SFO at midnight, cleared for runway 28R
  • Airport Configuration: Runway 28L closed for maintenance, lights turned off
  • Pilot Error: Confused taxiway Charlie (with 4 aircraft lined up) for runway 28R
    • Expected to see two parallel runways based on previous experience
    • Mistook center runway for 28L, taxiway for 28R
  • Aircraft at Risk: Over 1,000 passengers total
    • United One (Boeing 787)
    • Philippine Airlines 115 (Airbus 340)
    • Two additional United flights

Contributing Factors

  • NOTAM Issues: Runway closure listed in Notice to Airmen but missed by crew
    • NOTAMs typically several pages long, difficult to extract relevant details
  • Visual Approach: Clear weather conditions, normal procedure
    • Could have used ILS (Instrument Landing System) for backup confirmation
    • First officer failed to dial in frequency manually for runway 28R
  • Crew Fatigue:
    • Long day from Toronto, inner clock at 3:03 AM
    • Canadian fatigue rules less stringent than US regulations
    • Captain had no significant rest for 19 hours
  • Flight Path Design: Approach comes at slight angle from right to reduce noise pollution
    • Tower perspective shows aircraft appearing left of runway centerline as normal

Critical Moments

  • Pilot Confirmation: "Tower, just wanna confirm... we see some lights on the runway there"
  • Tower Response: 5-second delay, confirmed clearance for 28R, "no one on 28R but you"
  • United Pilot Alert: "Where is this guy going? He's on the taxiway" (no call sign to save time)
  • Go-Around: Air Canada missed tail fins by only few meters
  • Outcome: Potential largest general aviation accident in history avoided

Post-Incident Changes

  • NTSB Investigation: Full investigation launched with comprehensive recommendations
  • Policy Changes:
    • Visual approaches at night prohibited when adjacent runway closed at SFO
    • Two air traffic controllers required during late night arrival rush
  • Ongoing Concerns: Unprecedented number of close calls at US airports in recent years

JFK Airport Incident (January 13, 2023)

  • Aircraft Involved: American Airlines 106 (departing) and Delta 1943 (taking off)
  • Taxi Instructions: American 106 told to taxi left Bravo, hold short of Kilo for runway 4L
  • Communication Error: Pilot didn't read back runway assignment, only taxi route
  • Navigation Error: American 106 continued straight on Juliet instead of turning right on Kilo
    • Crossed runway 31L where Delta 1943 was departing
  • Contributing Factors:
    • Winds 340° at 18 knots, gusts 24 knots (favored runway 31L)
    • Operational reasons required using runway 4L
    • Separate frequencies: American on ground, Delta on tower
  • Resolution: Tower controller stopped Delta 1943 about 1,000 feet from intersection
  • Classification: Category B runway incursion

Austin Airport Incident (February 2023)

  • Aircraft: FedEx 1432 (Boeing 767 cargo) landing, Southwest 708 departing
  • Weather: Dense fog layer 1,000 feet thick, Category 3 ILS approach required
  • Visibility: RVR touchdown 1,400 feet, midpoint 600 feet, rollout 1,800 feet
  • Sequence:
    • FedEx 5.4 miles out, cleared to land 18L
    • Southwest cleared for takeoff with "traffic 3 miles final is heavy 767"
    • Southwest delayed takeoff by 60 seconds
  • Critical Moment: FedEx at 150 feet saw Southwest still rolling slowly
  • Direct Communication: FedEx told Southwest "abort" directly (violation of protocol)
  • Outcome: Aircraft came within 100 feet of each other, FedEx successfully climbed over Southwest

Aviation Safety Statistics

  • Runway Incursion Categories: A (most serious) through D, plus actual accidents
  • Historical Trends:
    • 2007: 22 Category A incidents
    • Past decade: Never more than 9 Category A incidents per year
    • Category B: Typically 10-20 per year, 2023 tracking for over 20
  • 2023 Status: 8 runway incidents reported, 3 classified as Category B

Historical Context: Tenerife Disaster (1977)

  • Deadliest Aviation Accident: Two Boeing 747s (KLM and Pan Am) collided on runway
  • Circumstances: Deteriorated weather, neither aircraft nor tower could see each other
  • Cause: KLM pilot assumed runway clear, began takeoff while Pan Am was taxiing

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome