AI summary by TwinMind
Time has 3 dimensions and that explains particle masses, physicist claims
Sabine Hossenfelder
5m 9s
Personal Background and Initial Reaction
- Speaker had same idea as undergraduate: three time dimensions to match three space dimensions
- Initially believed physics worked by following "pretty ideas"
- Learned proper physics and realized idea is nonsense
Fundamental Physics Problems with Three Time Dimensions
- Newton's law and Coulomb's law: gravitational/electric force drops with 1/r²
- Force lines spread in all directions of space
- In 3D space, directions scale with sphere surface (r²)
- In 4D space, Newton's law would go with 1/r³
- Can use force line spread or random particle movement to infer space dimension
- Called "spectral dimension"
- Usually same as normal Hausdorff dimension (orthogonal vectors)
- Advantage: works for non-integer/fractal dimensions
- Forces don't dilute in time → time has only one dimension
- Proponents must make extra assumptions that two of three time dimensions don't work like the third
- "Sweeping problems under the rug"
Recent Paper Analysis
- Press release about single author paper in low-quality journal
- Author claims ability to reproduce standard model particle masses
- Multiple fundamental errors identified:
- Normalizes wave function to one in spacetime with three time dimensions
- Wave functions normalized to one in space (probability to find particle somewhere must sum to one)
- Stays one at all times, not normalized in time
- Conservation laws are "uncontracted" and don't conserve anything
- Doesn't understand Lorentz invariance
- Pulls numbers from nowhere
- Thinks graviton propagator is scalar
- Claims 6D spacetime naturally reduces to standard Minkowski spacetime when two temporal dimensions become "negligible"
- "What does it mean for temporal dimension to become negligible?"
- Mathematical rubbish
- Normalizes wave function to one in spacetime with three time dimensions
Publication and Media Response
- Author contacted university PR office
- Press release distributed widely
- Paper described as "complete nonsense" that "should never have been published"
- Majority of physics colleagues can identify problems "at one glance"
Personal Reflection on Criticism
- Dislikes criticizing others' work
- Author put effort into paper and likely proud of it
- Feels bad about criticism but believes someone must address misinformation
- Suggests author should take physics courses before attempting physics research
- Kinder approach would be ignoring such work
- Questions whether people understand how physics actually works
