AI summary by TwinMind
The Worst Product I've Ever Reviewed... For Now
Marques Brownlee
25m 3s
Product Overview
- Humane AI pin: small wearable computer with AI assistant
- Size: large watch equivalent
- Features: camera, microphone, touchpad, laser projector
- Price: $700 + $24/month subscription for data/services/storage
- Standalone device with own internet connection and phone number
- Does not pair with smartphones
Hardware Build Quality
- Impressive construction: aluminum, dense, solid feeling
- Three color options: matte black (cheapest), white (+$100), black/silver (+$100)
- Dense sensor package: camera, microphones, lights, Class 2 laser projector
- Strong magnetic attachment system
- Pin attaches to "booster" (external battery) through clothing
- Satisfying magnetic connection sound
- Two boosters included for hot-swapping
- Charging accessories included:
- Reflective charging case (USB-C)
- Desktop charging puck for pin + booster
- LED notification lights at top, small pin light for waiting notifications
- Excellent craftsmanship and engineering effort evident
Core Functionality
- AI assistant without wake word - touch to activate microphone
- Voice queries processed in cloud: "Empire State Building is 1,454 ft tall to the tip"
- Multimodal capabilities - camera can analyze surroundings
- Can take pictures, 15-second videos (auto-uploads while charging)
- Memory function - remembers user requests
- Humane Center web portal (no app) shows:
- Call/text history
- Music listening history
- Query responses
- Saved memories
Projector Interface
- Laser projector creates 720p green display on palm
- Gesture controls using Time-of-Flight sensor:
- Roll hand like marble to navigate
- Pinch to select
- Fist to go back
- Push forward for deeper menu navigation
- 3D UI system requires learning curve
- Unlock mechanism uses spatial number selection
- "Borderline magic" first impression but fidgety and slow
Translation Feature
- Two-finger gesture activates real-time translation
- Auto-detects language, translates to English
- Bidirectional translation capability
- Demonstrated as best tech demo feature
Performance Issues
- Frequent inaccuracy and hallucinations
- Slow response times due to cloud dependency
- Server timeouts with poor internet connection
- Wrong answers common:
- Solar eclipse date incorrect (said 2044)
- Misheard "Asian food" as "Ash"
- Incorrect Nets game information
- Traffic query returned generic instructions
Battery and Thermal Problems
- Inconsistent battery life: 2-4 hours range
- Requires multiple daily charges and booster swaps
- Constantly warm during operation
- Multiple overheating incidents requiring cooldown
- Heat amplified by wireless charging inefficiency through fabric gap
- Weight causes clothing sag, especially with lighter materials
Hardware Limitations
- Cannot set timers or alarms
- Notification light outside peripheral vision
- Designed for specific body side (conflicts with seatbelts)
- Poor photo/video quality: noisy, squarish aspect ratio, 15-second video limit
- Projector not bright enough outdoors, dims with distance
- No readable text in many lighting conditions
Software/Service Limitations
- No apps available
- Limited account integrations: Apple, Google, Microsoft, Tidal only
- No access to: Uber, Spotify, WhatsApp, calendar, Gmail, Amazon, flight booking
- Humane Center web portal randomly stops working
Smartphone Comparison
- Smartphones superior in every comparable function:
- Better photo/video quality and framing
- Easier calling/texting
- Faster information lookup
- More versatile usage (loud/private places, any outfit)
- Full app ecosystem
- Photo sharing example: AI pin requires complex gesture navigation vs. simple phone interface
- Visual recognition: phone camera + Google Lens faster than AI pin processing
Assistant Limitations
- Lacks user context knowledge that smartphones possess
- Separate phone number creates conversation fragmentation
- Cannot access existing text threads or call history
- Massive disadvantage for personalized assistance
- No integration with user's existing digital life
Design Philosophy Analysis
- Humane's strategy: build standalone device for future vision
- Refuses smartphone integration to avoid future feature removal
- Current product "hamstrung by its ideal future version"
- Similar to Vision Pro's standalone approach
- Present functionality sacrificed for future ambitions
Positive Use Cases
- Voice memo while driving: hands-free idea capture worked well
- First-person video recording from chest position
- Minimal screen time goal alignment
- Occasional successful quick responses for basic queries
- Translation feature impressive when working properly
Target User Assessment
- Current recommendation: nobody should buy this device
- Potential user: someone wanting minimal phone screen time
- Even ideal users face too much friction and annoyance
- Product creates more problems than it solves
- Author skipped wearing device on travel day due to anticipated hassles
Future Development
- Team has shared roadmap with "decent stuff" including number sharing
- No dates or specific information provided
- Long development path ahead
- Respect for attempt at innovation despite current failures
