AI summary by TwinMind
These benchmarks look terrible for React...
Theo - t3․gg
15m 42s
Initial Flawed Benchmark Results
- Chart showed poor performance for frameworks like Svelte, React, Vue, Solid
- Created by Matteo (Fastify core creator, Node contributor)
- Benchmark measured HTML page generation speed for SSR
- Results appeared suspicious given Svelte's known performance capabilities
Sponsor Segment - Savala
- PHP deployment platform backed by Kinsta
- One-click deployment with Cloudflare integration
- DDoS protection, CDN, edge caching capabilities
- $50 free credit offer
- Supports Docker image deployments including databases
Major Benchmark Issues Identified
- Rich Harris (Svelte): Fixed Svelte implementation doing unnecessary work
- Changed from creating new arrays to pushing elements
- One-line change moved Svelte from bottom to near top performance
- AI-generated code was copying arrays unnecessarily
- Ryan Carniato (Solid): Found inconsistencies in Solid implementation
- Removed extra style bindings others weren't doing
- Turned off hydration for fair comparison with Fastify/HTMX
- Without hydration: 1305 min, 1506 average vs Fastify's 893 min, 982 average
- React Issue: Running in development mode instead of production
- Fixed by adding NODE_ENV=production
- Massive performance improvement from single environment variable
AI-Generated Code Problems
- Benchmarks written by LLMs without proper optimization
- Recommendation: Consult framework creators when results seem suspicious
- Especially for known fast frameworks like Svelte, Solid
Corrected Benchmark Results (Requests per Second)
- Fastify HTML: 1,888 (baseline - simple HTML templating)
- Vue: 1,128 (best comprehensive library performance)
- Svelte 5: 968 (pre-release version)
- Solid: 907
- Preact: 717
- React 19 RC: 572
Technical Implementation Details
- Test used 2,398 divs rendering spiral pattern
- All frameworks used production builds (except Fastify HTML, EJS)
- No client-side reactivity features used
- Style bindings handled via template literals where appropriate
- React/Solid used className instead of inline styles for efficiency
Framework-Specific Analysis
- Fastify HTML: Simple wrapper, no hydration capabilities
- Vue: Surprisingly fast render-to-string performance
- Svelte: Custom templating language enables high performance
- Solid: Client-side focused but strong SSR performance
- React: Focus on streaming/chunked rendering vs full page blocking
- render-to-string now deprecated
- New render-to-markup proposal for non-hydrated HTML
Performance Context
- Fastify comparison: 36,000 req/sec vs Rails 5,300 req/sec
- React achieving 50% speed of static HTML generation impressive given capabilities
- Vue performing close to Fastify remarkable for full framework
Key Takeaways
- SSR performance differences less critical than expected
- All modern frameworks achieved "pretty damn good" performance
- Proper configuration (production mode) crucial
- Framework-specific optimizations matter significantly
