AI summary by TwinMind
TikTok made an IDE and it's actually good? (free cursor killer??)
Theo - t3․gg
14m 43s
Initial Introduction to Trey
- New VS Code competitor from ByteDance/TikTok, not VC-funded startup or open source clone
- Named "Trey", currently free (pricing/TikTok ban implications unknown)
- Fresh installation/setup experience being documented live
Sponsor Segment - Browser Base & Stage Hand
- Stage Hand: open source package for Playwright automation
- Eliminates brittle element targeting - uses AI prompts instead of specific IDs
- Can extract data matching Zod schemas
- Browser Base: hosted Chromium/Playwright solution
- Comparison showing Stage Hand requires less code than traditional Playwright
Trey Website & Features Overview
- Tagline: "adaptable AI IDE that transforms how you work"
- Key features:
- Automatic agent selection for tasks (no manual model switching)
- Builder mode: breaks down/executes tasks automatically with preview/control
- Image upload for requirement clarification
- Full context awareness (file selection)
- Smart completion
- Currently free, likely to charge eventually
- Import from Cursor functionality available
Installation & Initial Setup
- Smooth installation process
- Dark mode, English language selection
- Login required for AI features
- VS Code-based architecture confirmed (extensions visible)
UI/UX Evaluation
- Significantly better visual design than other VS Code clones
- Better screen real estate usage than standard VS Code
- Proper file disambiguation (shows path context for same-named files)
- UI resembles JetBrains Fleet (not IntelliJ)
- Clean separation of interface sections
- No immediate UI quirks or annoyances
AI Capabilities Testing
Model Options
- Only Claude Sonnet 3.5 and GPT-4 available
- No Chinese models (DeepSeek) despite ByteDance ownership
- Claude Sonnet expensive (~$0.30 minimum per request)
Complex Image Analysis Task
- Challenge: analyze uploaded image, detect most common border color, use as background
- Multi-step agentic approach (plan then execute)
- Successfully completed on first attempt (other AI tools failed this task)
- Generated quality code:
- Canvas-based image rendering
- Edge pixel collection algorithm
- Color frequency analysis
- Proper implementation with minor type errors
UI Cloning Task
- Challenge: create AI chatbot page mimicking T3 chat UI
- Used mock data, no backend specified
- Correctly identified file structure (demo route)
- Automatic Tailwind CSS usage
- Generated custom SVGs (search, link icons)
- One-shot success with high-quality output
- Impressive visual fidelity to target design
Performance & Cost Considerations
- Occasional generation failures (possible rate limiting)
- Free Claude Sonnet access concerning given high API costs
- Potential financial unsustainability of free tier
- Generation speed moderate but acceptable
Security & Privacy Concerns
- ByteDance ownership raises data privacy questions
- Not recommended for production codebases with sensitive information
- T3 chat example avoided due to secrets/proprietary code
Competitive Assessment
- First genuine Cursor competitor encountered
- Quality comparable to established tools
- Smooth user experience without typical VS Code fork issues
- Command palette (Cmd+K) functionality present
- Stable keyboard shortcuts (unlike Windsurf issues)
Final Verdict
- Genuinely impressive tool, not just "okay" but high quality
- Recommended for users hesitant about AI tool costs
- Solid option while free tier available
- Worth monitoring for future development
- Represents meaningful improvement in AI-assisted development experience
