AI summary by TwinMind
Three strange river crossings
Tom Scott
8m 11s
Manchester Ship Canal Overview
- Canal runs nearly 60 kilometers from Mersey estuary near Liverpool to Manchester
- Over century old, massive engineering achievement
- 1885 Act of Parliament included 300 pages technical legal requirements
- Requirements included maintaining access, paying fees, providing ferries
- Many legal details still apply today
- Peel Group owns entire canal and major Manchester area infrastructure
Humes Ferry
- First of three crossings visited
- Legal requirement from 1885: "ferry by night and by day whenever required"
- Replaced low bridge knocked down for canal construction
- Hour's walk to alternative crossing
- Not practical for 21st century use - quicker to drive for most purposes
- Regular passengers exist but not many
- Mostly walkers and cyclists for recreation
- Runs only 3-4 days per week, few hours each day
- Never operates in winter
- Stopped running for year in 2010, required campaign to reinstate
- No official website, "use it or lose it" policy
- Author's crossing was logged and counted
Fell Wall Ferry (or Tel Wall)
- Second crossing, few kilometers west of Humes
- 11 pence charge
- No engine - powered by man rowing across
- Operating for 120+ years (not same man or boat)
- Service suspended during visit due to low water levels
- Author noted water levels looked fine
- Legal requirement: company "shall work the said ferry whenever required"
- About 600 crossings per year
- Some days barely anyone, other days whole walking clubs
- Runs most days but only few hours
- Apparently doesn't run when water low
Warburton Toll Bridge
- Third crossing between the two ferries
- 12 pence car toll or 25 pence day pass
- Often queues, cash only, no change given
- Toll collector with barrier system
- Author experienced no charges one direction, 20 pence charged return
- No day passes available during visit
- Original 1885 law: "two shillings and sixpence" for non-animal powered vehicles
- Inflation-adjusted would be ~15 pounds today
- Law didn't mention inflation
- Company can waive tolls (did during COVID lockdown)
- Difficult to reinstate tolls once stopped long-term
- One car each direction every 30 seconds average
- Generates ~quarter million pounds revenue annually
Legal Interpretation Analysis
- "Whenever required" has two possible interpretations:
- Literal: ferry must be available any hour any day
- Practical: only if reasonable demand exists
- Historical interpretation follows practical approach
- Other ferries mentioned in original laws have disappeared
- No government action likely due to minimal usage
- Legal removal process unclear
Corporate Economics Perspective
- Minor cost for multi-billion pound Peel Group
- More effort to stop services than maintain them
- Avoiding angry locals and bad press
- Toll increase would require law change - time-consuming and expensive
- Company has bigger priorities
- Similar to personal life - tolerating minor irritations vs fixing them
Future Changes
- Bridge needs expensive refurbishment/replacement soon
- Consultation process held last month
- Company wants to raise toll to 1 pound
- Plans to replace ticket booths with automatic systems
- Law change probably coming soon
- Author hopes locals ensure ferry removal never becomes easy option
