AI summary by TwinMind

The Worst Product I've Ever Reviewed... For Now

Marques Brownlee

25m 3s

Product Overview

  • Humane AI pin: small wearable computer with AI assistant
  • Size: large watch equivalent
  • Features: camera, microphone, touchpad, laser projector
  • Price: $700 + $24/month subscription for data/services/storage
  • Standalone device with own internet connection and phone number
  • Does not pair with smartphones

Hardware Build Quality

  • Impressive construction: aluminum, dense, solid feeling
  • Three color options: matte black (cheapest), white (+$100), black/silver (+$100)
  • Dense sensor package: camera, microphones, lights, Class 2 laser projector
  • Strong magnetic attachment system
    • Pin attaches to "booster" (external battery) through clothing
    • Satisfying magnetic connection sound
    • Two boosters included for hot-swapping
  • Charging accessories included:
    • Reflective charging case (USB-C)
    • Desktop charging puck for pin + booster
  • LED notification lights at top, small pin light for waiting notifications
  • Excellent craftsmanship and engineering effort evident

Core Functionality

  • AI assistant without wake word - touch to activate microphone
  • Voice queries processed in cloud: "Empire State Building is 1,454 ft tall to the tip"
  • Multimodal capabilities - camera can analyze surroundings
  • Can take pictures, 15-second videos (auto-uploads while charging)
  • Memory function - remembers user requests
  • Humane Center web portal (no app) shows:
    • Call/text history
    • Music listening history
    • Query responses
    • Saved memories

Projector Interface

  • Laser projector creates 720p green display on palm
  • Gesture controls using Time-of-Flight sensor:
    • Roll hand like marble to navigate
    • Pinch to select
    • Fist to go back
    • Push forward for deeper menu navigation
  • 3D UI system requires learning curve
  • Unlock mechanism uses spatial number selection
  • "Borderline magic" first impression but fidgety and slow

Translation Feature

  • Two-finger gesture activates real-time translation
  • Auto-detects language, translates to English
  • Bidirectional translation capability
  • Demonstrated as best tech demo feature

Performance Issues

  • Frequent inaccuracy and hallucinations
  • Slow response times due to cloud dependency
  • Server timeouts with poor internet connection
  • Wrong answers common:
    • Solar eclipse date incorrect (said 2044)
    • Misheard "Asian food" as "Ash"
    • Incorrect Nets game information
    • Traffic query returned generic instructions

Battery and Thermal Problems

  • Inconsistent battery life: 2-4 hours range
  • Requires multiple daily charges and booster swaps
  • Constantly warm during operation
  • Multiple overheating incidents requiring cooldown
  • Heat amplified by wireless charging inefficiency through fabric gap
  • Weight causes clothing sag, especially with lighter materials

Hardware Limitations

  • Cannot set timers or alarms
  • Notification light outside peripheral vision
  • Designed for specific body side (conflicts with seatbelts)
  • Poor photo/video quality: noisy, squarish aspect ratio, 15-second video limit
  • Projector not bright enough outdoors, dims with distance
  • No readable text in many lighting conditions

Software/Service Limitations

  • No apps available
  • Limited account integrations: Apple, Google, Microsoft, Tidal only
  • No access to: Uber, Spotify, WhatsApp, calendar, Gmail, Amazon, flight booking
  • Humane Center web portal randomly stops working

Smartphone Comparison

  • Smartphones superior in every comparable function:
    • Better photo/video quality and framing
    • Easier calling/texting
    • Faster information lookup
    • More versatile usage (loud/private places, any outfit)
    • Full app ecosystem
  • Photo sharing example: AI pin requires complex gesture navigation vs. simple phone interface
  • Visual recognition: phone camera + Google Lens faster than AI pin processing

Assistant Limitations

  • Lacks user context knowledge that smartphones possess
  • Separate phone number creates conversation fragmentation
  • Cannot access existing text threads or call history
  • Massive disadvantage for personalized assistance
  • No integration with user's existing digital life

Design Philosophy Analysis

  • Humane's strategy: build standalone device for future vision
  • Refuses smartphone integration to avoid future feature removal
  • Current product "hamstrung by its ideal future version"
  • Similar to Vision Pro's standalone approach
  • Present functionality sacrificed for future ambitions

Positive Use Cases

  • Voice memo while driving: hands-free idea capture worked well
  • First-person video recording from chest position
  • Minimal screen time goal alignment
  • Occasional successful quick responses for basic queries
  • Translation feature impressive when working properly

Target User Assessment

  • Current recommendation: nobody should buy this device
  • Potential user: someone wanting minimal phone screen time
  • Even ideal users face too much friction and annoyance
  • Product creates more problems than it solves
  • Author skipped wearing device on travel day due to anticipated hassles

Future Development

  • Team has shared roadmap with "decent stuff" including number sharing
  • No dates or specific information provided
  • Long development path ahead
  • Respect for attempt at innovation despite current failures

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome