AI summary by TwinMind

This Phone is $169 - What's the Catch?

Marques Brownlee

10m 55s

Moto G Play 2023 Overview

  • $169 smartphone from 2023
  • 6.5-inch 90Hz display with hole punch cutout
  • 5,000mAh battery
  • Triple cameras
  • MicroSD card slot for expandable storage
  • Headphone jack
  • Water resistance (IP52)

Display Analysis

  • 6.5-inch flat 90Hz LCD display
  • Only 720p resolution - pixels visible
  • Poor brightness levels
  • Bad viewing angles when off-axis
  • Thicker bezels, especially chin
  • Light falloff around hole punch camera
  • Adequate for basic tasks: texting, web browsing, navigation, social media

Build Quality & Design

  • Large plastic construction
  • Layout: ports/speakers at bottom, headphone jack at top
  • Expandable storage alongside SIM card tray
  • Fast fingerprint reader in classic Motorola dimple spot
  • No bending or creaking issues
  • Plastic more durable than glass when dropped
  • Lighter weight benefit for large phone
  • IP52 water resistance (not waterproof)

Battery Performance

  • 5,000mAh battery with 720p display = excellent battery life
  • 1.5 days regular use, 2 light days easily
  • 7 hours screen-on time
  • Only 10W charging (slow)
  • No wireless charging
  • Overnight charging sufficient

Software Experience

  • Near-stock Android with Moto features
  • Similar to $1,000 Flagship Edge phone experience
  • Pixel-like feel in quick settings/notifications
  • Motorola widgets and extra settings
  • Moto app with gesture features:
    • Double chop for flashlight
    • Three finger screenshot
    • Peak display for notifications
    • Fingerprint reader swipe for notification panel
  • Missing: double twist camera launch (due to poor camera)

Camera System

  • Triple camera layout (premium appearance)
  • Main: 16MP camera
  • Top: 2MP macro camera
  • Bottom: 2MP depth camera for portraits
  • Functional for basic photography with adequate light
  • 1080P video recording
  • Portrait mode uses depth camera but produces terrible zigzag cutouts
  • Won't win comparison tests but adequate for documentation

Performance Issues (Major Catch)

  • MediaTek Helio G37 chipset
  • 3GB RAM
  • Other phones with same chip: Techno Spark 9, Infinix Hot 12, Honor X7A (all under $150)
  • Geekbench scores dramatically lower than iPhone 14
  • Extremely slow performance across all tasks:
    • Slow UI scrolling and navigation
    • 90Hz display rarely achieves 60Hz due to stuttering
    • Slow app launches (including Settings app)
    • Slow unlock times
    • Slow photo capture
    • Slow typing and browsing
  • Possibly slowest phone reviewer has used
  • High-end gaming/photo editing not viable

Budget vs Used Flagship Comparison

Moto G Play 2023 ($169 new)

  • Slow MediaTek Helio G37, 3GB RAM
  • 720p 90Hz LCD (rarely hits refresh rate)
  • Plastic build
  • Basic camera system
  • Future software updates advantage

OnePlus 7 Pro (under $200 used)

  • Originally $669 in 2019
  • Snapdragon 855 (much faster despite age)
  • Better performance profile, faster storage, more RAM
  • Superior OLED screen (sharper, brighter, consistent 90Hz)
  • More built-in storage (not expandable)
  • Better camera system (primary + ultrawide + zoom)
  • Glass construction (premium feel)
  • 4,000mAh battery (comparable)
  • 30W Warp charging vs 10W

Software Updates Consideration

  • New budget phones get longer future support
  • Flagship phones lose advantage after 3+ years
  • OnePlus 7 Pro likely done with updates
  • Moto G Play has few updates remaining
  • Samsung A14 5G (similar specs/price) likely better update support than Moto

Environmental Impact

  • Used flagships better for environment
  • Extended device lifespan reduces e-waste
  • Less new manufacturing demand

Price Point Recommendations

  • $169: Definitely choose used flagship over new budget
  • $200: Many good used flagships available (OnePlus 7 Pro, Pixel 5)
  • $400: More debatable, some advantages still favor used flagship
  • $600: New phones competitive, software update advantage matters (Pixel 7 example)

Final Verdict

  • At $169 price point: "prehistoric premium over presently pleasantly priced"
  • Performance too compromised for acceptable user experience
  • Used flagship phones offer dramatically better value at similar prices

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome